| |

ICE Detaining Green Card Holders in 2026, Can Old Crimes Lead to Deportation?

Immigration officers are detaining some longtime green card holders over old criminal charges, past voter-registration records, and alleged omissions in immigration applications. Some of the incidents go back decades. A November 17, 2026 investigation by The Washington Post describes permanent residents being stopped at airports and land border crossings after living lawfully in the United States for many years.

Short answer: yes, ICE or CBP can detain a green card holder who has had status for 10, 20, or 30 years. But an old arrest does not automatically make someone deportable, and detention does not mean the green card has been revoked. Only an immigration judge can order removal.

The issue matters more now because of the Supreme Court’s June 23, 2026 decision in Blanche v. Lau, which changed how border officers can treat returning permanent residents. The ruling does not authorize automatic deportation of everyone with a record. Below is what it does and does not do, who is most at risk, and what to do if it happens to you or a family member.

ICE Detaining Green Card Holders: Quick Facts for November 2026

QuestionCurrent answer
Can ICE or CBP detain a green card holder?Yes, when immigration law gives them authority to
Does a valid green card prevent detention?No
Can decades-old offenses matter?Yes, depending on the exact offense, disposition, and law that applies
Is an arrest alone enough for deportation?Generally no; many grounds require a conviction or admission
Can an officer revoke a green card by taking it?No. Only an immigration judge can order removal
Can detention happen at airports?Yes, mainly on return from international travel
Is a bond hearing guaranteed?No. It depends on which detention law applies
Is there a blanket cancellation of green cards?No
Key Supreme Court rulingBlanche v. Lau, decided June 23, 2026 (6–3)

What Is Happening: The Washington Post Investigation

According to the Post, attorneys are seeing cases where permanent residents who renewed their cards without trouble were later detained over records that surfaced at a border crossing or in a government database check. The reported cases include:

  • A 75-year-old Texas woman, San Juanita Guerra, detained at the Progreso border crossing in March 2026 over a 1994 weapons case. She spent 22 days in detention before being released on bond, and her immigration case was still pending when the report ran.
  • Emiliano Andrade-Covarrubias, 56, of the Dallas area, who died in ICE custody on October 17, 2026, after being detained following a crossing from Mexico. ICE alleged he had not disclosed an old theft-related matter when he obtained status. His family disputes the government’s account and has raised concerns about his medical care.
  • A Florida permanent resident whose lawyer successfully challenged a detention tied to an erroneous voter-registration record.

These are individual cases as reported. They show how serious prolonged custody can be, but they do not prove that every green card detention is unlawful or that every old record leads to removal.

What the Supreme Court Decided in Blanche v. Lau

On June 23, 2026, the Supreme Court decided Blanche v. Muk Choi Lau, No. 25-429, by a 6–3 vote. Justice Thomas wrote for the majority. Justices Jackson, Sotomayor, and Kagan dissented.

The facts. Muk Choi Lau had been a permanent resident for nearly two decades. In 2012 he was charged with selling counterfeit goods. While the charge was pending he took a short trip abroad. When he returned through JFK Airport, officers did not admit him as a returning resident. They paroled him into the country and took his green card because of the pending charge.

The legal question. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(13)(C), a returning permanent resident is usually not treated as seeking a new admission. There are listed exceptions, including for a resident who has committed certain offenses described in the inadmissibility statute. The courts had split on how much proof an officer needs at the border before applying that exception. The Second Circuit had sided with Lau, while the Fifth and Ninth Circuits had taken a different view.

The holding. A border officer does not need clear and convincing evidence, at the moment of entry, that the returning resident committed a qualifying crime before treating that person as an applicant for admission.

What the ruling does not do

  • It does not make every returning green card holder with a record removable.
  • It does not decide that any particular offense is a crime involving moral turpitude. The Court left Lau’s own case open on that point.
  • It does not remove the government’s burden of proof in removal proceedings.
  • It does not let officers cancel permanent residence. Only an immigration judge can do that.

Why it still matters

The practical effect is on who carries the risk and delay at the border. A resident treated as an applicant for admission may face different legal grounds than someone treated as already admitted, may be paroled in or detained, and may have the physical card taken while the case plays out. Critics, including the dissent, argue this lets the government act first and justify it later. Defenders of the ruling point to the statutory text, which separates committing an offense (relevant to admission status) from conviction or admission requirements (relevant to inadmissibility).

ICE Detaining Green Card Holders in 2026, Can Old Crimes Lead to Deportation?

Can ICE Deport Someone Who Has Had a Green Card for 20 or 30 Years?

Yes, if the government proves a legal ground of removability and the person has no relief that prevents removal. There is no rule that an old conviction becomes safe after 10, 20, or 30 years.

The grounds of deportability are in 8 U.S.C. § 1227. They include certain aggravated felonies, qualifying crimes involving moral turpitude, controlled-substance offenses, firearms offenses, and certain immigration-related violations. For returning residents, 8 U.S.C. § 1182 (inadmissibility) can also come into play.

Not every crime qualifies. For example, the single-crime moral turpitude ground in § 1227 generally depends on how soon after admission the offense occurred and the sentence that could be imposed. Other grounds can reach older convictions without that limit. A traffic ticket or an arrest that never led to a qualifying conviction does not by itself establish deportability.

The exact statute of conviction, the sentence, the immigration history, and available exceptions all have to be examined by someone qualified to do it.

Which Records Can Cause Trouble?

Immigration law looks at the legal elements of the offense and its own definition of “conviction,” not just how old the case is or how it is labeled in state court.

Type of recordWhy it can matter
Crimes involving moral turpitudeSome theft, fraud, and forgery offenses can qualify, depending on the statute and potential sentence
Controlled-substance offensesMost drug convictions or formal admissions can matter, including state marijuana offenses; narrow exceptions exist
Domestic violence, stalking, child abuse, protective-order violationsSpecific deportability grounds under 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2)(E)
Firearms offensesSpecific deportability ground under 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2)(C)
Pending charges or unresolved criminal mattersCan raise problems on return from travel after Blanche v. Lau
False claims of citizenship or unlawful votingSeparate grounds under 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(6)(C)(ii) and § 1227(a)(6)
Omissions or errors in past immigration applicationsCan be alleged as misrepresentation or fraud
Long absences abroad (over 180 days)Can lead to the traveler being treated as seeking admission

Can ICE or CBP Detain Green Card Holders at Airports?

Yes, but the setting matters.

International arrivals. CBP conducts immigration inspection when a permanent resident returns from abroad. A traveler can be sent to secondary inspection, and ICE may become involved afterward.

Domestic flights. Passengers are not applying for admission, but ICE can still carry out enforcement at airports where it has legal authority.

Reporting in 2026 describes closer coordination between federal agencies and wider use of criminal-record and other government databases when travelers are screened.

Does a six-month trip abroad cost you your green card?

Not automatically. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(13)(C)(ii), a continuous absence of more than 180 days is one circumstance that can lead officers to treat a returning resident as seeking admission. Losing status through abandonment is a separate question that turns on intent and real ties to the United States. Anyone with a long trip planned, a prior removal order, or any criminal history should get individual advice first.

Can a Dismissed or Expunged Charge Still Cause a Problem?

Potentially, but the government still needs a valid legal basis for detention or removal.

An arrest alone generally does not satisfy provisions that require a conviction. However, 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(48)(A) defines “conviction” for immigration purposes differently from many state laws. Some guilty pleas and deferred adjudications count as convictions for immigration purposes even if state records show the case was later dismissed. Expungement does not always erase immigration consequences either.

This is why immigration attorneys ask for certified court dispositions instead of relying on an online background check.

Can Voter Registration Lead to Detention?

It can, depending on the facts. Federal law attaches consequences to false claims of U.S. citizenship and certain unlawful voting. But registering and voting are not the same act, and not every registration mistake is fraud. What matters is what the person signed, whether the claim was knowing, and whether any exception applies. Permanent residents should never complete a voter-registration form without confirming eligibility, and anyone who already made an error should speak with an immigration attorney before traveling.

What Happens When a Green Card Holder Is Detained?

Immigration detention is a civil process, though it is often triggered by criminal history. Depending on the case, authorities may:

  1. Question the person about immigration and criminal history.
  2. Review records and conduct further screening.
  3. Serve a Notice to Appear (Form I-862) that lists the alleged grounds for removal.
  4. Move the person to an immigration detention facility.
  5. Decide whether release on bond or other custody review is available.
  6. Proceed before an immigration judge.

A Notice to Appear is an allegation. It does not mean the green card has been lawfully terminated.

Is a detained green card holder entitled to a bond hearing?

Not always. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a), some detainees can ask an immigration judge for a custody review. But § 1226(c) requires mandatory detention for certain categories, which limits bond eligibility. Congress expanded some mandatory detention provisions in 2025. Courts have also been asked to decide when long detention of permanent residents requires an individualized hearing, and that area is still developing. Holding a green card for many years does not by itself guarantee a bond hearing.

For more on this distinction, see Supreme Court Dismisses Immigration Detention Case That Was Set for October Argument.

What To Do If ICE or CBP Detains a Green Card Holder

Time matters, because detention locations and court schedules can change fast.

1. Locate the person. Use the official ICE Online Detainee Locator: locator.ice.gov/odls. You may need the full name, country of birth, or Alien Registration Number (A-number). A person may not appear right away, especially while in CBP custody.

2. Check immigration court status. Use the Department of Justice case-status system at acis.eoir.justice.gov or call 1-800-898-7180. You generally need the A-number, and a new case may not show up immediately.

3. Contact an immigration attorney. Ask the lawyer to review the legal basis for custody, the certified criminal records, the person’s admission history, bond eligibility, and possible defenses. People in immigration proceedings have a right to hire counsel, but the government does not automatically provide one.

4. Gather documents. Useful records include the green card, passport, prior immigration approvals, certified court records, proof of family ties and employment, and any prior immigration decisions. If there are medical needs, tell the attorney and the facility right away.

5. Do not sign away permanent residence without advice. Form I-407 records the abandonment of permanent resident status. USCIS states that submitting it is voluntary. A resident who disputes an abandonment claim can ask for review before an immigration judge. Do not sign anything you do not understand, especially a document that waives rights. See the official USCIS Form I-407 page.

6. Be careful what you say. Give your identity documents, but speak with a lawyer before answering detailed questions about past arrests, pleas, or applications.

For more on encounters with immigration officers, see Your Rights When ICE Stops You: Citizens, Green Card Holders, and Undocumented.

Can a Green Card Holder Fight Deportation and Keep Status?

Often, yes, depending on the facts. Possible defenses include arguing that the offense is not a qualifying crime, disputing fraud or misrepresentation allegations, showing that a ground of inadmissibility or deportability does not apply, or applying for a waiver.

Some residents may qualify for cancellation of removal under 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(a). The basic requirements are:

  • At least five years as a lawful permanent resident.
  • At least seven years of continuous residence in the United States after admission in any status.
  • No aggravated felony conviction.

Other rules apply, including some that stop the clock on continuous residence. Cancellation is discretionary, so meeting the basic conditions does not guarantee relief. A resident who wins in immigration court keeps permanent resident status.

Anyone who believes the detention was unlawful may also want to learn about separate civil claims. See Can You Sue ICE for Wrongful Arrest? Legal Grounds and Realistic Outcomes.

Practical Steps Before You Travel

  • If you have any prior arrest, citation, pending charge, or expunged case, have an immigration attorney review the certified disposition before booking international travel.
  • Do the same before filing Form N-400 for citizenship.
  • Carry your green card and passport, and keep copies of key court and immigration documents somewhere you can reach them.
  • Do not assume that a clean renewal in the past means an old record was cleared. Renewing the card is not a waiver.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can ICE arrest someone with a valid 10-year green card?

Yes. A valid card does not stop enforcement of immigration law. But an arrest alone does not establish that the person is deportable.

Can ICE deport someone for a crime committed 20 years ago?

Potentially. Some removal grounds apply to older convictions. The exact offense, the statute, and available defenses decide the outcome.

Does renewing a green card mean an old conviction was forgiven?

No. A renewed card is not a waiver or a ruling that the conviction has no immigration consequences.

Are green card holders deported automatically at airports?

No. There is no automatic-deportation rule. Questioning or detention at the border can lead to removal proceedings, where the government must still prove its case and the resident can raise defenses.

Can an officer take away a green card without a judge?

Officers may take the physical card in some custody situations, but that does not end permanent resident status. Only an immigration judge can order removal.

What did Blanche v. Lau change for green card holders?

It held that border officers do not need clear and convincing evidence at entry before treating a returning permanent resident as an applicant for admission based on alleged criminal conduct. The government still has to prove its grounds in removal proceedings.

Can green card holders travel safely within the United States?

Domestic travel is not prohibited for permanent residents. But airport enforcement can create risk for people with unresolved immigration issues or criminal history.

How much does an immigration lawyer cost?

Fees vary widely by city, case complexity, and whether emergency court filings or a removal hearing are involved. Immigration defense is usually billed as a flat or hourly fee rather than a contingency fee, so ask for a written fee agreement before hiring.

Bottom Line

Longtime permanent residents are facing closer scrutiny over old criminal and immigration records, especially when they travel. Blanche v. Lau gives border officers more room to act at the port of entry. But there is no blanket cancellation of green cards, and neither an old arrest nor a detention automatically means a person can be deported. If you have a prior arrest, a pending charge, a voter-registration question, or a discrepancy in an old application, get your documents reviewed by a qualified immigration attorney before you travel. If a family member is already detained, locating them, learning the legal basis for custody, and getting counsel are the first priorities.

Sources and Official Resources

  1. Supreme Court opinion: Blanche v. Lau, No. 25-429 (June 23, 2026)
  2. 8 U.S.C. § 1101: Definitions, including returning residents and “conviction”
  3. 8 U.S.C. § 1182: Inadmissible noncitizens
  4. 8 U.S.C. § 1226: Detention
  5. 8 U.S.C. § 1227: Deportable noncitizens
  6. 8 U.S.C. § 1229b: Cancellation of removal
  7. ICE Online Detainee Locator
  8. DOJ Immigration Court Case Status
  9. USCIS Form I-407
  10. The Washington Post, November 17, 2026: ICE detentions involving longtime green card holders

Legal disclaimer: AllAboutLawyer.com is an information site, not a law firm, and this article is general information about U.S. immigration law, not legal advice. Immigration consequences of criminal history are highly fact-specific. Anyone facing detention, travel with a record, or a removal case should consult a licensed immigration attorney.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *