Ashes of Creation Lawsuit, Game Studio Shuts Down After $850K Breach of Contract Claim, Mass Layoffs Hit in February 2026
SADA Systems filed a breach-of-contract lawsuit on December 1, 2025 in New York Supreme Court for New York County against Intrepid Studios, seeking $852,630 for allegedly unpaid Google Cloud Platform services. Seven weeks after Ashes of Creation’s Steam Early Access launch raised millions from hopeful gamers, Intrepid Studios CEO Steven Sharif resigned on January 31, 2026, and the company issued WARN Act layoff notices to all employees on February 2, 2026, effectively shutting down the studio. If you backed this MMORPG with hundreds or thousands of dollars, here’s what the lawsuit alleges, why the studio collapsed, and what it means for your refund chances.
What Is The SADA Systems Lawsuit Against Ashes of Creation?
The complaint, brought by law firm Ballard Spahr, alleges that Intrepid Studios failed to pay for cloud services provided under a September 2022 agreement, despite multiple payment demands and the eventual cancellation of services in April 2025.
The cloud service provider alleges Intrepid Studios has not paid for cloud services delivered since September 2022 despite multiple payment requests. That’s nearly three years of unpaid bills totaling over $850,000 for Google Cloud Platform infrastructure—the backbone needed to run an online multiplayer game.
The lawsuit includes three legal claims: breach of contract (the primary claim), plus alternative claims for unjust enrichment and promissory estoppel if the contract claim fails.
Why Did Intrepid Studios Shut Down?
On January 31, 2026, director Steven Sharif wrote on Discord that “Control of the company shifted away from me, and the Board began directing actions that I could not ethically agree with or carry out. As a result, I chose to resign in protest rather than lend my name or authority to decisions I could not ethically support.”
On February 2, 2026, Intrepid Studios issued a layoff notice to all of its employees via First-Class Mail, affecting all job titles at all positions, describing it as an entire and permanent plant closing within the meaning of the WARN act. Translation: every single employee lost their job with essentially zero notice.
Payroll scheduled for February 1st was allegedly unable to be processed due to the company’s financial constraints. Workers didn’t get paid their final checks.
How Much Money Did Ashes of Creation Raise Before Shutting Down?
From 2016 to 2017, the Kickstarter campaign raised over $3.2 million from 19,576 backers. About 10,000 players purchased the highest-tier package at $500, while about 100K opted for the $250 package, for a total of $25 million in revenue from pre-order packages alone.
That doesn’t count the December 2025 Steam Early Access launch. Despite the hype and anticipation, Ashes of Creation only reached 31.8K peak players, but its estimated sales are between 220K and 320K copies.
Total revenue across nearly nine years? Over $70 million from crowdfunding, pre-orders, cosmetics, and Steam sales—yet the company allegedly couldn’t pay its cloud service bill.
What You Must Know About The Ashes of Creation Collapse
How Breach of Contract Lawsuits Work
In typical business litigation, breach of contract claims require proving: (1) a valid contract existed, (2) the plaintiff performed its obligations, (3) the defendant failed to perform, and (4) damages resulted. The parties entered into a September 2022 agreement where SADA Systems, a Delaware limited liability company and authorized reseller of Google Cloud Platform services, provided cloud infrastructure to Intrepid Studios, a California corporation.
If Intrepid used the services but didn’t pay, SADA’s case is straightforward—textbook breach of contract.
Why Did Steven Sharif Call The Lawsuit “Peanuts”?
Sharif wrote on Reddit: “Contract disputes are fairly common in business, and this will be resolved in a similar manner to other disputes Intrepid has seen in its 9 year history. 800k is a week’s worth of Opex for the studio, anyone promoting concern over this should consider that.”
He claimed Intrepid burned $800,000 per week in operating expenses—that’s over $41 million per year. For context, Guild Wars 2, one of the top MMORPGs in the west, pulled in $124.6M in revenues in Q3, which comes out to around $41,000,000 a month—in revenues, not expenses.
If accurate, Intrepid was spending Guild Wars 2-level money without Guild Wars 2-level income.
What January 2026 Developments Mean For Backers
The studio’s collapse raises serious questions about asset stripping and fraudulent conveyance. Sharif claimed board control shifted away from him and directed actions he “could not ethically support.” Some backers allege assets may have been transferred before insolvency, though no proof has surfaced publicly.
In the original Kickstarter campaign from 2016 to 2017, Sharif promised to refund all backers in full if the game didn’t launch. While this was not a legally binding statement, many gamers are wondering whether Sharif rushed to release the game on Steam to get around the previous statement.
The December 2025 Steam release—even in unfinished Early Access form—might technically satisfy “launch,” blocking refund claims based on that promise.
What To Do Next
How To Determine If You’re Affected
You’re potentially affected if you:
- Backed the 2017 Kickstarter campaign
- Purchased Early Access packages ($250 or $500 tiers)
- Bought in-game cosmetics over the years
- Purchased Ashes of Creation on Steam in December 2025
All of these groups paid money for a game that may never be completed.
Where To Find Official Lawsuit Information
The SADA Systems case is filed as Index No. 656217/2025 in New York Supreme Court, New York County, with the complaint filed December 1, 2025. Court documents are accessible through New York’s online court system or legal research platforms like Trellis.law.
For Kickstarter refund claims, Kickstarter’s Terms of Use require creators to fulfill rewards or refund backers, but enforcement is notoriously difficult once a company shuts down with no assets.
When Individual Legal Advice May Help
Consult a consumer protection attorney if you:
- Spent over $1,000 on packages or cosmetics
- Were promised specific features or rewards never delivered
- Believe fraudulent statements induced your purchase
Similar crowdfunding lawsuits have succeeded when plaintiffs prove material misrepresentation. For instance, consumer protection cases like the Shein $700,000 settlement for shipping delays and consumer protection violations show companies can be held accountable for failing to deliver promised services.
Contact your state Attorney General’s consumer protection division to file complaints. The Federal Trade Commission (ftc.gov) handles crowdfunding fraud complaints at reportfraud.ftc.gov.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Intrepid Studios actually shut down?
Yes. Intrepid Studios issued a layoff notice to all employees on February 2, 2026, describing it as an entire and permanent plant closing within the meaning of the WARN act, with payroll for February not processed due to the company’s current financial condition. The studio has ceased operations.
Will Ashes of Creation servers stay online?
Unknown. As of February 2026, Steam disabled purchases of Ashes of Creation after the dev studio closed down, and there’s no confirmation if the servers will even last long. Without a functioning company to pay hosting costs, servers could go offline at any time.
Can I get a refund for my Kickstarter pledge or Early Access purchase?
Unlikely. Kickstarter pledges are not purchases—they’re investments in a project with no refund guarantee. Steam refunds have a two-hour playtime window, which most early players exceeded. With Intrepid bankrupt and insolvent, recovering money requires joining potential class action litigation, which could take years with no guaranteed payout.
What happened with the $852,630 lawsuit?
The SADA Systems breach of contract lawsuit was filed December 2025 and remains pending. However, with Intrepid Studios shut down and reportedly unable to process payroll, SADA will likely join other creditors trying to recover money from a defunct company with few remaining assets.
Are there other lawsuits against Intrepid Studios?
Multiple business lawsuits and liens have been filed against Intrepid over the years, most of which appear to have been settled eventually, though there is another lawsuit from an insurance provider in addition to the SADA Systems case. The full extent of Intrepid’s debts won’t be known unless bankruptcy proceedings begin.
Why did CEO Steven Sharif resign?
Sharif stated: “Control of the company shifted away from me, and the Board began directing actions that I could not ethically agree with or carry out. As a result, I chose to resign in protest.” He didn’t specify what actions he opposed, leaving backers speculating about asset transfers, layoff decisions, or financial mismanagement.
What legal claims do Kickstarter backers have?
Potential legal theories include breach of implied contract (promising a delivered game in exchange for funds), consumer protection violations under state law, fraudulent misrepresentation (if Sharif knew the project would fail while soliciting funds), and unjust enrichment (Intrepid profited while failing to deliver). However, proving these claims requires evidence of intent to defraud, which is difficult. Successful cases like the Lexington Law $1.8 billion CFPB settlement for charging illegal upfront fees for services never delivered show consumer protection enforcement is possible, but requires regulatory action or strong evidence.
Bottom Line: The Ashes of Creation lawsuit exposed a game studio burning $800,000 per week that couldn’t pay an $852,630 cloud service bill. After nine years and over $70 million raised from backers, Intrepid Studios shut down in February 2026, leaving thousands of gamers with unfinished rewards, no refunds, and little legal recourse. The SADA Systems breach of contract case remains pending, but creditors face the reality of trying to collect from an insolvent company. If you backed Ashes of Creation, document your purchases, file complaints with consumer protection agencies, and watch for potential class action lawsuits—but prepare for the likelihood that most backers will never see their money again.
Last Updated: February 3, 2026
Disclaimer: This article provides factual information about the Ashes of Creation lawsuit and Intrepid Studios’ closure and is not legal advice. For specific legal questions, consult a licensed attorney.
Take Action: If you were affected by Ashes of Creation’s collapse, file a complaint with your state Attorney General’s consumer protection division and report crowdfunding fraud to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov.
Stay informed, stay protected. — AllAboutLawyer.com
About the Author
Sarah Klein, JD, is a licensed attorney and legal content strategist with over 12 years of experience across civil, criminal, family, and regulatory law. At All About Lawyer, she covers a wide range of legal topics — from high-profile lawsuits and courtroom stories to state traffic laws and everyday legal questions — all with a focus on accuracy, clarity, and public understanding.
Her writing blends real legal insight with plain-English explanations, helping readers stay informed and legally aware.
Read more about Sarah