|

Is Kalshi Legal in Maryland? Federal Appeals Court Allows State Gambling Enforcement to Proceed

A divided federal appeals court has refused to stop Maryland gambling regulators from taking action against Kalshi’s sports prediction-market contracts. The Fourth Circuit’s published opinion, dated November 18, 2026, affirmed a lower court’s denial of a preliminary injunction by a 2-1 vote. Some outlets reported the decision as coming Tuesday, November 17, but the court’s opinion lists November 18 as the decision date.

The short answer: the ruling means Maryland is not blocked, for now, from enforcing its sports wagering laws against Kalshi’s sports event contracts. It does not ban Kalshi nationwide, it does not decide every state’s authority, and it is not a final ruling on the merits. It is also a regulatory dispute between a company and a state, not a class action or a settlement.

Quick Facts

QuestionWhat the record shows
CaseKalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892 (4th Cir.)
Decision dateNovember 18, 2026 (argued May 7, 2026)
ResultAffirmed denial of preliminary injunction, 2-1
PanelJudges Gregory, Thacker and Benjamin
Lower courtU.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (Judge Adam B. Abelson)
Who suedKalshi, a CFTC-designated contract market
DefendantsMaryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency and Commission, the Maryland Attorney General and gaming officials, in their official capacities
Core issueWhether federal commodities law preempts Maryland’s sports wagering laws as applied to Kalshi’s sports contracts
Final ruling on the merits?No
Nationwide ban?No
Class action or settlement?No

What Did the Court Actually Decide?

The court’s formal opinion is one sentence long: the judgment of the district court is affirmed. That affirmance was a published per curiam opinion, joined by Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker. Each of them wrote a separate concurrence, and Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented.

What was affirmed is narrow. Kalshi asked for a preliminary injunction, which is a temporary court order that would have barred Maryland from enforcing its sports wagering laws against Kalshi while the case continued. To get one, a plaintiff has to show, among other things, that it is likely to win on the merits. The lower court said Kalshi had not shown that, and the Fourth Circuit let that denial stand.

Because the affirmance only concerns the preliminary injunction, Maryland’s underlying case remains before the district court, and Kalshi could still prevail later on the merits.

The Question Behind the Case

Kalshi runs an exchange regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), where users trade contracts tied to future events, including sports outcomes. Maryland says those sports contracts are sports wagering and need a state license. Kalshi says federal law gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction, so Maryland’s law is preempted, meaning federal law overrides it.

The Commodity Exchange Act gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over “swaps” traded on a designated contract market (7 U.S.C. § 2(a)(1)(A)). So there are two steps. First, are Kalshi’s sports contracts swaps? Second, if so, does that exclusive jurisdiction displace Maryland’s traditional power to regulate gambling?

The Act also has a separate “Special Rule” (7 U.S.C. § 7a-2(c)(5)(C)). It lets the CFTC find that event contracts involving gaming are contrary to the public interest and bar them from being listed or traded. The judges disagreed about how all these pieces fit together.

Timeline

DateDevelopment
April 7, 2025Maryland gaming authorities send Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter, saying it was offering sports wagering without a Maryland license and demanding it stop within 15 days
April 21, 2025Kalshi sues Maryland officials and asks for a preliminary injunction
August 1, 2025The district court denies the injunction
May 7, 2026Oral argument at the Fourth Circuit
November 18, 2026Fourth Circuit affirms, 2-1

Maryland had reportedly agreed not to enforce its laws against Kalshi until the Fourth Circuit ruled, according to one trade report. Check Maryland’s gaming agency and Kalshi for any current notices.

The Three Opinions

Two judges reached the same result by different roads, which is why this ruling is less sweeping than “Maryland wins” suggests.

JudgePositionReasoning in brief
Gregory (concurring)AffirmDid not decide whether the contracts are swaps. Even assuming they are, neither the statute nor CFTC rules clearly displace Maryland’s authority over gambling, and Kalshi could comply with both by getting a Maryland license or not offering the contracts in the state
Thacker (concurring in the judgment)AffirmKalshi’s sports contracts are not swaps, so they fall outside the CFTC’s exclusive authority and Maryland can co-regulate. She wrote that the contracts pay on the outcome of a sporting event rather than on whether an event occurs
Benjamin (dissenting)ReverseThe contracts are swaps, so the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction and Maryland’s law is field preempted. She would have vacated the denial and sent the case back to consider the remaining injunction factors

Judge Gregory: no clear intent to displace the state

Judge Gregory started from the principle that gambling regulation is a traditional state power, and courts don’t assume Congress displaced such powers unless its intent is clear. He found the statute and the CFTC’s implementing rules left the question unresolved. He noted that Kalshi’s contracts remain listed because Kalshi self-certified that they comply with the Act and the CFTC hasn’t issued a final determination requiring removal. In his view that doesn’t amount to a clear federal rule shielding the contracts from state law.

On conflict preemption, he said Maryland’s requirements are a state license, advertising restrictions (including limits on advertising to prohibited and at-risk individuals and a ban on false or deceptive ads), and data security obligations. He concluded Kalshi had not shown it would be impossible to comply with both state and federal law. He described his own conclusion as “narrow.”

Related article: Michigan Tax Foreclosure Settlement, Homeowners in 28 Counties Have Until November 23 to Claim Surplus Money

Is Kalshi Legal in Maryland? Federal Appeals Court Allows State Gambling Enforcement to Proceed

Judge Thacker: this is sports betting

Judge Thacker concluded the contracts aren’t swaps. She reasoned that a swap requires payment to depend on whether, or to what extent, an event occurs, and that Kalshi’s contracts instead depend on the result of a completed game. She also pointed out that Kalshi’s own counsel had acknowledged the company advertised as sports betting a year earlier, and that treating these contracts as swaps could sweep in ordinary sports bets.

Judge Benjamin: swaps, and exclusive federal jurisdiction

Judge Benjamin took the opposite view on both steps. She reasoned that sports contracts can be swaps, that Congress gave the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps on designated contract markets, and that Maryland therefore can’t regulate them. She acknowledged the argument that Kalshi “walks like a casino” but wrote that the statute gives the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction, not the states.

So, Is Kalshi Legal in Maryland?

There isn’t a clean yes or no, and anyone offering one is oversimplifying.

  • Maryland’s position: its law generally prohibits sports wagering unless the operator is licensed, and it says Kalshi needed a license to offer sports contracts to people in the state.
  • Kalshi’s position: it is a federally regulated exchange and Maryland’s law is preempted.
  • What the court said: Kalshi hadn’t shown it was likely to win that argument, so Maryland is not blocked from enforcing.
  • What the court did not say: it did not issue a final judgment, it did not impose penalties on Kalshi, and it did not address whether individual users face any liability.

If you use or are thinking about using a prediction market in Maryland, this article can’t tell you your personal legal exposure. Check current notices from Kalshi and Maryland’s gaming authorities, and speak with a licensed Maryland attorney about your situation. If you hold funds on a platform, review its terms for how withdrawals work if its service changes.

How This Differs From Rulings in Other Courts

Courts have not agreed. The Fourth Circuit opinions themselves list a split among federal courts, and the Fourth Circuit is now one of several appeals courts to weigh in.

CourtOutcomeNotes
Third Circuit (Flaherty, New Jersey)For KalshiHeld the contracts are swaps under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction
Sixth Circuit (Schuler, Ohio)Against KalshiHeld the contracts are not swaps and found no clear preemption
Ninth Circuit (Assad, Nevada)Against KalshiHeld the contracts likely are not swaps
Fourth Circuit (Martin, Maryland)Against Kalshi at the injunction stageTwo judges affirm on different reasoning; one dissent

District courts have split too. The Fourth Circuit’s opinion cites rulings against Kalshi in Nevada, Ohio, New York, Michigan and Utah, and rulings favoring Kalshi in Arizona, Tennessee and Minnesota.

A key point for readers: the Fourth Circuit’s one-line majority opinion gives no shared rationale. Judges Gregory and Thacker reached the result on different grounds, so it is harder to say what legal rule binds courts later than it would be if a majority had agreed on one explanation. That, plus the circuit disagreement, is one reason the issue is widely expected to head toward the Supreme Court. One outlet reported that a Supreme Court petition in the Third Circuit case is pending, but we have not independently confirmed that.

What Happens Next?

Several things could move the issue forward.

  1. The Maryland district court case continues. The ruling affirms only the injunction denial.
  2. Kalshi could ask for further review. That could include rehearing by the full Fourth Circuit or a petition to the Supreme Court. Kalshi has not been verified as having filed either.
  3. The CFTC may act. The Fourth Circuit opinion notes the agency issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking in March 2026 and proposed amendments to Rule 40.11 in June 2026, which remain pending. Judge Gregory pointed to the unsettled federal framework as part of his reasoning.
  4. Congress could clarify. Judge Gregory wrote that Maryland has concurrent authority “until Congress and the CFTC are clear.”

Kalshi said in a statement reported by Reuters that the decision shows there is no unified legal argument against prediction markets.

What This Ruling Does Not Mean

  • It is not a nationwide ban. It concerns Maryland and the Fourth Circuit.
  • It does not resolve other states. Other courts have ruled both ways.
  • It is not a final ruling on the merits. It affirms a preliminary denial.
  • It is not a class action. There is no settlement, claim form or payout.
  • It doesn’t decide whether users broke the law. The case is between Kalshi and Maryland officials.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Fourth Circuit ban Kalshi?

No. It affirmed a lower court’s refusal to block Maryland from enforcing its sports wagering laws against Kalshi’s sports contracts. It did not order Kalshi to shut down anywhere.

How did the judges vote?

2-1. Judges Gregory and Thacker agreed Kalshi was not entitled to the injunction but for different reasons, and Judge Benjamin dissented.

Why did the two majority judges disagree?

Judge Gregory declined to decide whether the contracts are swaps and found no clear federal displacement of state gambling law. Judge Thacker found they are not swaps at all.

Is this the final decision in the case?

No. The court affirmed only the denial of a preliminary injunction. The underlying case continues in district court.

Can Maryland now take action against Kalshi?

The ruling leaves Maryland free to pursue enforcement under its gaming laws. What action it takes, and when, is up to the state, and Kalshi may still contest it.

Does this affect users in other states?

Not directly. Other states’ authority depends on their own laws and the courts that cover them, and federal courts have disagreed.

Can I be penalized for trading on Kalshi in Maryland?

The case doesn’t answer that. It concerns Kalshi’s obligations as an operator. For personal advice, consult a licensed Maryland attorney.

Is there a class action or settlement I can join?

No. This is a regulatory dispute, and there is no class action, settlement or claim form.

Will the Supreme Court decide this?

Possibly. Federal appeals courts have disagreed, which often leads to Supreme Court review, but whether and when that happens is not certain.

The Bottom Line

The Fourth Circuit’s ruling leaves Maryland free to continue enforcing its gambling laws against Kalshi’s sports contracts for now. But it is a narrow, preliminary and fractured decision: two judges agreed on the result for different reasons, a third dissented, and appeals courts around the country remain split. The legal status of prediction-market sports contracts will depend on what comes next in the Maryland litigation, any further appeals, CFTC action and possibly Congress. We’ll update this page as those develop.

Sources and Legal References

  1. Fourth Circuit published opinion, KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, No. 25-1892 (Nov. 18, 2026)
  2. Justia copy of the Fourth Circuit opinion
  3. 7 U.S.C. § 2(a)(1)(A): CFTC exclusive jurisdiction
  4. 7 U.S.C. § 7a-2(c)(5)(C): Special Rule for event contracts
  5. 7 U.S.C. § 1a(47): definition of “swap”
  6. InGame: Fourth Circuit sides with Maryland over Kalshi
  7. Securities Regulation Daily, Nov. 18, 2026 (reporting Kalshi’s statement to Reuters)

AllAboutLawyer.com provides independent legal information, not legal advice, and is not a law firm. Nothing here is financial, investment or betting advice. Court opinions can be appealed, reheard or changed by later events. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed attorney.

By AllAboutLawyer Legal Content Research | Published November 19, 2026

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *