UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Lawsuit 2026, Why UnitedHealth Group Sued CMS in Georgia and What It Means for Seniors
UnitedHealth Group, the parent company of UnitedHealthcare and the largest Medicare Advantage insurer in the country, sued the federal government on November 19, 2026. It claims the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) used unlawful calculations to lower the 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings of dozens of its plans. The case was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Georgia in Brunswick.
The complaint challenges 26 quality measures across 51 contracts, including 45 with published 2027 ratings. UnitedHealth says the ratings could cut federal bonus payments and eventually affect premiums and dental, vision and other benefits for millions of seniors.
For current members, the lawsuit does not cancel coverage or automatically cut 2027 benefits. The disputed 2027 ratings mainly affect federal bonus payments for 2028. There is no consumer settlement, claim form or payout fund, because UnitedHealth is the plaintiff suing the government. Medicare’s Annual Open Enrollment ends December 7, 2026, so members should review their own 2027 plan now.
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Lawsuit Quick Facts
| Detail | Information |
| Case | UnitedHealth Group Inc. et al. v. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services et al. |
| Filed | November 19, 2026 |
| Court | U.S. District Court, Southern District of Georgia, Brunswick Division |
| Case number | 2:26-cv-00131-LGW-BWC |
| Judge | U.S. District Judge Lisa Godbey Wood |
| Plaintiffs | UnitedHealth Group and 19 affiliated companies |
| Defendants | CMS and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services |
| Ratings challenged | 2027 Medicare Advantage Star Ratings (published October 8, 2026) |
| Disputed measures | 26 |
| Contracts involved | 51, including 45 with published ratings |
| Members in 35 contracts below 4 stars | About 2.9 million, per UnitedHealth |
| Main legal issue | Whether CMS followed Medicare law in adopting and applying the measures |
| Financial effect | Quality bonus payments and plan funding for 2028 |
| Status | Active; no ruling on UnitedHealth’s claims |
| Settlement or consumer claim form | None |
What Are Medicare Advantage Star Ratings and Why Do They Matter?
CMS grades Medicare Advantage plans from 1 to 5 stars on measures such as preventive screenings, chronic-illness care, prescription refills, customer service, complaints and appeals, and member experience. The ratings appear on Medicare.gov so seniors can compare plans.
They also drive money. Plans rated 4 stars or higher can qualify for federal quality bonus payments. Insurers use that funding, along with rebates, to pay for extras such as lower premiums, dental, vision, hearing and over-the-counter allowances. A 3.5-star contract generally misses the bonus tier that a 4-star contract receives, which is why a half-star swing is worth so much.
Why Did UnitedHealthcare Sue CMS Over the 2027 Star Ratings?
UnitedHealth says its problem is not just disappointing scores. It argues CMS used rules and data it was not legally authorized to use. The complaint names two main legal problems.
Did CMS Skip Required Public Rulemaking Under 42 U.S.C. § 1395hh(a)(2)?
UnitedHealth argues CMS adopted the detailed instructions behind the 26 measures without the notice-and-comment process Medicare law requires. Those instructions decide which patients count toward a score, which services qualify, what is excluded and how results are calculated. CMS says changes to the broader 2027 methodology went through earlier public rulemaking. The lawsuit disputes whether that was enough for the specific measures challenged.
Did CMS Use Data Outside Its Authority Under 42 U.S.C. § 1395w-23(o)?
UnitedHealth claims eight of the 26 measures relied on information the statute does not authorize for star-rating calculations, including some drug-safety measures on combinations such as opioids and benzodiazepines. It is not arguing medication safety is unimportant. It says Congress limited the data CMS may use for these payment calculations.
These are UnitedHealth’s allegations. The complaint does not establish that CMS broke the law. CMS declined to comment.
Related article: Howard Hanna $395 Transaction Fee Lawsuit 2026, Can Pennsylvania Homebuyers Get a Refund?

How Many UnitedHealthcare Plans Could Gain Stars if the Court Agrees?
According to the complaint, removing the 26 disputed measures would raise ratings as follows:
| Claimed increase | Contracts |
| 1.5 stars | 10 |
| 1 star | 30 |
| 0.5 star | 5 |
| Total rated contracts | 45 |
UnitedHealth says 35 contracts now below four stars would reach at least four stars. Those contracts serve about 2.9 million members. It also says 43 contracts would qualify for a higher share of rebate payments, and six new contracts without their own ratings depend partly on other contracts’ ratings. These figures are UnitedHealth’s calculations and have not been approved by the court.
Contract H5322 is an example. UnitedHealth says it serves about 218,576 members, including about 96,521 in Georgia, and that its 3.5-star rating would rise to 4.5 stars without the contested measures.
Will UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Members Lose Benefits in 2027?
No. The lawsuit does not automatically reduce anyone’s 2027 benefits. CMS published the 2027 ratings on October 8, 2026, and they mainly affect bonus payments for 2028. UnitedHealth argues lower payments could eventually mean higher premiums, smaller supplemental benefits or less generous plans, but no such change has been announced for every plan. Benefits vary by contract and county, so your plan documents control. See Medicare Advantage 2027 Changes, Plan Cuts, December 7 Enrollment Deadline, Premiums and Part D Costs.
The lawsuit covers particular insurance contracts, not every product sold under the UnitedHealthcare name. Check your plan’s rating on Medicare Plan Finder.
How Do Star Ratings Change Rebates for Medicare Advantage Plans?
| Star rating | Rebate percentage |
| 3 stars or lower | 50% |
| 3.5 or 4 stars | 65% |
| 4.5 or 5 stars | 70% |
These percentages describe how Medicare calculates certain payments to insurers. They are not cash rebates sent to members. A win would not guarantee any member a lower premium or bigger dental allowance, because plan benefits still need CMS approval.
What Was the French Mystery-Shopper Call in UnitedHealth’s Earlier CMS Lawsuit?
This is background from UnitedHealth’s separate 2024 lawsuit over its 2025 ratings, not part of the November 2026 complaint. In that case, a CMS test caller placed a call in French that was marked as a failure. A federal judge in the Eastern District of Texas (Judge Jeremy Kernodle) ruled in November 2024 that CMS must recalculate UnitedHealth’s 2025 ratings without that call. UnitedHealth later said the government dropped its appeal. The earlier case shows that star-rating disputes have gone to court before and that results depend on the specific legal issue.
Why Does the Clover Insurance Company Ruling Matter in the UnitedHealth Case?
UnitedHealth relies on Clover Insurance Company v. Department of Health and Human Services, No. 2:25-cv-142 (S.D. Ga.). In that case Judge Wood ruled on May 27, 2026 that CMS improperly used 20 measures for Clover’s 2026 rating. CMS recalculated Clover’s rating from 3.5 to 4.5 stars. CMS also announced on June 17, 2026 that it would voluntarily recalculate 2027 Quality Bonus Payment ratings in light of that ruling.
UnitedHealth says CMS still used 14 of the same measures in its 2027 ratings. The Clover ruling does not decide UnitedHealth’s case. CMS appealed, and according to UnitedHealth’s complaint, oral argument is set for January 21, 2027.
Why Brunswick, Georgia, and Which Other Insurers Have Sued Over Star Ratings?
UnitedHealth’s case went to Judge Wood, who is also hearing a suit CVS Health filed in October. Humana, Elevance Health, SCAN Health Plan and others have also challenged CMS ratings. Press reports count more than a dozen suits over the 2027 ratings, and UnitedHealth is at least the 15th by one count. The cases differ, so a win for one insurer does not decide another’s. For background, see Humana Loses BILLIONS, Humana Medicare Advantage Ratings Lawsuit, Judge Crushes Medicare Lawsuit TWICE—Millions of Seniors at Risk.
Which Federal Laws Apply to the UnitedHealth v. CMS Star Ratings Case?
- 42 U.S.C. § 1395hh(a)(2): public rulemaking for certain Medicare policies.
- 42 U.S.C. § 1395w-23(o): Medicare Advantage quality ratings and bonus payments.
- 42 U.S.C. § 1395w-22(e): quality and performance information for Medicare Advantage plans.
- 5 U.S.C. § 706 (Administrative Procedure Act): lets courts set aside unlawful agency action.
- 42 C.F.R. §§ 422.164 and 423.184: star-rating regulations.
The case is not a criminal prosecution, malpractice claim or claim of misconduct by doctors.
What Does UnitedHealth Want the Federal Judge to Order?
UnitedHealth asks the court to declare the disputed uses of the measures unlawful and to order CMS to recalculate affected 2027 ratings without them, with corrected ratings applied to future payment calculations and 2028 benefit review. It is not seeking damages for beneficiaries or a consumer fund.
What Happens Next in UnitedHealth Group v. CMS?
Both sides may brief the agency’s authority, the measures and whether to recalculate. Dates to watch: the January 21, 2027 Clover appeal argument, CMS’s April 5, 2027 payment-rate announcement and the June 7, 2027 deadline for insurers’ proposed 2028 benefit packages. None guarantees a final decision in UnitedHealth’s case.
What Should UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Members Do Before December 7, 2026?
Annual Open Enrollment runs October 15 through December 7, 2026, and elections generally take effect January 1, 2027.
- Do not wait for the lawsuit. Court fights take months and mostly affect payments to insurers. Choose your plan from today’s published benefits.
- Read your Annual Notice of Change for 2027 costs, coverage and terms.
- Check your doctors, specialists and hospitals for 2027 network status.
- Compare drug costs: formulary, copays and pharmacy rules.
- Check the maximum out-of-pocket limit in case of a major hospital stay.
- Review dental, vision, hearing and transportation benefits for allowances and limits.
- Look beyond the star number to your own medical needs.
- Compare plans by ZIP code at Medicare.gov/plan-compare or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227).
People already in Medicare Advantage can usually make one change during the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period, January 1 through March 31, 2027. Switching to Original Medicare can affect drug coverage and Medigap eligibility, so check those rules first. State Health Insurance Assistance Programs offer free counseling.
Can UnitedHealthcare Members File a Claim or Join a Class Action Over the Star Ratings Lawsuit?
No. Beneficiaries are not plaintiffs, and there is no settlement amount, compensation fund, claims administrator or payment deadline. This is different from lawsuits over denied claims, such as AARP UnitedHealthcare Class Action, Seniors Say Medigap Claims Were Denied Using a Made-Up Condition, which involves Medicare Supplement denials and different claims.
What If UnitedHealthcare Denies Care You Need?
Do not wait for this case. Medicare has a separate appeals process. The denial notice explains the reason and how to appeal. See Medicare.gov, Filing an Appeal.
UnitedHealthcare Star Ratings Lawsuit Frequently Asked Questions
Did UnitedHealthcare lose its Medicare Advantage star ratings?
Some contracts received lower ratings than UnitedHealth believes they deserve. The suit seeks recalculation. It does not mean every plan lost its rating.
Why is UnitedHealthcare suing the federal government?
It claims CMS used 26 measures in ways that violate rulemaking requirements or limits on data sources.
Is UnitedHealthcare leaving Medicare Advantage in 2027?
No. The suit does not mean a nationwide withdrawal, though plan availability can change by county for other reasons.
Will my UnitedHealthcare premium go up?
The lawsuit does not establish that. Check your 2027 plan documents.
Could UnitedHealth win?
Possibly. The Clover ruling supports part of its argument, but it is on appeal and UnitedHealth must prove its own claims.
Will members receive settlement checks?
No. The case concerns ratings and payments to insurers.
Are the published 2027 ratings still valid?
Yes, unless CMS revises them or a court orders changes.
The Bottom Line on the UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage Star Ratings Lawsuit
UnitedHealth Group’s November 19, 2026 suit challenges how CMS calculated 2027 star ratings, with about 2.9 million members in 35 contracts at stake in the company’s math. It does not cancel current coverage, force 2027 benefit cuts or create compensation for patients. The deadline that matters now is December 7, 2026. Compare your real 2027 options before it passes. The case is active and its outcome is not determined.
Official Sources for the UnitedHealth Group v. CMS Star Ratings Lawsuit
- UnitedHealth Group v. CMS, Federal Complaint, November 19, 2026 (PDF)
- Georgetown Law, UnitedHealth Group v. CMS Case Record
- CMS, 2027 Medicare Advantage and Part D Star Ratings
- Medicare.gov, Open Enrollment Rules
- Medicare.gov, Medicare Coverage Appeals
- Medicare.gov, Compare Health and Drug Plans
Disclaimer: General legal and Medicare information, not legal, financial or insurance advice.
Researched and written by Israr Ahmad, legal content researcher and founder of AllAboutLawyer.com. All facts verified against the federal complaint as published by the Georgetown Law Health Care Litigation Tracker, CMS and Medicare.gov guidance, and STAT and Law360 reporting, as of November 22, 2026. Last Updated: November 22, 2026.
About the Author
Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.
