New Haven Sues Westport Insurance Over $30.5 Million Wrongful Conviction Settlement, What the Lawsuit Means
The City of New Haven, Connecticut, has filed a federal lawsuit against Westport Insurance Corporation, alleging that the insurer breached its contract by refusing to fully cover a $30.5 million settlement paid to Vernon Horn and Marquis Jackson, two men who spent nearly two decades in prison for a murder they did not commit.
The complaint was filed on November 13, 2026, and publicly reported on November 16. It comes three months after the city agreed to pay Horn and Jackson $15.25 million each to resolve their federal civil-rights cases.
The new case does not challenge the men’s exonerations and does not create a second $30.5 million payment. It concerns who must pay the compensation already agreed upon: the city, its insurer, or both.
The case is City of New Haven v. Westport Insurance Corporation, No. 3:26-cv-01989, U.S. District Court for the District of Connecticut. No ruling on coverage has been announced.
Quick Facts: New Haven v. Westport Insurance
| Detail | Information |
| Case | City of New Haven v. Westport Insurance Corporation |
| Case number | 3:26-cv-01989 |
| Filed | November 13, 2026 (reported November 16) |
| Court | U.S. District Court, District of Connecticut |
| Main claim | Alleged breach of insurance contract |
| Combined settlements | 30.5million(15.25 million each to Horn and Jackson) |
| Insurance contribution initially expected | $5 million |
| City share initially expected | $25.5 million |
| Bond authorization | Up to $27 million (Ordinance OR-2026-0030) |
| Convictions vacated | 2018 |
| Status | Newly filed; no coverage ruling |
| Public claim form for residents | None |
Why Is New Haven Suing Westport Insurance?
When the settlements were announced on August 12, 2026, Mayor Justin Elicker said insurance would cover $5 million of the total plus the defense costs of the relevant defendants, leaving the city responsible for $25.5 million.
According to published reporting on the city’s 31-page complaint, New Haven alleges that Westport paid only part of what the city believes is owed under the applicable liability policies, and that Westport wrongly denied fuller coverage.
Why did Westport refuse additional coverage?
Based on that reporting, Westport’s position is that the Horn and Jackson lawsuits did not involve “bodily injury” or “personal injury” as those terms are defined in the policies.
New Haven disagrees. It points to allegations of physical harm, pain, scarring, mental anguish and psychological injury during the men’s imprisonment, and argues that these claims fall within the policies’ coverage and that Westport breached its duty to indemnify the city.
The central question is whether a policy covering bodily or personal injury must pay damages arising from wrongful imprisonment and alleged police misconduct. The answer depends on the actual policy wording, coverage periods, exclusions and definitions. A wrongful-conviction suit is not automatically covered by every municipal policy, and an insurer cannot defeat coverage simply by saying the case is about constitutional rights rather than physical harm. The court must interpret the specific contract.
Westport has not publicly responded in detail to the lawsuit.
Has Westport been found to have breached its contract?
No. These are allegations only. As of November 17, 2026, no court has ordered Westport to pay additional settlement money.
Who Are Vernon Horn and Marquis Jackson?
On January 24, 1999, 22-year-old Caprice Hardy was shot and killed during a robbery at the Dixwell Deli in New Haven. Horn and Jackson were convicted at a joint trial in 2000. Horn received a 70-year sentence and Jackson a 45-year sentence.
What led to their exonerations in 2018?
A reinvestigation uncovered telephone-record evidence that undermined the prosecution’s account and raised serious doubt about whether Horn could have been at the deli. In 2018, Connecticut authorities moved to vacate the convictions and the charges were dismissed. Horn had served about 17 years and Jackson about 19.
The exonerations ended the criminal cases but did not compensate the men for the years lost. They then filed federal civil-rights lawsuits against the City of New Haven, former detectives and a state forensic examiner.
What Misconduct Did Horn and Jackson Allege?
Their lawsuits, brought mainly under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleged suppression of favorable evidence, improper witness-interview tactics, fabrication of evidence and failure to intervene.
What did the federal court decide in March 2024?
In a March 19, 2024 ruling, Judge Robert N. Chatigny allowed the Brady v. Maryland evidence-suppression claims and certain failure-to-intervene claims to proceed toward trial. The court granted summary judgment to the detectives on the fabrication-of-evidence and unreasonably prolonged detention claims addressed in that ruling.
The court did not find that every allegation was proven. The parties settled before trial, so no jury decided the surviving claims. Official document: March 19, 2024 ruling.
How Much Did New Haven Agree to Pay?
| Recipient or source | Amount |
| Vernon Horn | $15,250,000 |
| Marquis Jackson | $15,250,000 |
| Combined settlement | $30,500,000 |
| Initially expected insurance contribution | $5,000,000 |
| Initially expected city responsibility | $25,500,000 |
These were negotiated settlements, not jury awards. Full background: New Haven’s $30.5 Million Wrongful Conviction Settlement.
Why Did New Haven Authorize $27 Million in Borrowing?
On October 5, 2026, the Board of Alders enacted Ordinance OR-2026-0030, authorizing up to $27 million in general-obligation bonds to finance the settlements through the city’s litigation self-insurance fund. That is a maximum authorization, slightly above the $25.5 million city share. It is not a new award to Horn or Jackson, and it does not by itself show that the full amount has been borrowed. Official source: Ordinance OR-2026-0030.
Will New Haven taxpayers have to pay?
General-obligation bonds are repaid with interest from the city’s financial resources, so borrowing can affect future budgets. But authorization does not establish a specific property-tax increase. The impact depends on the amount actually borrowed, interest rates set in the bond sale, the repayment schedule and future budget decisions.

Could winning the lawsuit reduce the city’s costs?
Potentially. Additional reimbursement could lower the city’s net burden. But the amount recoverable is uncertain and could depend on policy limits, deductibles, exclusions, other insurance and what Westport has already paid. It would be inaccurate to assume the city will recover the full $25.5 million.
Is this part of a larger financial pressure on the city?
Reporting indicates New Haven faces other large wrongful-conviction claims, including a reported $38 million federal jury verdict in the Stefon Morant case, which the city is reportedly appealing. That context is based on news reports and was not independently verified against court records for this article.
What Connecticut Insurance Law Applies?
This is an insurance contract dispute, not a new constitutional claim by Horn or Jackson.
1. Policy interpretation. Connecticut courts read an insurance policy as a whole, including coverage grants, definitions, exclusions and conditions. Genuinely ambiguous language is generally construed in favor of the insured, but courts do not rewrite clear policy terms to create coverage never promised. See Capstone Building Corp. v. American Motorists Insurance Co., 308 Conn. 760 (2013).
2. Duty to defend vs. duty to indemnify. The duty to defend is broader and is triggered when allegations potentially fall within coverage. The duty to indemnify requires payment of a covered judgment or settlement according to the policy and the actual basis of liability. Insurer-paid defense costs do not mean every settlement dollar is covered. See DaCruz v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., 268 Conn. 675 (2004).
3. “Bodily injury” and “personal injury.” Bodily injury coverage generally concerns physical injury, sickness or disease. Personal injury coverage may include listed offenses such as false arrest, wrongful detention or malicious prosecution. Definitions vary by insurer and policy period, so the exact Westport wording will matter.
4. Breach of contract. New Haven must show a valid policy, an obligation owed by Westport, a failure to perform and recoverable loss. Westport can contest each element and raise policy defenses. A large settlement does not by itself prove breach.
5. Why federal court? The docket identifies jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332 (diversity jurisdiction). New Haven is a Connecticut municipality, and reporting identifies Westport as Missouri-based. Federal court does not mean a federal crime is alleged. This remains a civil contract case.
Which Federal Civil-Rights Laws Applied in the Original Cases?
- 42 U.S.C. § 1983: civil remedy for federal rights violations under color of state law.
- Fourteenth Amendment: due process protections against tainted convictions.
- Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963): duty to disclose material favorable evidence.
- Giglio v. United States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972): duty to disclose evidence bearing on witness credibility.
- Monell v. Department of Social Services, 436 U.S. 658 (1978): when a municipality is liable for violations caused by its policies or customs.
These laws explain the underlying suits. They do not decide whether Westport’s policy covers the settlement. For a different wrongful-detention example, see Jason Killinger Lawsuit Update.
Did Connecticut Already Compensate Horn and Jackson?
Yes. Before the municipal settlements, both men received state wrongful-incarceration awards.
| Recipient | State award |
| Vernon Horn | $4,817,954 |
| Marquis Jackson | $5,312,921 |
| Combined | $10,130,875 |
These awards are separate from the $30.5 million settlements and are not at issue in the Westport lawsuit. The state compensation procedure is in Connecticut General Statutes § 54-102uu.
Does the Lawsuit Affect Horn and Jackson’s Payments?
The suit concerns the city’s right to reimbursement from its insurer. It does not seek to revoke the settlement agreements. The city’s obligation to the two men and its dispute with Westport are separate legal relationships. Available records confirm the settlements and the borrowing authorization but do not establish the date each man received full payment, so the filing should not be read as proof that either man has been denied agreed compensation.
Can Other Residents File Claims?
No. These were settlements of two individual lawsuits, not a class action. There is no claims administrator, eligibility form or public compensation fund. Anyone who believes they were wrongfully arrested, convicted or imprisoned should consult a licensed attorney about their own circumstances and filing deadlines.
What Happens Next?
- Westport responds to the complaint or files a preliminary motion.
- The parties address which policies, limits and exclusions apply.
- The court may consider motions on contract interpretation and coverage.
- The parties may settle or proceed toward further rulings and possibly trial.
Possible outcomes include a ruling for New Haven, a ruling for Westport, a partial coverage ruling or a negotiated resolution. No additional reimbursement has been ordered as of November 17, 2026. A coverage ruling also would not mean every allegation of police misconduct was proven. For a different insurer-policyholder dispute, see Allianz Must Face Igloo Products Corp.’s Insurance Lawsuit.
Timeline
| Date | Development |
| January 24, 1999 | Caprice Hardy killed in Dixwell Deli robbery |
| 2000 | Horn and Jackson convicted |
| 2018 | Convictions vacated; charges dismissed |
| September 2018 | Horn files federal civil-rights suit |
| March 2019 | Jackson files federal civil-rights suit |
| March 19, 2024 | Federal ruling on detectives’ summary judgment motion |
| August 12, 2026 | New Haven announces $30.5 million settlements |
| October 5, 2026 | Board of Alders authorizes up to $27 million in bonds |
| November 13, 2026 | City files suit against Westport Insurance |
| November 16, 2026 | Lawsuit publicly reported |
| November 17, 2026 | Coverage dispute unresolved |
Why This Case Matters Beyond New Haven
Municipalities buy liability insurance to protect public budgets, but coverage for alleged police misconduct and wrongful imprisonment raises hard questions. Policy periods, definitions, exclusions and the type of injury claimed can decide whether an insurer must pay. Other cities facing similar claims may watch the outcome closely. For residents, the immediate question is how much of the $30.5 million ultimately falls on city finances. For Horn and Jackson, the underlying issue remains the years lost to convictions that were later vacated.
Bottom Line: Must Westport Pay More of the $30.5 Million?
That question is unresolved. New Haven alleges Westport failed to provide coverage its policies require. Westport reportedly disputes that the alleged injuries qualify. The city planned for a $5 million insurance contribution and a $25.5 million city share. Success could reduce the city’s exposure, but no court has ordered additional payment.
Official Sources and Court Records
- City of New Haven v. Westport Insurance Corporation, No. 3:26-cv-01989: Federal Docket
- City of New Haven: Mayor Elicker’s August 12, 2026 Settlement Announcement
- New Haven Board of Alders: Ordinance OR-2026-0030
- U.S. District Court: March 19, 2024 Ruling
- Connecticut General Statutes § 54-102uu
- 28 U.S.C. § 1332
Research note: The federal docket confirms the new complaint. Coverage-denial details come from contemporaneous reporting describing the complaint. The full 31-page complaint and the policy terms were not independently reviewed and should be checked against the filed documents when available. Reports of the filing date varied by one day; this article uses the docket date of November 13, 2026.
Legal disclaimer: This article provides general legal information, not legal advice. Allegations in pending lawsuits are not findings of wrongdoing, and insurance-coverage rights depend on the applicable contract and law. Consult a licensed attorney for advice on your situation.
Researched and written by Israr Ahmad, Legal Content Researcher, AllAboutLawyer.com.
About the Author
Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.
