|

NYC $60 Million Third Party Transfer Settlement, Who Qualifies and How to Claim Compensation

Settlement status as of October 29, 2026: Preliminary approval was granted on October 21, 2026. The settlement is not final, claims are not open, and no money has been paid. The settlement website says administration has not begun. The final approval hearing is May 5, 2027, and that is a court hearing date, not a claim deadline.

New York City has agreed to a $60 million settlement with former property owners who say the city’s Third Party Transfer (TPT) program took their properties without paying them for the equity left after unpaid municipal charges. U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon of the Southern District of New York granted preliminary approval on October 21, 2026, certified a settlement class for settlement purposes, and authorized notices inviting former owners to submit claims.

The case is Dorce et al. v. City of New York et al., No. 1:19-cv-02216 (JLR) (SLC) (S.D.N.Y.). The settlement covers only Round 10 of the TPT program: 64 properties containing approximately 839 housing units. Properties transferred in Rounds 1 through 9 are not covered.

NYC Third Party Transfer Round 10 Eligibility Checklist: Could You Be a Class Member?

You may be in the settlement class if all of these apply:

  • [ ] Your property was transferred in Round 10 of New York City’s Third Party Transfer program (not an earlier round, and not a different foreclosure program).
  • [ ] You held a qualifying ownership interest in that property before the transfer. That can include an individual owner, a housing development fund corporation (HDFC), or an HDFC shareholder, subject to the court-approved class definition.
  • [ ] The property had surplus equity. In plain terms, its value was above the tax and other municipal charges owed.
  • [ ] You can document your interest. If the former owner has died, an estate representative or successor may need to show authority to act.

Who does not qualify automatically: tenants who held no ownership interest, owners whose properties were transferred in Rounds 1 through 9, and people whose property was foreclosed under another city, county, or state program.

NYC Third Party Transfer Settlement Quick Facts

ItemDetails
Settlement fund$60,000,000, paid by the City of New York
CaseDorce et al. v. City of New York et al., No. 1:19-cv-02216 (JLR) (SLC)
Court and judgeU.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y.; Judge Jennifer L. Rochon
Covered properties64 properties transferred in Round 10 (about 839 housing units); about 30 were HDFC buildings
Preliminary approvalOctober 21, 2026
Final approval hearingMay 5, 2027, 10:00 a.m. ET
Claims statusNot open
Claims administratorSimpluris
Official settlement websiteTPTRound10Settlement.com (currently a placeholder page stating administration has not begun)
Earlier TPT roundsNot covered; still in litigation
ReliefMoney for lost surplus equity. Titles are not returned

How the NYC Third Party Transfer Program Works

Under the city’s in rem foreclosure law, N.Y.C. Admin. Code §§ 11-401 et seq., the city can foreclose on properties with long-unpaid taxes and other municipal charges. In the TPT program, title then passes to a nonprofit, here Neighborhood Restore Housing Development Fund Company, Inc., for rehabilitation and eventual transfer to an affordable-housing developer. The city says the goal is to rehabilitate distressed buildings and preserve affordable housing.

The dispute is about what happens to the value above the debt. In an ordinary foreclosure sale, a surplus may be generated. Under TPT, there is no auction and no cash proceeds for the former owner.

A simple illustration: if a building is worth $300,000 and the charges owed are $70,000, the gap is $230,000 before other liens and valuation disputes. That example only shows the issue. It is not a calculation of anyone’s payment.

What Did the Dorce v. City of New York Lawsuit Allege?

The case was filed in March 2019. The plaintiffs, including McConnell Dorce, alleged that the city took properties worth more than the municipal debt without paying for the surplus equity, gave inadequate notice, and ran a program that fell hardest on Black and Latino homeowners and HDFC limited-equity cooperatives. Their claims rest on the Fifth Amendment’s just compensation requirement, due process, and equal protection. Other defendants included Neighborhood Restore and BSDC Kings Covenant.

A 2019 City Council investigation, reported by Law360, found that half of the 420 properties first selected for Round 10 did not meet the legal definition of “distressed” because outstanding municipal charges were under 15% of their value.

The City maintains that the transfers did not violate owners’ rights. The settlement is not a trial finding of liability.

The Second Circuit’s 2021 Ruling in Dorce v. City of New York

The district court dismissed the case in May 2020. On June 23, 2021, the Second Circuit reversed in part in Dorce v. City of New York, 2 F.4th 82 (2d Cir. 2021), allowing key claims to continue. It did not decide that the city was liable. It decided which claims could go forward.

How Tyler v. Hennepin County Changed the Legal Backdrop

In Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023), the Supreme Court unanimously held that a homeowner plausibly alleged a Fifth Amendment taking when a county sold her property for a tax debt and kept the excess value. Tyler involved Minnesota’s system and did not decide whether New York’s TPT program is unconstitutional. It did strengthen the legal theory behind surplus-equity claims.

For a comparison with another government that kept surplus proceeds, see Clackamas County $2.47M Foreclosure Settlement, Former Property Owners Can Claim Surplus Proceeds By May 25, 2026.

What the $60 Million Settlement Covers: Round 10 Properties, HDFC Buildings, and Shareholders

The settlement resolves claims from the 64 Round 10 properties. It does not reverse the foreclosures or return any building to its former owner.

About 30 of the properties were HDFC buildings. In an HDFC cooperative, residents generally hold shares tied to their apartments instead of owning the whole building. Former HDFC shareholders in Round 10 buildings are part of the settlement class, but living in a building is not the same as holding a qualifying ownership interest. The official class definition and notice control.

Are Owners From NYC Third Party Transfer Rounds 1 Through 9 Covered?

No. Earlier-round claims are separate litigation. A magistrate judge heard argument on October 22, 2026 on a motion to certify a class for those earlier rounds, but that hearing created no settlement fund and does not make those owners eligible for Round 10 payments.

For an example of how separate tax-foreclosure cases can have different class definitions and proof rules, see Lane County $1.35 Million Tax Foreclosure Class Action Settlement, Who Qualifies, How Payments Work and the February 22, 2027 Deadline and Michigan Tax Foreclosure Lawsuit, Sixth Circuit Revives Denise Thompson’s Fight Over the $23,500 Allegan County Kept. Eligibility in one case does not carry over to another.

How Much Could a Former Owner Receive From the NYC $60 Million Settlement?

The $60 million is a total fund, not a payment per person. Court-approved attorneys’ fees, costs, administration expenses, and any service awards come out of the fund before distribution.

Payments are expected to follow individual surplus-equity calculations, not an equal split among the 64 properties or 839 units. The settlement papers use the city’s 2018 desktop appraisals as a starting point, although the parties disputed some valuation issues. The papers also refer to interest and to a $25,000 figure in the allocation formula. Reports differ on whether that figure operates as a minimum or a ceiling, so read the plan of allocation in the official notice before relying on it.

The final amount for any claimant depends on the approved plan of allocation, claim review, and the court’s final approval.

How to Claim in the NYC Third Party Transfer Round 10 Settlement

Claims are not open, but you can prepare now.

  1. Identify the property. Confirm the address and gather deeds, cooperative share certificates, corporate ownership records, tax bills, lien statements, foreclosure papers, and any city correspondence.
  2. Document your interest. If the former owner died, keep probate records, a will, or court appointment papers showing authority to act.
  3. Watch for notice. Simpluris is expected to send notice and claim forms to known former owners using records supplied by the city. Not receiving a letter does not prove you are ineligible, so also check TPTRound10Settlement.com and the court docket (No. 1:19-cv-02216).
  4. File on the official form. The notice will set the claim, exclusion, and objection deadlines. Settlement papers describe a 90-day period after notice, but take the actual dates from the official notice only.
  5. Keep proof. Save a copy of your claim, attachments, and confirmation or proof of mailing.

Do not pay anyone for a claim form. Verify the website and administrator before sending personal information, and do not send documents or money to anyone claiming to represent the settlement before official notice arrives.

Can Class Members Object or Opt Out of the NYC Settlement?

The official notice will explain any objection and exclusion procedures and their deadlines. A class settlement can bind eligible members who take no action the notice requires, so read the notice as soon as it arrives.

NYC Third Party Transfer Settlement Key Dates

DateEvent
March 2019Dorce lawsuit filed
June 23, 2021Second Circuit reverses dismissal in part
May 25, 2023Supreme Court decides Tyler v. Hennepin County
August 26, 2026Parties report a fully executed Round 10 settlement agreement
September 2, 2026Court denies the pending summary-judgment motion as moot, without prejudice if the settlement is not completed
October 21, 2026Preliminary approval granted; settlement class certified for settlement purposes
October 22, 2026Hearing on the separate earlier-rounds class-certification motion
After notice is mailedClaim, exclusion, and objection deadlines set by the notice
May 5, 2027, 10:00 a.m. ETFinal approval hearing

NYC Third Party Transfer Settlement FAQs

Is the NYC $60 Million Third Party Transfer Settlement Final?

No. It has preliminary approval only. Payments depend on final approval, the claims process, and the settlement becoming effective.

Can I File a Claim Right Now?

No. Claims are not open and administration has not begun.

Is May 5, 2027 the Claim Deadline?

No. It is the scheduled final approval hearing. Use the deadline in the official notice, which may be earlier.

Do NYC Tenants Qualify?

Not just because they lived in an affected building. The settlement is for former owners and qualifying ownership interests.

Will Former Owners Get Their Properties Back?

No. The relief is money for lost surplus equity.

Did the Court Find That New York City Violated the Constitution?

No. The Second Circuit let key claims proceed in 2021, but the Round 10 claims were resolved by settlement, not by a trial finding.

Does the Settlement Cover All NYC Tax Foreclosures?

No. It covers the Round 10 class only.

Bottom Line for Former Owners of NYC Round 10 Properties

If your property, or your HDFC shares, was transferred in Round 10 and the property had value above the municipal charges, you may be in the settlement class. Gather your ownership and valuation records, watch TPTRound10Settlement.com and your mail for the official notice from Simpluris, and rely on that notice for deadlines.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. AllAboutLawyer.com is a consumer legal information site, not a law firm. For advice about your situation, consult a licensed attorney or review the official settlement notice when it is issued.

Sources

  1. Official NYC Third Party Transfer Round 10 settlement website (Simpluris)
  2. Dorce et al. v. City of New York et al., No. 1:19-cv-02216 (JLR) (SLC) (S.D.N.Y.): September 2, 2026 order, ECF No. 532; the October 21, 2026 preliminary-approval order (ECF No. 542); and October 22, 2026 order, ECF No. 543
  3. Dorce v. City of New York, 2 F.4th 82 (2d Cir. 2021)
  4. Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023)
  5. NYC Department of Finance: Third Party Transfer (TPT) In Rem Program
  6. Law360: Judge Advances $60M Deal Over NYC Foreclosure Program

Researched and written by Israr Ahmad, legal content researcher and founder of AllAboutLawyer.com. All facts verified against the court docket and orders in No. 1:19-cv-02216, the Second Circuit and Supreme Court opinions, and the official settlement website run by the administrator (TPTRound10Settlement.com), as of October 29, 2026. Last Updated: October 29, 2026.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *