Supreme Court Rejects Trump Appeal Over University of California Research Grants, What Trump v. Thakur Means

On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Trump v. Thakur, No. 26-210. That leaves in place a Ninth Circuit ruling that the administration’s termination of certain University of California (UC) research grants over researchers’ perceived viewpoints likely violated the First Amendment. The Court gave no explanation, and no public dissent was reported.

The government’s petition put about $59 million in remaining funds on the affected National Science Foundation (NSF) and National Endowment for the Humanities (NEH) grants at issue, out of about $150 million in original awards.

This was a refusal to hear the appeal, not a final ruling. The Court did not declare the administration’s DEI policies unconstitutional. The ruling the Ninth Circuit issued is preliminary, and the underlying lawsuit continues.

Supreme Court Trump v. Thakur Ruling: Quick Facts

QuestionVerified answer
Supreme Court caseTrump v. Thakur, No. 26-210
Supreme Court actionPetition for certiorari denied, November 16, 2026
Lower court caseThakur v. Trump, No. 3:25-cv-04737-RFL (N.D. Cal.)
District judgeRita F. Lin
Appeals court rulingNinth Circuit, May 26, 2026, 176 F.4th 1187 (No. 25-4249)
Lead plaintiffDr. Neeta Thakur
Main legal issueFirst Amendment viewpoint discrimination
Remaining funds on NSF/NEH grants (per DOJ)About $59 million
Original value of those NSF/NEH awardsAbout $150 million
Government’s petitionFiled August 18, 2026
Case statusMerits litigation continues

Sources: Supreme Court docket No. 26-210, Ninth Circuit opinion, and counsel’s case milestones page.

What Did the Supreme Court Decide on November 16, 2026?

The Court denied the Trump administration’s petition for a writ of certiorari, the formal request for review. That left the Ninth Circuit’s May 26, 2026 decision undisturbed. Three points matter:

  1. The ruling protects grants covered by the surviving preliminary injunction. It does not restore every federal grant canceled since January 2025.
  2. A preliminary injunction is temporary relief before a final decision on the merits.
  3. A denial of certiorari does not mean the Court endorsed every conclusion of the lower court.

The case goes back to the district court.

Why Did the Trump Administration Cancel University of California Research Grants?

After Donald Trump returned to office in January 2025, two executive orders drove the cuts:

  • Executive Order 14151 (January 20, 2025), “Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs and Preferencing.”
  • Executive Order 14173 (January 21, 2025), “Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity.”

The administration says federal funding should follow current priorities and civil rights law. The Ninth Circuit’s opinion describes agencies identifying grants through keyword searches and analytics, then sending standard termination letters saying the grants no longer matched agency priorities. The researchers say that was viewpoint-based suppression.

In court stipulations, NSF, NEH, the Department of Defense, the Department of Transportation and NIH-HHS admitted they selected grants for termination because the grants “expressed, or were presumed to express, viewpoints disfavored by the Administration,” according to the plaintiffs’ counsel.

Who Filed Thakur v. Trump, and What Grants Were Affected?

UC researchers filed the class action on June 4, 2025. The grants came from the EPA, NSF and NEH, and in September 2025 the case was expanded to add grants terminated by the Department of Defense, Department of Transportation and NIH. A motion to add Department of Energy grants followed in November 2025.

The work spanned medicine, climate and water policy, history and other fields. The lawsuit is not limited to projects devoted to DEI, because some grants were allegedly flagged by keywords. On June 23, 2025, Judge Lin issued a class-wide preliminary injunction ordering the government to stop the terminations and reinstate covered grants.

What Did the Ninth Circuit Rule in Thakur v. Trump?

A three-judge panel affirmed part of Judge Lin’s injunction and reversed part of it.

Equity Termination Class: First Amendment Injunction Upheld

For researchers whose grants were terminated under the DEI executive orders, the Ninth Circuit found a likely First Amendment violation. It distinguished between deciding which programs the government will fund and canceling individual grants inside existing programs based on the perceived viewpoints of the researchers. The injunction protecting this class stayed in place.

Form Termination Class: Different Outcome on the APA Claim

For researchers terminated through form letters, the plaintiffs relied on the Administrative Procedure Act. The Ninth Circuit found those claims likely belong in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims under the Tucker Act, because they are essentially claims for money owed under grant terms. That part of the preliminary relief was stayed.

The result was not an across-the-board win for either side. The researchers won the preliminary First Amendment issue. The government won a jurisdiction point on the APA theory.

Supreme Court Rejects Trump Appeal Over University of California Research Grants, What Trump v. Thakur Means

Why Does the First Amendment Apply to Government Research Grants?

The First Amendment does not make the government fund every proposal, and agencies have wide discretion over spending priorities. The question is whether the government can cancel existing grants because of the views behind them.

  • Rosenberger v. Rector and Visitors of the University of Virginia, 515 U.S. 819 (1995): a public university could not exclude a publication from a funding program because of its religious viewpoint.
  • Rust v. Sullivan, 500 U.S. 173 (1991): the government may fund some programs and not others to advance its policy. The administration relies on this.
  • National Endowment for the Arts v. Finley, 524 U.S. 569 (1998): upheld a decency-and-respect consideration in arts funding while recognizing viewpoint concerns.
  • NRA v. Vullo, 602 U.S. 175 (2024): officials cannot use their power to coerce or punish disfavored speech.

What Did the Trump Administration Argue to the Supreme Court?

Solicitor General D. John Sauer filed the petition on August 18, 2026. The government argued that agencies must be free to shift priorities after elections, that declining to fund a project does not stop researchers from speaking, and that the Ninth Circuit’s approach could bind future presidents to fund projects that conflict with their policies. The Court did not say why it declined to take the case.

Does the Ruling Restore $59 Million or $150 Million to UC Researchers?

AmountWhat it represents
About $59 millionRemaining funding on the NSF and NEH grants at issue, per DOJ
About $150 millionOriginal value of those NSF and NEH awards
Much larger totals reported (CalMatters, for example, cited roughly a billion dollars)The broader litigation across several agencies

The November 16 order is not an award of new money, and it does not mean $59 million will be paid in one sum. The injunction protects covered grants while the case continues. Actual payments still follow award terms, agency administration and court orders.

Is There a Settlement in Thakur v. Trump?

Yes, with the Environmental Protection Agency only. The plaintiffs’ counsel announced a class-wide agreement under which the EPA permanently restores $19 million in UC research grants. It is separate from the NSF and NEH issue before the Supreme Court. It restores grants rather than paying cash to individuals, and the EPA denies wrongdoing.

According to the case website, the settlement received preliminary approval on October 1, 2026, with an objection deadline of November 20, 2026 and a final approval hearing on December 10, 2026. Confirm the details, release terms and instructions on the official UC Researcher Grant Terminations website before relying on them.

Does This Mean the Federal Government Cannot Cut University Research Funding?

No. Agencies still have lawful authority over budgets and grant management. The Ninth Circuit’s ruling limits the government’s ability to cancel covered grants on viewpoint grounds, based on the evidence in this case. Other grant fights have gone differently depending on the claims and relief sought. For separate litigation on humanities grants, see Authors Guild vs. National Endowment for the Humanities, DOGE Humanities Grant Cuts Ruled Unconstitutional.

What Does the Trump v. Thakur Denial Mean for Researchers Outside California?

The classes in this case are UC researchers. Researchers at other institutions are not automatically covered, though the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning may influence similar lawsuits. For related cases, see Pitt Professors Join NIH Putative Class Action Alleging Scientific Research Censorship and American Academy of Pediatrics Lawsuit, Federal Court Orders HHS to Restore $12M After Alleged First Amendment Retaliation. Those involve different plaintiffs, evidence and procedure. The Supreme Court’s denial does not by itself restore anyone else’s grant.

What Happens Next in Thakur v. Trump?

The case remains before Judge Rita Lin. Briefing on the plaintiffs’ summary judgment and class certification motion had been stayed pending the Supreme Court’s decision on the petition, with the exception of the Department of Energy equal protection claim. In the stipulations, the Department of Energy admitted terminating 283 grants in states that voted for Kamala Harris while not terminating 340 grants in states that voted for Donald Trump, which supports the plaintiffs’ equal protection claim. The Supreme Court’s order did not decide those issues.

What Should Affected UC Researchers Do?

Keep award notices, termination letters, agency emails, budgets and records of disrupted work. Check whether your grant is in a covered class or the EPA settlement, and talk to your campus sponsored-research office or a lawyer before assuming the injunction resolves your individual award.

Frequently Asked Questions About Trump v. Thakur

Did the Supreme Court rule against Trump on November 16, 2026?

It declined to hear his administration’s appeal. That left a lower court ruling in place, but it was not a final Supreme Court judgment on the merits.

Which justices voted against Trump’s appeal?

The Court did not announce individual votes, and no public dissent was reported.

Did the Supreme Court restore all University of California research funding?

No. It left a preliminary injunction covering certain grants in place. Other claims remain unresolved.

Can the federal government still cancel DEI-related grants?

Agencies keep lawful spending authority but must follow the Constitution, statutes, grant terms and court orders.

Is there money available through the EPA settlement?

The settlement restores $19 million in UC research grants. It does not create a claims process for individual cash payments, so confirm details with the settlement website.

Is the University of California lawsuit finished?

No. It continues in federal district court.

The Bottom Line on the Supreme Court’s Trump v. Thakur Denial

The Supreme Court’s November 16, 2026 order is a setback for the administration’s effort to cancel certain UC research grants over viewpoint. It leaves in place a preliminary Ninth Circuit ruling, but it does not end the case, invalidate every DEI policy, or guarantee funding for all research. The next developments are district court proceedings and the EPA settlement dates.

Primary Sources and Official Court Records

  1. Supreme Court docket, Trump v. Thakur, No. 26-210
  2. Respondents’ brief in opposition, No. 26-210
  3. Petitioners’ reply brief, No. 26-210
  4. Farella Braun + Martel: Thakur v. Trump case milestones
  5. UC Researcher Grant Terminations, official litigation and settlement website

Disclaimer: AllAboutLawyer.com provides legal information, not legal advice. Researchers should consult qualified counsel about their own grants and settlement rights.

Researched and written by Israr Ahmad, legal content researcher and founder of AllAboutLawyer.com. All facts verified against Supreme Court docket No. 26-210 and the parties’ briefs, and counsel’s published case milestones, as of November 17, 2026. Last Updated: November 17, 2026.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *