|

Howard Hanna $395 Transaction Fee Lawsuit 2026, Can Pennsylvania Homebuyers Get a Refund?

Howard Hanna Real Estate Services faces a new putative class action in Pennsylvania state court over a $395 “Realtor Transaction Fee” allegedly charged to a homebuyer at closing. The complaint was reported as filed on November 10, 2026, in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas, and the plaintiff alleges the fee was an unearned add-on to a seller-funded commission.

The plaintiff, Pittsburgh first-time buyer Dena M. Bergamasco, says she paid the fee when she bought a $217,000 home in October 2021. The $395 was about half of the $788.95 in cash she brought to closing. The suit alleges breach of fiduciary duty and violations of Pennsylvania’s Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL), and it seeks class treatment, damages (including treble and punitive damages), repayment of collected fees and an injunction. Howard Hanna disputes the allegations and says its practices comply with the law.

No class has been certified, no settlement has been announced, and there is no claim form or settlement fund today. This is also not Howard Hanna’s older, court-approved commission settlement, whose claim deadline was December 30, 2025.

Howard Hanna $395 Transaction Fee Lawsuit Quick Facts

DetailInformation
CaseBergamasco v. Howard Hanna
FiledReported November 10, 2026 (Law360 reported it November 12)
CourtAllegheny County Court of Common Pleas, Pennsylvania
PlaintiffDena M. Bergamasco
DefendantHoward Hanna Real Estate Services
Disputed fee$395 “Realtor Transaction Fee”
Home purchase$217,000, October 2021, Pittsburgh
ClaimsBreach of fiduciary duty; UTPCPL violations
Proposed classQualifying Pennsylvania buyers who paid a fixed brokerage fee on top of a seller-funded commission
StatusPending putative class action; no class certified
Settlement or claim deadlineNone
Separate settlement site (different case)Official Real Estate Commission Settlement Website

The state-court docket number has not been independently verified. Details reflect reported coverage of the complaint and should be checked against the Allegheny County court record.

Why Is Howard Hanna Being Sued Over a $395 Closing Fee?

The question is whether a brokerage can collect an extra fixed fee from a buyer after it has already been paid a seller-funded commission. The complaint alleges that Howard Hanna received the buyer-broker commission from the seller, then charged Bergamasco another $395 without identifying a separate service. It also alleges that agents were instructed to include the fee in buyer transactions and to describe it as mandatory. Press coverage describes the claims as a “junk fee” challenge.

An additional brokerage fee is not automatically illegal. The dispute is whether this fee was properly agreed to, accurately described and collected consistently with Pennsylvania law.

What Happened in the Bergamasco Home Purchase?

Purchase detailReported amount
Home price$217,000
Primary mortgage$213,069
Second loan$10,850
Seller credit toward closing costs$7,300
Cash brought to closing$788.95
Howard Hanna transaction fee$395

Where Did the $395 Fee Appear on the Closing Disclosure?

According to the complaint, the fee appeared on her Closing Disclosure between a pest inspection charge and an owner’s title insurance premium, in the “Other” charges section (12 C.F.R. § 1026.38). The plaintiff argues that placing it among ordinary closing costs made a brokerage add-on look like a standard or required settlement charge. A fee’s appearance on a Closing Disclosure does not by itself show the buyer agreed to it or that it was lawfully collected.

What Does Howard Hanna Say About the Transaction Fee Lawsuit?

Howard Hanna told Real Estate News it is committed to transparency about its compensation and that its practices comply with the law. It has not been found liable. The court may need to review the buyer’s agreements, fee disclosures and the brokerage’s fee practices.

Who Could Be Included in the Howard Hanna Putative Class Action?

The suit seeks to represent buyers who:

  1. Bought residential property in Pennsylvania
  2. Were represented by Howard Hanna
  3. Paid a flat-dollar fee (called “Transaction Fee,” “Realtor Transaction Fee” or similar) at closing
  4. Paid it in addition to a commission Howard Hanna received from the seller or seller’s broker
  5. Closed within a period the court ultimately allows

The class period has not been set. The suit was filed in Allegheny County, but the proposed class is not limited to Pittsburgh, and eligibility elsewhere in Pennsylvania depends on the final class definition. Buyers outside Pennsylvania are not automatically included, because states have different broker and consumer protection rules. A fee of a different amount, such as $495, may or may not fit.

Related article: Illinois HOA Fence Lawsuit 2026, Why Ashford Farms Homeowners Lost Their Security Fence Appeal Despite Trespassing Concerns

Howard Hanna $395 Transaction Fee Lawsuit 2026, Can Pennsylvania Homebuyers Get a Refund?

Is Howard Hanna’s $395 Realtor Transaction Fee Illegal Under Pennsylvania Law?

Not necessarily. Pennsylvania real estate regulations set rules on written agreements, fee descriptions and honest dealing:

  • 49 Pa. Code § 35.281: agreements requiring a consumer to pay a broker a fee or commission generally must be in writing.
  • 49 Pa. Code § 35.331: covered written brokerage agreements must identify the services provided and the fees charged.
  • 49 Pa. Code § 35.292: licensees must deal honestly and in good faith with consumers.
  • 49 Pa. Code § 35.313: a buyer’s agent must act loyally toward the buyer, even when the seller pays the commission.
  • 49 Pa. Code § 35.334: brokers must give written estimates of reasonably foreseeable closing costs before the agreement of sale is signed.

Whether a contract met these rules requires reviewing the actual documents.

How Does the Pennsylvania UTPCPL Apply to the Howard Hanna Lawsuit?

The suit invokes the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, 73 P.S. § 201-1 et seq., including 73 P.S. § 201-2(4) (misleading or deceptive practices). Under 73 P.S. § 201-9.2, a consumer who proves a violation and a resulting loss may seek actual damages or $100, whichever is greater, attorney fees and, in a court’s discretion, up to three times actual damages.

Does Federal Law Like RESPA Section 8(b) Apply to the Howard Hanna Fee?

Possibly as background, but the reported complaint is mainly about Pennsylvania law and fiduciary duty. The Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act restricts unearned fees under 12 U.S.C. § 2607(b), but a flat fee alone does not establish a RESPA violation. Federal TRID rules require lenders to deliver the Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing, and the CFPB advises buyers to compare it with their Loan Estimate. A properly listed fee is not automatically lawful under state law. For a separate RESPA example, see Zillow RESPA Lawsuit, Were You Affected? — Taylor v. Zillow, No. 2:25-cv-01818.

Can Pennsylvania Homebuyers Recover $395 or More From Howard Hanna?

Possibly, but nothing is approved or guaranteed. The plaintiff seeks repayment of fees, damages, attorney fees and an injunction.

Possible theoryIllustration
Repayment of the fee$395
Three times a proven $395 loss$1,185
Attorney fees and other reliefUp to the court

The $1,185 figure is only a mathematical illustration of a possible legal remedy, not an expected payout. A court could reject the claims or award something different.

How Can You Check Whether Howard Hanna Charged You a Transaction Fee?

  1. Find your closing paperwork: Closing Disclosure, HUD-1, ALTA Settlement Statement or Buyer Closing Statement, from your lender, closing attorney or title company.
  2. Look for brokerage charges labeled “Realtor Transaction Fee,” “Broker Fee,” “Administrative Fee,” “Processing Fee” or “Compliance Fee.” A label alone does not make a fee improper.
  3. Compare with your buyer agency agreement: was the fee, its amount and its services disclosed and signed?
  4. Check who paid the commission (seller, listing broker or you).
  5. Save everything: agreement, closing documents, payment records and emails about fees. Do not send mortgage or identity documents to unsolicited “claim” websites.

How Can Homebuyers Avoid or Negotiate Broker Transaction Fees Before Closing?

  • Before signing a buyer representation agreement, look for any flat fee on top of the percentage commission and ask in writing for it to be removed. Broker compensation is negotiable.
  • Check your Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing, especially the “Other” section between title, inspection and HOA charges. If a brokerage fee appears that you did not agree to in writing, or were told was legally required, ask the managing broker to remove it before closing.
  • Keep your Closing Disclosure, signed agency contract and any emails or texts with your agent so an attorney can evaluate your rights if you already closed.

What Can You Do if You Think Howard Hanna Overcharged You?

Ask the brokerage in writing to explain the fee and the agreement authorizing it. Pennsylvania residents can file a consumer complaint with the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General or report licensee misconduct to the Pennsylvania Department of State. A complaint does not guarantee reimbursement. For money damages, consider a Pennsylvania consumer protection or real estate attorney. Deadlines depend on the claim and when you discovered the injury, so do not assume a 2021 purchase is still eligible.

How Is This Different From the Earlier Howard Hanna Commission Settlement?

Howard Hanna’s older settlement resolved federal antitrust claims by home sellers over inflated commissions, part of a multi-brokerage resolution of more than $42 million, with Hanna Holdings reportedly paying about $32 million. The court granted final approval on February 5, 2026, the Eighth Circuit affirmed on August 19, 2026, and the claim deadline was December 30, 2025.

IssueOlder commission settlementNew $395 lawsuit
ConcernAllegedly inflated broker commissionsAllegedly improper fixed transaction fee
PeopleQualifying home sellersProposed Pennsylvania homebuyer class
Legal focusFederal antitrustPennsylvania consumer protection and broker duties
SettlementApprovedNone
Claim formDeadline passedNone

Whether the older release affects a particular claim requires reading the release. See 8th Circuit Upholds $1 Billion-Plus NAR Real Estate Commission Settlement, Rejects Class Member Objections.

Are Other Brokerages Facing Transaction Fee Lawsuits?

Yes. In October 2026, homebuyer Gregory Deivert sued Keller Williams Elite in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania over an alleged $650 broker fee, seeking class status. A putative class action against Compass over a $475 fee was voluntarily dismissed. These cases do not show that all brokerages act unlawfully. Each involves different facts. For a different buyer-commission settlement, see NAR $120.3M Homebuyer Commission Settlement, How to File Your Claim by October 27, 2026. That deadline has passed.

Did the 2024 NAR Rules Change Apply to the Bergamasco Purchase?

On August 17, 2024, NAR practice changes took effect requiring many buyer agents to sign written agreements with defined compensation before touring homes. Bergamasco bought in October 2021, so her claims are judged under the rules and agreements in effect then.

What Happens Next in the Howard Hanna Transaction Fee Lawsuit?

The case is early. The court must decide whether to certify a class, Howard Hanna may raise defenses such as signed agreements and filing deadlines, and evidence may include brokerage agreements, internal fee policies and disclosures. A settlement, dismissal or trial are all possible. As of November 22, 2026, no verified settlement, certified class or payment program exists.

Howard Hanna $395 Transaction Fee Lawsuit Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get my $395 Howard Hanna fee refunded?

Not automatically. A refund could come only from a court award, a settlement or an individual resolution.

Is there a Howard Hanna class action settlement in 2026?

A separate commission settlement was approved earlier. The $395 case has no settlement.

Is a Howard Hanna transaction fee illegal in Pennsylvania?

Not automatically. Agreed, properly disclosed fees can be lawful.

Do I need to file a claim form?

No claim form exists for this case. Keep your records and watch the court docket.

What if I bought a home outside Pennsylvania?

The current proposed class is Pennsylvania-focused.

Bottom Line: What Pennsylvania Homebuyers Should Know About the Howard Hanna Lawsuit

The suit asks whether a brokerage can charge a buyer an extra fixed fee after receiving a seller-funded commission. The answer depends on the agreement, the disclosure, the fee’s purpose and Pennsylvania law. For now this is a putative class action, not a proven violation or approved settlement. Check your closing documents, compare them with your signed agreement and save your records.

Official Sources for the Howard Hanna Transaction Fee Lawsuit

  1. 49 Pa. Code § 35.281
  2. 49 Pa. Code § 35.331
  3. 49 Pa. Code § 35.334
  4. Pennsylvania Attorney General, Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (PDF)
  5. CFPB, Closing Disclosure Guide
  6. Pennsylvania Attorney General, Consumer Complaint Form
  7. Allegheny County, Civil and Family Court Records
  8. Official Real Estate Commission Settlement Website (separate Howard Hanna settlement)

Disclaimer: General legal information, not legal advice. Allegations are disputed unless established by a court.

Researched and written by Israr Ahmad, legal content researcher and founder of AllAboutLawyer.com. All facts verified against Pennsylvania regulations and statutes, CFPB guidance, the official commission settlement website and Law360 and Real Estate News reporting, as of November 22, 2026. Last Updated: November 22, 2026.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *