What Happens If More Than One Will Exists in a Probate Situation?
This is not an uncommon scenario. Studies show that nearly 55% of Americans do not update their wills regularly, leading to potential confusion and probate disputes (Source: Caring.com). When multiple wills exist, courts must determine which one is legally valid. This process can be lengthy, expensive, and emotionally draining.
When a loved one passes away, their will is expected to guide the distribution of their estate. But what happens when multiple wills exist? This situation can lead to legal complications, family disputes, and extended probate proceedings. Understanding how courts handle multiple wills and how to prevent such conflicts is crucial.
What Does the Law Say About Multiple Wills?
In probate cases, when more than one will is presented, courts follow specific guidelines to determine the valid document:
1. The Most Recent Will Prevails
Most jurisdictions uphold the most recently executed will, assuming it meets all legal requirements and was intended to revoke previous versions. If a person creates multiple wills, courts will analyze dates and revocation clauses to establish which document reflects their final intentions.
2. Legal Validity of Each Will
Each will must comply with state laws regarding execution. This includes proper signatures, witness requirements, and notarization. Courts assess whether the will:
- Was voluntarily created by the deceased (free from undue influence or coercion)
- Meets legal standards for signing and witnessing
- Clearly revokes previous wills, if applicable
For example, in California, a will must be signed by the testator and at least two witnesses. If multiple wills exist, courts scrutinize whether each document follows these formalities.
3. Codicils vs. Entirely New Wills
Sometimes, a deceased person amends their will through a codicil (a legal amendment). A codicil does not replace a will but modifies specific terms. Courts must determine whether a later document is a new will or simply a codicil intended to update an existing will.
4. Presence of a Revocation Clause
Most properly drafted wills include a clause revoking all previous wills. If such a clause is missing, legal uncertainty arises, and courts may need to compare documents to interpret the deceased’s true intent.
Related article for you:
Does a Car Have to Go Through Probate in California? A Complete Guide
Challenges of Multiple Wills in Probate
When multiple wills exist, several legal challenges and family disputes may arise, including:
1. Will Contests and Litigation
Heirs and beneficiaries may challenge a will’s validity if they believe a newer or older document should be honored. Common reasons for will contests include:
- Fraud or Forgery: Allegations that one will was fraudulently created or signed.
- Undue Influence: Claims that the deceased was pressured into changing their will.
- Lack of Capacity: Arguments that the deceased was not of sound mind when drafting the will.
According to the American Bar Association, about 20% of estate-related lawsuits involve will contests (source).
2. Delays in Probate
Probate courts must analyze all submitted wills, potentially leading to months or even years of legal proceedings. Disputes over which will is valid can delay asset distribution, causing financial strain on beneficiaries.
3. Family Conflicts
Multiple wills often create disagreements among family members, particularly if significant changes exist between documents. Heirs may suspect foul play or favoritism, leading to emotional and legal battles.
How Courts Determine the Valid Will
To resolve conflicts over multiple wills, probate courts follow these steps:
- Examine the Dates of the Wills – The most recent, legally valid will generally takes precedence.
- Check for Revocation Clauses – Courts verify if a later will explicitly revokes previous versions.
- Review Witness Statements – If necessary, witnesses may be called to confirm the will’s authenticity and the testator’s mental state.
- Assess Testamentary Capacity – Medical records or expert testimony may be reviewed to determine if the deceased was mentally competent when creating the will.
How to Prevent Issues with Multiple Wills
To avoid probate complications related to multiple wills, consider the following preventive measures:
1. Regularly Update Your Will
It’s crucial to update your will after major life events, such as marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child. Ensure outdated versions are properly revoked.
2. Clearly Revoke Old Wills
Each new will should contain an explicit revocation clause stating that all prior wills are null and void.
3. Store Your Will Securely
Keep your most recent will in a safe, accessible place, such as a lawyer’s office, a secure home safe, or a state registry.
4. Inform Your Executor and Family
Make sure your executor and trusted family members know the location of your current will to prevent outdated documents from being submitted in probate.
5. Obtain Legal Assistance
Working with an estate attorney can help ensure your will is properly drafted, executed, and stored to avoid legal conflicts.
FAQs About Multiple Wills in Probate
What Happens If Two Wills Have Different Executors?
If multiple wills appoint different executors, courts will determine which will is valid and appoint the executor named in that document. If the valid will lacks an executor, the court may appoint an administrator.
Can a Handwritten Will Override a Typed Will?
In some states, a handwritten (holographic) will may be accepted, but it must meet strict requirements. Courts will compare all documents to determine the deceased’s final intentions.
What If No Will Clearly Revokes the Others?
If multiple wills exist without clear revocation clauses, courts must interpret the documents together to determine which provisions are valid.
Final Thoughts
The existence of multiple wills in probate can create legal challenges, financial delays, and family conflicts. Courts analyze factors such as the most recent will, legal validity, and revocation clauses to determine which document prevails. To avoid such issues, individuals should update their wills regularly, include clear revocation clauses, and use legal guidance when making estate plans.
By taking proactive measures, families can prevent costly probate disputes and ensure that a loved one’s final wishes are honored smoothly and efficiently.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult an estate attorney for guidance specific to your situation.