|

New York Shield Law 2026, Can Another State Obtain Your Abortion or Medical Records?

New York has strengthened protections against out-of-state attempts to obtain abortion records, reproductive-health information, and other sensitive medical data. On November 9, 2026, Attorney General Letitia James released updated guidance explaining when hospitals, doctors, technology companies, and individuals can legally disclose this information.

An out-of-state subpoena does not automatically give another state access to abortion records held in New York. Under the Shield Law, covered record holders generally must check what the request is for, get a sworn statement, notify the Attorney General and the affected people, and wait 30 days before disclosing anything, unless an exception applies.

The law can also protect people who get medication abortion through telehealth from New York-based providers, even when the patient lives in another state.

The Shield Law does not make every medical record permanently confidential, override every valid court order, or stop other states from starting their own investigations.

New York Shield Law 2026: Quick Facts

QuestionAnswer
LawNew York Shield Law, including Shield Law 2.0 (signed December 2025)
Latest guidanceNovember 9, 2026
OfficialAttorney General Letitia James
Principal information-disclosure lawGeneral Business Law § 394-i
Covered healthcareAbortion, reproductive care, and gender-affirming healthcare that is legal under New York law
Protected recordsMedical, billing, location, internet-search, and other qualifying information
Out-of-state subpoenasSubject to statutory restrictions
Notice to the Attorney GeneralGenerally within five business days, subject to timing rules
Notice to affected peopleGenerally at least 30 days before disclosure
Waiting periodGenerally 30 calendar days after required notices
Penalty for improper disclosure$10,000 per qualifying violation
Penalty for false sworn affirmation$15,000 per qualifying violation
Can patients get their own records?Yes
Can another state still investigate?Yes, but New York restricts certain cooperation

What Is the Shield Law, and Why Was It Created?

New York’s Shield Law is a set of state statutes designed to protect patients, healthcare professionals, and people helping others get reproductive or gender-affirming healthcare. The first protections followed the U.S. Supreme Court’s June 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which overturned Roe v. Wade.

After Dobbs, states took different approaches. Some prohibit most abortions and seek to enforce restrictions against providers. New York generally protects reproductive healthcare that is lawful under its own statutes. That creates hard interstate questions: What happens if a person in a restrictive state gets medication abortion from a New York physician? Can the other state demand patient records, sue the physician, or seek extradition?

The Shield Law answers by limiting how New York officials, courts, organizations, and businesses can assist certain out-of-state efforts to impose legal consequences for protected care. Shield Law 2.0, signed in December 2025, extended protections to more professionals and set stronger rules for information requests. The November 9 guidance explains how those rules work in practice.

Who and What Is Protected?

Protected Care

Abortion care (including medication abortion prescribed through telehealth by New York clinicians) and gender-affirming care that is lawful under New York law.

Who Is Protected

Per the Attorney General’s guidance, protection can extend to:

  • Patients and people managing their own care, wherever they live
  • Healthcare professionals in New York, including physicians, nurse practitioners, pharmacists, and mental health clinicians, while physically located in New York
  • Families and guardians who consent to care for a child
  • Clinic staff, volunteers, insurers, and attorneys who take part in or advise on protected care
  • People helping with payment or travel to an appointment, in qualifying circumstances

For healthcare professionals and helpers, protection generally depends on being physically in New York while taking part in the protected activity. The guidance specifically addresses telehealth, including medication abortion provided by a physician physically in New York to a patient elsewhere.

Related article: Arizona Photo Radar Ban 2026, Are Speed Cameras and Red-Light Cameras Still Legal?

New York Shield Law 2026, Can Another State Obtain Your Abortion or Medical Records?

Which Medical Records Are Protected?

Information can qualify if it can reasonably be connected to a person’s or entity’s past, present, or future involvement in legally protected healthcare.

InformationPotential Protection
Abortion clinic recordsYes
Medication abortion prescriptionsYes
Miscarriage treatment recordsYes
Fertility and IVF informationYes
Contraception recordsYes
Pregnancy and prenatal recordsYes
STI testing or treatmentYes
Gender-affirming healthcare recordsYes
Billing and insurance records tied to protected careYes
Search histories about protected carePotentially
Location records showing visits for protected carePotentially
Ordinary records unrelated to protected careNot covered just because they are private

Protection depends on the information, the request’s purpose, the record holder’s connection to New York, and the statutory exceptions. A record doesn’t have to be in a traditional hospital database to qualify.

Can Texas or Another State Subpoena Records From New York?

Another state can try, but New York law restricts when records can be obtained or disclosed. Suppose a Texas investigator asks a New York clinic for records identifying patients who received lawfully provided medication abortions. The clinic generally cannot hand them over just because it received a subpoena.

  • General Business Law § 394-i requires covered recipients to follow set procedures before complying with requests about legally protected health activity.
  • Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR) § 3119 limits when an out-of-state subpoena can be made enforceable through New York courts. Anyone trying to domesticate one must submit the required sworn affirmation of a permissible purpose.

An investigation meant to punish someone for providing care protected under New York law does not become permissible just because another state started it.

What If the Subpoena Comes From a Judge?

The issuing court and the legal basis matter. A subpoena issued outside New York is not automatically enforceable in New York, and New York courts and lawyers are restricted from issuing or domesticating subpoenas meant to punish protected healthcare. A court order that is valid and enforceable in New York may change particular notice or waiting requirements, and federal court orders can raise additional questions of federal law and jurisdiction. A provider that receives such a demand should get legal advice instead of ignoring it or producing records without review.

Do Period-Tracking Apps, Searches, and Payment Records Count?

Potentially, yes. The guidance covers data held outside traditional healthcare. Covered recipients can include social-media companies, mobile apps, payment platforms, nonprofits, individuals, and businesses located, headquartered, or incorporated in New York. If a request for someone’s period-tracking history or payment records concerns legally protected health activity, the recipient may have to follow the Shield Law’s disclosure procedures.

New York law also restricts law enforcement from buying or obtaining certain electronic health data from non-HIPAA organizations without a warrant, including location data tied to healthcare facilities and records of payments for medical services.

Limitation: The law does not guarantee that every technology company anywhere in the country must follow New York’s disclosure rules. The company’s legal location, the type of records, and the requesting authority’s jurisdiction all matter.

What Must Doctors and Businesses Do When They Receive a Request?

General Business Law § 394-i sets out a structured process, which the November 9 guidance summarizes in four steps.

Step 1: Decide Whether the Request Concerns Protected Healthcare

The recipient must examine whether the request focuses on legally protected reproductive or gender-affirming care or seeks protected information. If coverage is unclear, the guidance says the recipient should get a sworn Coverage Affirmation from the requestor, stating that the request doesn’t concern protected activity, that any protected information would be incidental, and that the records won’t be used to punish protected care.

Step 2: Get a Sworn Affirmation of Permitted Purpose

For covered requests, the recipient generally must get an Affirmation of Permitted Purpose. The requestor swears, under penalty of perjury, that the records will not be used to impose civil, criminal, or professional consequences for protected care. An alternative permitted purpose is a patient-initiated tort or contract claim that would be actionable in New York. Without the required affirmation, the recipient generally cannot produce the information. The Attorney General provides an official affirmation form.

Step 3: Notify the Attorney General and Affected People

The recipient generally must notify the Attorney General within five business days of receiving the request (or by the earlier statutory deadline), usually including a copy of the subpoena and related documents. It must also make reasonable efforts to notify the patients, providers, or others whose protected information would be disclosed, generally at least 30 days before disclosure. The Attorney General provides an official notice form.

Step 4: Observe the 30-Day Waiting Period

The recipient generally must wait 30 calendar days after the required notices before producing anything. That gives affected people and the Attorney General time to evaluate the request and challenge it, for example by moving to quash a subpoena.

This is not a mandatory 30-day wait for every medical-record request. Statutory exceptions and enforceable court orders can change the steps.

Are There Exceptions That Allow Records to Be Shared?

Yes. The law does not bar legitimate uses of medical information.

  • Patient requests and consent: Patients and their authorized representatives can get their own records, and a valid written authorization or HIPAA release can allow a specified disclosure without the ordinary Shield Law steps.
  • Treatment and routine billing: Appropriate sharing for treatment, care coordination, insurance claims, and ordinary billing can continue under applicable rules.
  • Patient-initiated lawsuits: Certain malpractice or contract cases brought by patients can qualify as a permitted disclosure.
  • Defense against an investigation: A person or organization targeted over protected care can request information needed for its defense, subject to the required sworn statement.
  • Government audits and grant reporting: Certain disclosures of de-identified information, or identifying information strictly necessary for qualifying audits, remain permitted.
  • Conduct that violates New York law: The Shield Law does not prevent investigations of conduct that would violate New York law, such as certain healthcare misconduct. Covered requests generally still require the disclosure steps unless an exception or enforceable court order changes them.

What New York Agencies and Courts Can’t Do

The Shield Law also limits how New York government itself may cooperate with out-of-state efforts. According to the guidance and statutory summaries, New York state and local agencies and courts are restricted from enforcing out-of-state subpoenas or extradition demands aimed at protected care, and from using protected care against someone in certain New York proceedings. The law also limits professional discipline and malpractice-insurance consequences based solely on providing or advising on protected care. Check the statutory text for the exact scope in a particular situation.

Does HIPAA Protect Abortion Records in 2026?

Yes, the ordinary federal HIPAA Privacy Rule still protects qualifying medical information held by covered entities and business associates. There is an important distinction, though.

In April 2024, the federal government adopted extra HIPAA restrictions designed to protect information tied to lawful reproductive healthcare. On June 18, 2025, a federal district court in Texas vacated most of those special amendments in Purl v. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, No. 2:24-cv-00228, and HHS acknowledges the ruling in its current guidance.

The special 2024 HIPAA reproductive-health restrictions should not be described as fully enforceable in 2026. Ordinary HIPAA requirements remain, including safeguards, rules on permitted disclosures, and patient access to records. New York’s Shield Law provides separate state protections that can go beyond HIPAA’s general rules, so the two must be analyzed together when a provider receives a request.

Does the Shield Law Protect Patients Who Live Outside New York?

Potentially, yes. According to the November 9 guidance, protections for patients and people managing their own healthcare can apply regardless of where they received protected care. That does not mean New York can stop every legal action in another state. A patient who is physically outside New York may face separate legal questions under that state’s law.

The Texas and Louisiana Cases Involving a New York Provider

Interstate disputes have already tested the Shield Law’s limits.

  • Texas pursued civil proceedings against New York physician Margaret Daley Carpenter over allegations that she provided medication abortion to a Texas resident.
  • Louisiana separately pursued criminal charges over alleged medication-abortion services to a patient in Louisiana.
  • In February 2025, Governor Kathy Hochul refused Louisiana’s extradition request, relying on the Shield Law.
  • An Ulster County clerk refused to accept papers to enforce a Texas judgment against the physician, and a New York court later upheld the clerk’s reliance on the law, according to the Attorney General’s updated guidance. Further litigation continues.

These cases show the difference between another state starting a proceeding and successfully enforcing it through New York institutions. They do not show that all interstate disputes are resolved or that New York can stop proceedings outside its borders.

Can New York Doctors Be Extradited?

New York law generally restricts extradition of people accused of legally protected healthcare. There is one exception, which the Attorney General explains: extradition can remain available under the statutory fugitive-from-justice exception when the request shows the accused was physically in the requesting state when the alleged offense happened and later fled it (see Criminal Procedure Law § 570.17). The Shield Law does not remove federal jurisdiction or stop another state from filing charges. It limits specified forms of New York cooperation and enforcement.

What Penalties Apply for Violating the Law?

General Business Law § 394-i provides civil penalties:

ViolationStatutory Penalty
Intentionally, knowingly, willingly, or recklessly violating the disclosure restrictions$10,000 per qualifying violation
Intentionally, knowingly, willingly, or recklessly submitting a false required affirmation$15,000 per qualifying violation

These are enforcement penalties, including actions by the Attorney General. They are not automatic payments to patients.

Can Someone Sue Under the Shield Law?

Yes, in some circumstances. A person or business that receives a covered information request can bring an action for a declaration that compliance is prohibited, generally within one year of receiving or being served with the request (whichever is later). A prevailing plaintiff may recover reasonable costs and attorney’s fees.

Separately, New York Civil Rights Law § 70-b lets certain people targeted by lawsuits or criminal charges over legally protected healthcare bring an action for compensatory damages and legal costs. Additional damages of up to three times compensatory damages can be available when the required malicious purpose is shown. The deadline for that claim is generally six years. Eligibility and remedies depend on the claim and the proof.

Related Reading on AllAboutLawyer.com

What Should Patients Do If They’re Worried About Disclosure?

  1. Ask your provider about its disclosure policies and whether it has received any legal request for your records.
  2. Request a copy of your own records and review what is held and whether corrections are appropriate.
  3. Ask about confidentiality options, including lawful communication preferences and limits on certain disclosures.
  4. Don’t sign broad releases without understanding them. A signed authorization can allow access to sensitive information.
  5. Be careful about where records are copied. Syncing a patient portal into outside apps or third-party health trackers can put information in places the Shield Law may not reach.
  6. Keep contact details current with your provider so you receive any notice before a covered disclosure.
  7. Keep copies of legal notices, such as subpoenas, letters, and any notice that records may be released.
  8. Get legal help promptly. A lawyer can evaluate whether a request can be challenged or limited.

Don’t alter or destroy records to interfere with a lawful investigation, and don’t delay needed medical care because of concerns about future record requests. For help, contact the Attorney General at [email protected], or call the state’s reproductive-health legal information hotline at 212-899-5567.

Can Parents Get a Minor’s Reproductive-Health Records?

It depends on the patient’s age, the type of care, consent laws, and confidentiality rules. New York allows minors to consent on their own to certain healthcare in specified circumstances, and a parent doesn’t automatically have unrestricted access to every confidential record. The Shield Law protects certain parents and guardians who help children get legally protected care, but it does not remove New York’s ordinary rules on child protection, medical consent, or professional misconduct.

Does the Shield Law Change Abortion Rights in Other States?

No. The guidance does not repeal another state’s abortion law. It explains New York’s existing protections and how to respond to covered requests. New York’s limits on cooperation should not be confused with a nationwide rule that makes abortion lawful in every state.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Texas obtain abortion records from a New York hospital?

Not automatically. A covered request must satisfy New York’s statutory restrictions, including sworn statements, notification procedures, and any applicable court rules.

Does New York protect abortion pill prescriptions through telehealth?

The Shield Law can protect legally provided medication abortion by healthcare professionals physically in New York, including qualifying services to out-of-state patients.

Does the law protect search histories and period-tracking data?

Potentially. The guidance covers information reasonably connected with legally protected healthcare, including search, location, and billing data. Whether it applies depends on the request and the record holder.

Can doctors share records for treatment?

Yes. Appropriate treatment-related sharing is allowed under applicable consent and privacy rules.

Can I still get my own records from a New York clinic?

Yes. Patients keep their right to request and receive their own records.

Does every subpoena trigger a 30-day delay?

No. Only requests covered by the requirements, and not excused or modified by an exception or enforceable court order, trigger the full procedure.

Can patients sue someone who tries to punish them for protected care?

In qualifying cases, yes. Civil Rights Law § 70-b creates a civil claim with possible damages and legal fees.

Are the $10,000 and $15,000 penalties automatic settlements?

No. They are statutory civil penalties for qualifying violations, not a public compensation program.

Does New York protect records stored outside the state?

Whether New York can regulate a given disclosure depends on the record holder, jurisdiction, and applicable law. The Shield Law is not universal protection for every record stored elsewhere.

What Happens Next?

The November 9 guidance explains New York’s existing protections. It is not a new abortion ban, a class action settlement, or a new court ruling. The Attorney General’s Office is providing forms and instructions to help patients, providers, and businesses comply. Future litigation may clarify how the Shield Law interacts with out-of-state judgments, federal information demands, and interstate telehealth. The next meaningful update would be a court decision on enforcing the Shield Law against an out-of-state judgment, or a material change to federal medical-privacy rules.

Bottom line: New York’s Shield Law makes it harder for another state to use New York healthcare records to punish legally protected abortion or gender-affirming care. But disclosure is not prohibited in every circumstance, and patients and providers should look carefully at subpoenas, consent forms, and court orders before any information is released.

Disclaimer: AllAboutLawyer.com provides independent legal information, not personalized medical or legal advice. Whether the Shield Law applies depends on the healthcare activity, the records, the jurisdiction, the request, and the exceptions.

Researched by AllAboutLawyer.com, Legal Content Research. Last reviewed: November 16, 2026.

Sources

  1. New York Attorney General, Shield Law Guidance (November 9, 2026): https://ag.ny.gov/shield-law-guidance
  2. Attorney General James, November 9 guidance announcement: https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2026/attorney-general-james-releases-guidance-new-yorks-shield-law
  3. New York General Business Law § 394-i: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/GBS/394-I
  4. New York CPLR § 3119: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/CVP/3119
  5. New York Civil Rights Law § 70-b: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/CVR/70-B
  6. New York Criminal Procedure Law § 570.17: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/CPL/570.17
  7. New York Attorney General, Shield Law Quick Guide (PDF): https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2026-11/shield-law-quick-guide.pdf
  8. New York Attorney General, official affirmation form (PDF): https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2026-11/shieldlaw-affirmationform.pdf
  9. New York Attorney General, official notice form: https://ag.ny.gov/shield-law-notice
  10. HHS, Reproductive Health Privacy Rule and 2025 court decision: https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/special-topics/reproductive-health/final-rule-fact-sheet/index.html
  11. New York Attorney General, Reproductive Rights and Legal Assistance: https://ag.ny.gov/resources/individuals/health-care-insurance/reproductive-rights-abortion-legal-new-york
  12. Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022); Purl v. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, No. 2:24-cv-00228 (N.D. Tex. June 18, 2025)

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *