|

Arizona Chauffeur Wage Class Action Revived, Ninth Circuit Rules on Unpaid Work and Overtime

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has revived major wage claims brought by current and former chauffeurs against The Driver Provider, an Arizona-based luxury transportation company accused of not paying for required work before and after passenger trips. In a published decision on November 18, 2026, in Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix, LLC, Nos. 24-6575 and 24-6914, the court reversed three district court rulings and sent the case back to the District of Arizona.

The panel held that the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) does not preempt the drivers’ Arizona Wage Act overtime claims, that the district court wrongly denied class certification of certain unpaid straight-time claims, and that private plaintiffs may pursue Arizona civil penalties for recordkeeping violations.

This is an appeal win, not a payout. The drivers have not been awarded money on the revived claims. A separate $2.5 million partial settlement was reached in 2024 and expressly left these claims unresolved. No new settlement, claim form or deadline has been announced.

Arizona Chauffeur Wage Lawsuit Quick Facts: Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix, LLC

DetailConfirmed information
CaseSalazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix, LLC
Original filingDecember 2019
District court and case numberU.S. District Court, District of Arizona, 2:19-cv-05760-SMB
Appeals court and numbersNinth Circuit, Nos. 24-6575 and 24-6914
Decision dateNovember 18, 2026
PanelJudge Roopali H. Desai (author), Judge Salvador Mendoza Jr., Judge Daniel P. Collins (concurring in part, dissenting in part)
Lead plaintiffKelli Salazar
DefendantsDriver Provider Phoenix, LLC, related entities and individual defendants
Central disputePay for required pre-trip and post-trip work
Laws involvedFLSA; Arizona Wage Act; Arizona Minimum Wage Act
Earlier partial settlement$2.5 million (2024)
November 2026 resultReversed and remanded
New settlement or claim formNone announced
Official settlement websiteNone for the revived claims. The 2024 partial settlement had its own administrator site, driverprovidersettlement.com.
Official opinionNinth Circuit opinion, November 18, 2026

Why Did Arizona Chauffeurs Sue The Driver Provider Over Unpaid Wages?

The Driver Provider runs luxury ground transportation in Arizona, Utah and Wyoming with a fleet of more than 140 vehicles, according to the Ninth Circuit’s opinion. Its services include airport transfers, fixed routes, shuttles, charters and individual trips. The lawsuit began in December 2019, when chauffeurs said the company’s pay system did not cover all the hours they were required to work.

What work did Driver Provider chauffeurs allegedly do without separate pay?

The court described these required duties:

  • Reporting to the company location about an hour before the first ride
  • Checking out vehicles and doing pre-trip inspections
  • Arriving at pickup locations at least 15 minutes early
  • Refueling and cleaning company vehicles
  • Doing post-trip inspections and checking vehicles back in

The plaintiffs said the company tracked passenger-trip time but did not adequately record the other required work. Federal and Arizona wage laws protect compensable work time, not only the minutes spent serving a paying customer.

How Did The Driver Provider’s Commission Pay System Work?

Chauffeurs were paid a commission, a percentage of the base amount charged to the customer, with the percentage depending on vehicle type, customer rate and driver classification. The Ninth Circuit gave an example: a Sedan-Z1 trip with a base rate of $70.40 and a 34% commission for a Level 1 chauffeur paid about $23.94.

The question was not whether $23.94 was a fair price for driving. It was whether the commission paid for the required work around the trip. The company also had separate arrangements for errands, training, dry runs and meet-and-greets, and whether those met its wage obligations is still part of the case.

What Did the Ninth Circuit Rule in Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix on November 18, 2026?

1. Arizona Wage Act overtime claims are not preempted by the FLSA

The district court had dismissed the Arizona Wage Act overtime claims as preempted by the FLSA, meaning federal law displaced them. The Ninth Circuit majority disagreed and concluded that Arizona’s possibly more generous remedies do not undermine the FLSA’s purpose of protecting workers. The federal overtime statute does not automatically wipe out these state-law claims. The ruling does not mean any plaintiff has proved a violation.

2. The denial of class certification for straight-time claims was reversed

The district court refused to certify a class for unpaid regular wages under the Arizona Wage Act because drivers had different understandings of how they were paid, some thinking commission and some thinking hourly. The Ninth Circuit found that approach legally flawed. All chauffeurs were paid under the same commission plan and raised the common question of whether it covered required pre-trip and post-trip work. Their differing subjective understandings did not defeat commonality under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23. The certification question goes back to the district court, and this is not a class-wide payment order.

3. Private plaintiffs may pursue Arizona recordkeeping penalties

Under A.R.S. § 23-364, employers must keep certain payroll records, including daily hours worked. Civil penalties start at $250 for a first violation and $1,000 for each later or willful violation. The district court had held that private employees could not enforce the penalty provision. The Ninth Circuit held that they can. The ruling sets no penalty amount for The Driver Provider.

Did All Three Ninth Circuit Judges Agree in Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix?

No. Judge Desai wrote the majority opinion, joined by Judge Mendoza. Judge Collins agreed the Arizona overtime claims should not have been dismissed as preempted and agreed with dismissing the company’s cross-appeal, but on different reasoning. He dissented on class certification and on private enforcement of the civil penalties, questioning whether the court had jurisdiction to review the certification ruling after the settlement and disagreeing with the commonality analysis. The majority opinion controls unless it is changed through further review.

Wasn’t There Already a $2.5 Million Driver Provider Wage Settlement?

Yes, and it is essential to understanding the new decision. In 2024 the parties reached a $2.5 million partial settlement, which the district court approved and entered as a final judgment. Law360 reported that the company then filed a cross-appeal.

ClaimStatus after the 2024 settlement
FLSA minimum-wage claimsSettled
FLSA overtime claimsSettled
Arizona Minimum Wage Act minimum-wage class claimsSettled
Named plaintiffs’ Arizona straight-time claimsSettled
Certain Arizona Wage Act overtime claimsPreserved for appeal
Putative class members’ Arizona straight-time claimsPreserved for appeal
Arizona recordkeeping civil penalty claimsPreserved for appeal

The earlier notice covered certain Arizona chauffeurs who worked between December 6, 2016 and January 5, 2024, plus qualifying employees who joined the federal collective action. Those dates describe the historical settlement groups and are not a new eligibility period for the November 2026 ruling.

Can drivers file another settlement claim now?

No new claims process has been announced. The $2.5 million belongs to the earlier settlement and was not created on November 18, 2026. Drivers who took part should keep their notices, payment records and settlement documents, because whether they can benefit from unresolved claims depends on the earlier releases, the claims preserved and later court rulings.

Related article: Five Below Tariff Refund Lawsuit, Can Shoppers Get Money Back From the Retailer?

Arizona Chauffeur Wage Class Action Revived, Ninth Circuit Rules on Unpaid Work and Overtime

What Arizona and Federal Wage Laws Protect Chauffeurs From Unpaid Work?

Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. §§ 206 and 207

Covered, nonexempt employees must receive minimum wage and overtime of at least one and one-half times their regular rate for hours over 40 in a workweek. Under 29 CFR § 785.11, work the employer knows or has reason to know is being done generally counts as working time. Some preliminary and postliminary activities are excluded under the Portal-to-Portal Act. In this case the parties agreed the disputed pre-trip and post-trip work was compensable and disagreed over whether the commission system paid for it.

Arizona Wage Act, A.R.S. §§ 23-350, 23-351 and 23-355

The Act governs payment of wages owed. Its definition of wages includes nondiscretionary pay earned through time, tasks, piecework or commissions. Section 23-355 allows civil actions for unpaid wages and provides for possible treble damages in qualifying cases. Treble damages are not automatic.

Arizona Minimum Wage Act, A.R.S. § 23-364

This law sets recordkeeping duties and enforcement. Private enforcement of the civil penalties is the notable part of the November 18 ruling. It does not mean every missing record earns every employee a separate $1,000.

Do Commission-Based Chauffeurs Have a Right to Overtime Under the FLSA and Arizona Law?

Potentially. Commission pay does not automatically exempt an employee from overtime. Exemptions depend on statutory conditions and facts. In this case the lower court had ruled against The Driver Provider on claimed FLSA exemptions for the settled claims, and the Ninth Circuit dismissed the company’s cross-appeal because those federal claims had been settled. The court did not reopen the settled FLSA claims.

For a separate driver pay dispute, read FedEx Overtime Lawsuit, Were You Affected As A Driver?.

Can Employers Require Workers to Arrive Early Without Pay Under Arizona Law?

An employer can set reporting times and require preparation, but whether the time must be paid depends on the activities. Required inspections, equipment preparation, work paperwork and cleaning can be compensable. A worker who arrives early by choice and uses the time for personal purposes is a different case. As an illustration only, 30 minutes of required unpaid preparation on five days adds up to 2.5 hours a week, which could affect minimum-wage and overtime calculations. That is not an estimate of what any driver is owed.

Similar off-the-clock allegations appear in Walmart Wage Theft Lawsuit, Employees Allege Off-the-Clock Work, Unpaid Meetings and Interrupted Lunch Breaks.

Why Do Accurate Time Records Matter in the Driver Provider Wage Lawsuit?

An employer cannot necessarily satisfy wage laws by recording only the most visible, revenue-producing part of a job. Employers have recordkeeping duties under federal regulations and Arizona law, and when records are incomplete, employee testimony, schedules and electronic data can help show actual hours.

A different case about pre-shift and post-shift time is discussed in Fontaine Modification $1.6 Million Employee Wage Class Action Settlement, Who Qualifies, How to Claim and the November 27 Deadline. It involves different employees and a different settlement.

What Should Current and Former Driver Provider Chauffeurs Do After the Ninth Circuit Ruling?

  1. Keep pay records: pay stubs, commission statements, tax forms and employment agreements.
  2. Document required duties: roughly how long inspections, cleaning, refueling, early arrival and check-in took.
  3. Keep earlier settlement documents, because prior participation and release terms can affect remaining claims.
  4. Follow the case in the Arizona district court after remand instead of assuming payment eligibility.
  5. Talk to a wage-and-hour attorney about how the ruling, your employment dates and limitation periods affect you.

Do not take confidential customer information or proprietary company records while gathering your own wage documents. You can also contact the Industrial Commission of Arizona or the U.S. Department of Labor Wage and Hour Division. A pending lawsuit does not necessarily stop limitation periods for every person or every separate claim.

What Happens Next in Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix After Remand?

The case returns to the District of Arizona. The court must address the revived claims, which may mean renewed class-certification briefing, discovery, motions or trial preparation. The defendants may also seek further appellate review. As of November 19, 2026, there is no verified new trial date, payment schedule or second settlement.

Arizona Chauffeur Wage Lawsuit Timeline

DateDevelopment
December 2019Drivers file the original wage lawsuit
2023District court issues class-certification, preemption and summary-judgment rulings
2024Parties reach a $2.5 million partial settlement; court approves it and issues a final judgment; appeals follow
November 18, 2026Ninth Circuit reverses three rulings and remands
Not announcedFurther district court proceedings or a new settlement

Frequently Asked Questions About the Driver Provider Chauffeur Wage Lawsuit

Did Arizona chauffeurs win their unpaid wage lawsuit?

They won an important appeal. The ruling did not establish liability or award damages on the revived claims.

What are the Driver Provider case numbers?

The district court case is 2:19-cv-05760-SMB. The Ninth Circuit appeals are 24-6575 and 24-6914.

Is there a new Driver Provider class action settlement?

No. The parties reached a $2.5 million partial settlement in 2024, and nothing new has been announced.

Can drivers receive additional overtime pay?

Possibly, depending on the preserved claims, each driver’s circumstances and later rulings. No payment is guaranteed.

Does Arizona law allow penalties for missing time records?

Yes. The Ninth Circuit held that private plaintiffs may pursue the Arizona Minimum Wage Act’s civil penalties for recordkeeping violations, if they prove a qualifying violation.

Are Utah and Wyoming chauffeurs included?

The earlier federal collective included qualifying employees in Arizona, Utah and Wyoming. The revived Arizona state-law claims have a different scope, so drivers outside Arizona should not assume they qualify.

Bottom Line: Arizona Chauffeurs Revive Wage Claims Against The Driver Provider, but No New Payments Yet

The Ninth Circuit’s November 18, 2026 decision gives Arizona chauffeurs another chance to pursue wage claims left open by the 2024 partial settlement. It held that Arizona wage claims were not preempted by federal overtime law, reversed the denial of class certification based on differing driver understandings of a common commission plan, and allowed private enforcement of Arizona recordkeeping penalties. The drivers won a legal appeal, not a new monetary award. What happens next depends on the district court, the evidence and any future settlement or judgment.

Sources

  1. Ninth Circuit, Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix, LLC, published opinion, November 18, 2026
  2. GovInfo, Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix LLC, District of Arizona records
  3. 2024 Driver Provider partial settlement notice
  4. A.R.S. § 23-350, § 23-351, § 23-355, § 23-364
  5. U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet 22, Hours Worked Under the FLSA
  6. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23

Disclaimer: This is general legal information, not legal advice. The ruling does not create a compensation program or guarantee payment to any driver.

Researched and written by Israr Ahmad, legal content researcher and founder of AllAboutLawyer.com. All facts verified against the Ninth Circuit’s published opinion, the 2024 partial settlement notice and the Arizona wage statutes, as of November 19, 2026. No official settlement website exists for the revived claims. Last Updated: November 19, 2026.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *