Carelon $10.35 Million New York Settlement, Who Qualifies for Mental Health Insurance Refunds?
New York Attorney General Letitia James announced two settlements with Carelon Behavioral Health on November 10, 2026. They require the company to reimburse eligible New Yorkers who overpaid for out-of-network mental health care, or who had expenses after improper addiction-treatment coverage denials.
The $10.35 million headline figure is not one consumer claims fund. It combines $2.35 million in penalties, fees and costs with up to $8 million for one category of network-access reimbursement. Other restitution, including for directory errors and addiction treatment, is required separately. Some eligible members can also recover excess payments with 12% interest.
Carelon runs behavioral health benefits for about four million New Yorkers through plans such as EmblemHealth, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Independent Health and the Empire Plan.
If you paid out of pocket for therapy, psychiatric care or addiction treatment between January 1, 2020 and November 10, 2026, you may qualify. It depends on your plan, why you went out of network, and whether Carelon handled your coverage improperly. Not everyone gets an automatic payment, and the two agreements use different procedures and deadlines.
Carelon New York Settlement: Quick Facts
| Detail | Verified information |
| Company | Carelon Behavioral Health, Inc. (and Carelon Behavioral Health IPA, Inc.) |
| Settlement date | November 10, 2026 |
| Headline amount | $10.35 million, plus separate restitution obligations |
| Penalties, fees and costs | $2.35 million |
| Network-access restitution | Up to $8 million |
| Other restitution | Directory-error and addiction-treatment reimbursements |
| Interest | 12% on qualifying directory and network claims |
| Covered treatment period | January 1, 2020 to November 10, 2026 |
| Settlement type | Two New York Attorney General enforcement agreements (Nos. 26-007 and 26-008) |
| Network claim deadline | 100 days after the required notice is mailed |
| Addiction-treatment documents | Generally 60 days after you receive a notice |
| Single open claims portal | Not verified as of November 20 |
Official announcement: New York Attorney General, November 10, 2026
Who Qualifies for Refunds?
The agreements create three main reimbursement situations. You must have received services through a covered Carelon-administered arrangement during the covered period.
1. Your provider was listed as in-network, but you were charged out-of-network rates (Directory Claim)
Say you found a therapist in Carelon’s directory, booked believing they were in-network, and later got an out-of-network bill. Eligible members can recover what they paid above their in-network copay, coinsurance or deductible, plus 12% interest. An independent monitor reviews records to identify these claims, and members identified that way can receive restitution without filing an initial application.
2. You could not find an available in-network provider (Network Claim)
You may qualify if you tried to get an appointment with an appropriate in-network provider but could not, and so paid for out-of-network care. Examples include listed providers who did not return calls, were not accepting patients, had left the network, or had no appointments within a reasonable time. The monitor decides whether you made reasonable efforts and had qualifying excess costs.
The agreement provides up to $8 million for valid Network Claims. If approved claims exceed that, payments are reduced proportionately.
3. Carelon improperly denied addiction treatment
The second agreement covers substance use disorder treatment. New York found Carelon sometimes used medical necessity criteria not approved by the state’s Office of Addiction Services and Supports (OASAS), and that some denial reviews skipped required procedures. Members who paid for treatment, or still owe unpaid bills after a qualifying improper denial, may receive restitution. This is separate from the $8 million Network Claim cap.
Which Insurance Plans Are Included?
The Attorney General identified plans for which Carelon manages behavioral health benefits, including:
| Plan | Relevance |
| EmblemHealth | Network access and denials; also has its own restitution program (see below) |
| Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield | Certain Carelon-administered benefits |
| Empire Plan / NYSHIP | State and local government employee coverage |
| Independent Health | Covered Carelon-administered arrangements |
| VNS Health and others | Hamaspik, Village Care Max, Amida Care, Elderplan and other qualifying plans |
Carelon previously managed benefits for MVP Health Plan, which appears in the addiction-treatment investigation.
Having one of these insurance cards does not automatically qualify you. The program covers specified commercial, state and local government employee, Essential Plan, Qualified Health Plan, Medicaid managed care and Child Health Plus arrangements. Self-funded employer plans governed by ERISA are excluded from the provider-network relief, while fully insured ERISA plans are included. Confirm your own plan and treatment dates.

EmblemHealth Has a Separate Refund Portal
EmblemHealth members should know that an earlier Attorney General agreement (No. 24-009) already created a behavioral health restitution program at EmblemHealthRestitution.com. It covers services from January 1, 2020 to February 19, 2026. As of November 20, its published status is:
| Claim category | Status |
| Network Claims | Closed September 8, 2026 |
| Directory Claims | Initial payments being calculated; later filing period upcoming |
Members identified for initial Directory Claim restitution are paid without filing, and a later period lets them seek additional restitution if payments fall short. The Carelon agreement requires cooperation with this program and avoids duplicate reimbursement. Do not assume the November 10 announcement reopened EmblemHealth’s September 8 Network Claim deadline.
There is also an unrelated EmblemHealth case about retired city workers: EmblemHealth Senior Care Co-Pay Settlement.
Why Did New York Investigate Carelon?
The investigations focused on misleading provider directories and improper addiction-treatment denials.
The “ghost network” problem
A ghost network is a directory full of providers members cannot actually reach, because they stopped accepting the insurance, closed their practice, stopped taking new patients or never answer. The Attorney General found that 82% of surveyed Emblem behavioral health providers listed as accepting new patients were effectively unavailable. That figure covers the surveyed listings, not all New York mental health professionals. Investigators also found Carelon had internally recognized the problem without adequately helping members.
One example: a member seeking psychiatric care for a spouse contacted at least eight listed providers without success. Carelon gave about 25 more names and later contacted another 38 providers, and still could not arrange care. It then rejected the member’s complaint because the originally contacted providers’ names had not been submitted within 10 days. In another case, a mother seeking a psychiatrist for her 14-year-old son waited months until the Attorney General’s Office helped secure coverage for an out-of-network psychiatrist.
Addiction-treatment denials
According to the signed agreement, investigators identified 41 instances of unapproved medical necessity criteria among about 7,900 denials issued from 2015 to 2022, and Carelon acknowledged 21 of them. Reviewing external appeals from 2019 to 2022, independent reviewers overturned 17 of 24 Empire Plan denials, 27 of 50 EmblemHealth denials and 4 of 6 MVP Health Plan denials. These are selected appealed cases, not the share of all Carelon denials that were wrong. Investigators found problems in how Carelon considered patients’ addiction histories, co-occurring psychiatric conditions and withdrawal symptoms. Carelon must now use the state-approved LOCADTR criteria.
Carelon neither admits nor denies specified findings. These are binding enforcement agreements, not a court judgment on every disputed allegation.
How Much Could You Receive?
There is no fixed payment such as $100 or $1,000 per member. For directory and network claims, the calculation generally starts with what you paid above your applicable in-network cost-sharing.
| Illustrative example | Amount |
| Out-of-network treatment you paid | $2,000 |
| In-network cost-sharing that would have applied | $200 |
| Potential excess cost before interest | $1,800 |
That hypothetical $1,800 is subject to eligibility review, prior payments and the settlement terms, and 12% interest may increase it. The monitor determines the calculation. Network Claims are subject to the $8 million cap and possible proportional reductions. Addiction-treatment reimbursements depend on qualifying costs or unpaid bills from improper denials.
How to Request a Refund
What you do depends on your claim type.
Step 1: Identify your plan. Find the insurance card or policy that covered you at the time, and check whether Carelon administered your mental health or substance use benefits. Keep records from both Carelon and your insurer.
Step 2: Identify your treatment and dates. Look at services from January 1, 2020 to November 10, 2026. Record the provider, dates, amounts billed and amounts you paid.
Step 3: Pick your category. Was it an inaccurate directory listing, no available in-network appointment, or an addiction-treatment denial? You can have more than one issue, but you cannot be reimbursed twice for the same expense.
Step 4: Gather records. Useful documents include:
- Explanations of benefits (EOBs)
- Provider invoices and proof of payment
- Denial letters and appeal decisions
- Screenshots or copies of directory listings
- Emails, call logs or notes of unsuccessful appointment searches
- Bills for addiction treatment received after a denial
If you no longer have records, ask your insurer and providers for copies.
Step 5: Watch for an official notice. For Network Claims, Carelon must propose a notice to the Attorney General within 30 days of November 10, and the monitor must mail notices within 45 days after approval. The general filing period is 100 days from the mailing date. For Directory Claims identified from records, initial payment may happen without an application, and some members get a separate 60-day period after payment notices to submit additional claims. For addiction-treatment claims, Carelon must contact potentially eligible members and ask for expense documentation, generally with 60 days after receiving the notice to respond.
As of November 20, 2026, no single public Carelon claim deadline or universal application portal has been verified. Be wary of sites promising guaranteed payments.
Step 6: Get help. The Attorney General’s Health Care Bureau Helpline is 1-800-428-9071 (see the Health Care Helpline page). A complaint is not necessarily the same as a restitution claim, so ask which process applies to your plan.
When Will Payments Go Out?
There is no single payment date.
| Milestone | Timing |
| Agreements effective | November 10, 2026 |
| Network notice proposed for approval | Within 30 days |
| Network notices mailed after approval | Within 45 days |
| General Network Claim period | 100 days after notices are mailed |
| Additional Directory Claims | Separate 60-day period after initial payments |
| Addiction-treatment notices | Within 30 days |
| Addiction-treatment documentation | 60 days after you receive the notice |
| Addiction-treatment eligibility review | Within 150 days of the effective date |
| Addiction-treatment payments | Within 180 days of the effective date |
Directory Claim payments generally must be made within 60 days after all identified directory claims are determined, subject to permitted extensions. Do not expect a specific payment date for any one person.
What Changes Going Forward?
Carelon must correct inaccurate directory information within two business days, verify listings at least every 90 days, and run quarterly secret shopper surveys. It must also check that recommended providers can actually take patients. Required appointment access includes:
| Type of care | Required timeframe |
| Emergency care | Immediately |
| Urgent behavioral health care | Within 24 hours |
| First outpatient appointment (commercial and government employee plans) | Within 10 business days |
| Nonurgent Medicaid care | Within 7 calendar days |
| Follow-up after hospital discharge or ER visit (covered commercial and government plans) | Within 7 calendar days |
If a member cannot get timely in-network care, Carelon generally has three business days to find an available provider, except in urgent cases. If it cannot, it must grant an in-network cost-sharing exception for a qualifying out-of-network provider, so you should not have to pay out-of-network prices just because the network lacks an available provider. An independent monitor reports to the Attorney General every six months.
Which Laws Are Involved?
- New York Executive Law § 63(12) lets the Attorney General pursue repeated fraudulent or illegal business conduct and seek restitution and changes in practices.
- New York General Business Law §§ 349 and 350 cover deceptive practices and false advertising, which the Attorney General cited in the directory investigation.
- New York Insurance Law §§ 3217-a, 3241 and 4324 deal with provider-directory information and network adequacy.
- The federal No Surprises Act, 42 U.S.C. § 300gg-115, sets provider-directory verification duties and protections for members who rely on inaccurate network information.
- The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act, 42 U.S.C. § 300gg-26 and 29 U.S.C. § 1185a, generally bars plans from applying more restrictive limits to mental health and substance use benefits than to comparable medical benefits. New York’s parity rules, including Timothy’s Law, add state protections.
- New York Insurance Law § 4902(a)(9) and Public Health Law § 4902(1)(i) govern the use of approved medical necessity criteria for substance use treatment, which is why the second agreement requires OASAS-approved LOCADTR criteria.
For other insurer disputes, see the Anthem proton beam settlement and Delta Dental out-of-network coverage claims. These are separate from the New York Carelon agreements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the whole $10.35 million paid to members?
No. $2.35 million is penalties, fees and costs. Up to $8 million is for Network Claims, and other restitution is separate.
Do I get paid automatically?
Some Directory Claim members identified from records can be paid without an initial application. Network Claims and addiction-treatment claims use notice and documentation processes.
What treatment dates are covered?
January 1, 2020 to November 10, 2026.
Is there a claim deadline?
The Network Claim period is 100 days after notices are mailed. No single public deadline or portal had been verified as of November 20, 2026.
How much will I get?
There is no fixed amount. It depends on what you paid above your in-network cost-sharing, with 12% interest on qualifying directory and network claims.
I’m an EmblemHealth member. Is there a separate program?
Yes. See EmblemHealthRestitution.com. Its Network Claim deadline closed September 8, 2026.
Does this apply outside New York?
These are New York Attorney General agreements for New York plans and members.
Does Carelon admit wrongdoing?
No. It neither admits nor denies specified findings in the agreements.
The Bottom Line
The real question is not whether your insurer uses Carelon, but whether you paid more than your plan’s proper in-network cost because of an inaccurate network, unavailable treatment or a qualifying improper denial. If so, the November agreements may give you a path to reimbursement. The amount depends on your actual expenses and the settlement terms. Keep your insurance records, watch for official notices, and use the Attorney General’s helpline if you need guidance.
Official sources and settlement documents
- New York Attorney General: Carelon Settlement Announcement, November 10, 2026
- Assurance of Discontinuance No. 26-007 (provider network)
- Assurance of Discontinuance No. 26-008 (addiction treatment)
- EmblemHealth Member Restitution Portal
- New York Attorney General Health Care Helpline
Researched for AllAboutLawyer.com from the signed New York Attorney General agreements, official restitution guidance and applicable insurance laws. This article is general legal and consumer insurance information, not individualized legal, medical or financial advice.
About the Author
Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.
