Honeywell Tobacco Surcharge Class Action 2026, Can Employees Recover $1,000 Health Insurance Fees?

Honeywell International Inc. faces a new proposed class action alleging that employees and covered spouses were charged $1,000 or more a year in health insurance tobacco surcharges without the protections federal employee benefits law requires.

The case is Bolen v. Honeywell International Inc., No. 3:26-cv-00978, filed November 13, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of North Carolina. Former employee William Bolen alleges Honeywell violated the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) by imposing tobacco penalties without adequate alternatives or proper disclosures. The complaint also challenges Honeywell’s biometric-screening program, including extra charges for employees who skipped screenings.

Can employees recover the money? Possibly, but no refunds have been ordered. The case is new. No class has been certified, and there is no settlement, claim form, or guaranteed payment. Honeywell has not been found liable, and every allegation below is unproven.

Honeywell Tobacco Surcharge Lawsuit: Quick Facts

DetailInformation
DefendantHoneywell International Inc.
PlaintiffWilliam Bolen
FiledNovember 13, 2026
CourtU.S. District Court, Western District of North Carolina
Case number3:26-cv-00978
TypeProposed ERISA class action
Recent annual tobacco surcharge alleged$1,000
Earlier annual surcharge alleged$1,500
Biometric-screening penalty alleged$500
Covered spousesPotentially included
Proposed class periodNovember 12, 2020, through judgment
Class certificationNot granted
SettlementNone announced
Claim form or deadlineNone
Honeywell liability established?No

Docket: Bolen v. Honeywell International Inc., No. 3:26-cv-00978.

Why Is Honeywell Being Sued Over Tobacco Surcharges?

The central allegation is that Honeywell charged higher health insurance premiums based on tobacco-use classifications without meeting federal requirements for health-contingent wellness programs. Federal law allows certain tobacco surcharges, but only when the program offers a reasonable alternative way to earn the same financial benefit and clearly tells participants about it. Bolen alleges Honeywell’s program fell short.

Who is William Bolen?

Bolen is a former Honeywell employee who worked at the company’s South Bend, Indiana, facility from April 2008 until March 2026. He alleges he paid tobacco-related charges over multiple years. He seeks relief for himself, other affected participants, and the Honeywell International Inc. Benefit Plan. The suit was filed in North Carolina, where Honeywell is headquartered, but proposes relief reaching beyond that state.

How Did the Surcharge Program Allegedly Work?

The complaint alleges that employees enrolling in Honeywell medical coverage, and covered spouses or domestic partners, had to complete annual biometric screenings that included testing for cotinine, a marker of nicotine exposure. Those classified as tobacco users faced an extra annual charge. According to the allegations:

  • The tobacco surcharge was $1,000 a year in recent years and reportedly up to $1,500 earlier.
  • Skipping a required biometric screening could trigger a separate $500 penalty.
  • Some participants who skipped screenings were allegedly treated as tobacco users without any positive test.
  • Charges were generally collected through payroll deductions, sometimes under less obvious labels such as a healthcare resources penalty.
  • Combined penalties could reach $2,000 a year for some employee-and-spouse situations, depending on plan rules.

What if an employee never used tobacco?

Bolen alleges that missing a required screening could lead to being treated as a tobacco user for surcharge purposes. If proven, some participants may have paid extra because of a missed screening, not a confirmed tobacco test. Honeywell has not been found liable for these alleged practices.

What Does the Lawsuit Say Was Unlawful?

1. No meaningful way to avoid the full surcharge. Federal rules generally require outcome-based wellness programs to offer a reasonable alternative. For tobacco, that can be a smoking-cessation program, and the participant need not actually quit to earn the benefit. Bolen alleges Honeywell’s deadlines and conditions kept employees from receiving the full benefit even after completing an alternative.

2. Inadequate notice. The complaint alleges Honeywell’s plan materials did not sufficiently disclose the availability and conditions of alternative standards, which federal regulations require in qualifying program materials.

3. Limited medical accommodations. The suit questions whether Honeywell adequately accommodated people whose own physicians recommended different approaches.

4. No adequate alternative to the biometric penalty. Bolen disputes the separate charge for skipped screenings and asks whether it complied with wellness-program rules.

These are allegations in a newly filed complaint. The court has not decided whether Honeywell violated ERISA.

What Changed in the 2027 Program?

According to the complaint, enrollment materials released in June 2026 describe a process letting some participants who missed the original screening deadline complete a tobacco-cessation alternative by December 31, 2027, and receive reimbursement of applicable 2027 surcharges. Bolen argues this shows broader reimbursement was possible, and that it does not fix alleged problems in earlier years or with biometric penalties. Changing a program does not by itself prove the earlier version was unlawful. The court will look at the historical requirements and plan documents.

Related article: TransUnion Class Action 2026, 800,000 Consumers Remain in Credit Report Privacy Lawsuit

Honeywell Tobacco Surcharge Class Action 2026, Can Employees Recover $1,000 Health Insurance Fees?

Is It Legal to Charge Employees More for Tobacco Use?

Tobacco surcharges are not automatically illegal. HIPAA, the Affordable Care Act, and ERISA permit certain wellness incentives and penalties when conditions are met. Under 29 CFR § 2590.702(f), qualifying health-contingent programs generally must satisfy five requirements:

RequirementWhat it means
Annual opportunityParticipants can qualify at least once a year
Incentive limitThe reward or penalty stays within percentage limits
Reasonable designThe program genuinely promotes health or prevents disease
Reasonable alternativeParticipants have an appropriate alternative route to the reward
Adequate noticeProgram materials disclose the alternative-standard information

For a qualifying tobacco-prevention program, the maximum incentive can reach 50% of the total cost of applicable health coverage, under the regulation’s calculations. That does not let an employer charge 50% more without also meeting the other requirements.

Must employees actually quit? Not necessarily. The Department of Labor’s regulations give an example where participants who complete a reasonable cessation program avoid the surcharge even if they keep smoking. Official regulation: 29 CFR § 2590.702. For background, see our guide: Employer Tobacco Surcharge on Health Insurance: Is It Legal?

The August 2026 Department of Labor Guidance

On August 26, 2026, the Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and Treasury issued guidance on health-contingent wellness programs. It gives limited enforcement relief to certain plans that do not refund surcharges retroactively to the start of a plan year. If a participant completes a reasonable alternative, the agencies generally will not take enforcement action just because a qualifying plan applies the benefit going forward, provided the guidance’s other conditions are met.

Does this mean Honeywell automatically wins? No. The guidance addresses federal enforcement. It does not decide private ERISA lawsuits, and it does not remove the requirements for reasonable alternatives and proper notices.

Are retroactive refunds guaranteed? No. Whether past surcharges must be returned is still disputed in private litigation. Official source: DOL August 26, 2026 guidance.

Who Could Be Part of the Class?

The proposed class covers people who paid qualifying tobacco surcharges under the Honeywell International Inc. Benefit Plan from November 12, 2020, through the eventual judgment. That could include:

  • Current employees who paid qualifying surcharges
  • Former employees who paid while enrolled
  • Participants charged because of a covered spouse or domestic partner
  • People who paid tobacco penalties despite completing an alternative program
  • Participants whose screening or classification records matter to the alleged practices

This is only a proposed definition. The court may narrow, change, or reject certification, and working at Honeywell does not by itself make anyone eligible for money.

Can Employees Recover $1,000 or More?

Potentially, but no amount has been approved. Someone who paid $1,000 a year for several years may have paid thousands in extra premiums, but that does not mean they will get all of it back. Relief depends on which claims survive, the years involved, available records, defenses, and any judgment or settlement. The plaintiff seeks recovery of allegedly improper charges and other appropriate ERISA relief. Right now there is:

  • No approved settlement amount
  • No certified class
  • No official claim form
  • No settlement administrator
  • No deadline to apply for compensation

Beware of fake claim sites. Because the case is at its earliest stage, no genuine claim form exists. Ignore websites or emails claiming you can file a claim and collect a payout today.

Is this the same as the Advocate Aurora settlement?

No. A separate tobacco-surcharge case against Advocate Aurora Health has a proposed $8.95 million settlement. See Advocate Aurora Health $8.95M Tobacco Surcharge Settlement. It involves a different employer and gives Honeywell employees no payment rights.

What Should Current and Former Employees Do Now?

  1. Review old pay stubs. Look for tobacco charges, wellness penalties, biometric-screening fees, or unexplained additions to medical contributions, including items labeled with less obvious payroll descriptions.
  2. Request plan documents. Ask the benefits administrator for Summary Plan Descriptions, enrollment guides, cessation-program rules, biometric-screening requirements, premium contribution records, and any written notice of reasonable alternatives.
  3. Preserve proof. Save payroll statements, benefit elections, cessation-program completion records, and emails with the benefits administrator. Former employees should keep records from every covered year.
  4. Ask about the alternative standard. If you are being charged now, request the alternative in writing and ask whether completing it changes future charges, whether any refund is available, and what documentation is required.
  5. Contact the Department of Labor. The Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) helps workers with ERISA health plan questions at 1-866-444-3272 or dol.gov/agencies/ebsa.
  6. Talk to an ERISA attorney if you are considering individual action, since filing deadlines apply.

Do not stop paying required insurance contributions without understanding how it could affect your coverage.

How Is This Different From the JPMorgan Case?

In January 2026, a former JPMorgan Chase employee filed a separate proposed class action challenging an $80 monthly tobacco surcharge. It also raises questions about wellness alternatives and reimbursement. See JPMorgan Class Action: Tobacco Surcharges and ERISA. The cases involve different employers, plans, plaintiffs, and classes, and one outcome does not decide the other.

Timeline

DateDevelopment
2019Bolen alleges he was already paying tobacco surcharges
November 12, 2020Start of proposed class period
March 2026Bolen’s employment with Honeywell ends
June 2026Honeywell’s 2027 enrollment materials reportedly describe revised reimbursement options
August 26, 2026Federal agencies issue updated wellness-program enforcement guidance
November 13, 2026Bolen files proposed class action in North Carolina
November 16, 2026National legal reporting highlights the case
November 18, 2026No certified class or approved settlement identified

What Happens Next?

Honeywell will respond to the complaint. Expect motions challenging the claims, discovery into historical plan materials, arguments over the 2026 federal guidance, and a request for class certification. The court may also have to decide whether the alleged tobacco and biometric charges fall under the federal wellness rules and what remedies ERISA allows. No class-certification hearing, settlement deadline, or payout date had been verified from the initial docket. The next meaningful developments will be Honeywell’s formal response or a substantive ruling.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Honeywell being sued over tobacco surcharges?

Yes. William Bolen filed a proposed ERISA class action on November 13, 2026, challenging the company’s health insurance wellness-program charges.

How much did Honeywell allegedly charge?

The complaint alleges about $1,000 a year recently, up to $1,500 in earlier years, and a $500 biometric-screening penalty.

Does the lawsuit include former employees?

Potentially. The proposed class covers people who paid qualifying surcharges during the defined period, subject to later court decisions.

Can spouses qualify?

Potentially. The allegations include charges tied to covered spouses and domestic partners.

Do I need to submit a claim?

No. No claim form or court-approved compensation process exists, and any site claiming otherwise should be treated with suspicion.

Can employers legally charge tobacco users more?

Yes, under certain federal wellness-program rules. The program must meet requirements for incentives, alternatives, design, and notice.

Did the Department of Labor end these lawsuits?

No. The August 2026 guidance gives limited federal enforcement relief on retroactive rewards but does not decide private ERISA cases.

Has Honeywell lost the case?

No. The complaint was recently filed, and no liability judgment has been issued.

Bottom Line

The November 13 lawsuit alleges Honeywell improperly charged employees and covered family members tobacco-related health insurance fees without meeting federal wellness-program requirements. The reported charges include annual surcharges of about $1,000, higher amounts earlier, and $500 biometric-screening penalties. The complaint challenges the alternatives offered, the adequacy of notices, and the treatment of people who completed cessation programs. There is no settlement, approved refund, or open claim process yet. Employees should keep their payroll and benefit records, review the plan’s written wellness policies, and learn their ERISA rights. The outcome will turn on the evidence, federal benefits law, and future rulings by the North Carolina federal court.

Sources and Legal References

  1. Federal docket: Bolen v. Honeywell International Inc., No. 3:26-cv-00978
  2. U.S. Department of Labor: August 26, 2026 Wellness Program Guidance
  3. DOL: ACA and HIPAA Implementation FAQs, Part 74
  4. 29 CFR § 2590.702: Nondiscrimination and Wellness Program Requirements
  5. 29 U.S.C. § 1182: Prohibition of Discrimination Based on Health Status
  6. 29 U.S.C. § 1132: ERISA Civil Enforcement
  7. DOL Employee Benefits Security Administration

Editorial note: The federal docket confirms the plaintiff, defendant, filing date, court, case number, and ERISA classification. Details of the alleged surcharge structure and proposed class come from contemporaneous accounts of the complaint, and the full complaint PDF was not independently reviewed. These details remain allegations subject to judicial review.

Legal disclaimer: This article offers general employment-benefits information, not legal advice. Class membership, individual remedies, and filing deadlines depend on applicable law and future court proceedings.

Researched and written by the AllAboutLawyer.com legal content research team.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *