| |

Washington Initiative 638 Lawsuit, Will Girls Need Sex Verification to Play School Sports?

Girls who want to compete in certain Washington K-12 school sports may have to provide medical verification of their sex starting December 3, 2026, after voters approved Initiative 638. A lawsuit in King County Superior Court is asking a judge to stop the requirement before it takes effect.

The measure restricts transgender girls from girls-only interschool sports. It also requires students entering those competitions to provide a signed statement from their personal healthcare provider.

As of November 16, no court order blocking I-638 had been verified. The measure is still scheduled to take effect December 3 unless a court intervenes.

The plaintiffs argue the initiative violates Washington’s constitutional protections for privacy, equal rights, and education. Supporters say it protects fairness and opportunities in girls’ sports.

Washington Initiative 638 Lawsuit: Quick Facts

QuestionAnswer
MeasureInitiative Measure IL26-638
Official nameDefending Equity in Interscholastic Sports Act
ElectionNovember 3, 2026
ResultAbout 56% Yes (reported at roughly 55.98% Yes, 44.02% No; unofficial, pending certification)
Scheduled effective dateDecember 3, 2026
Lawsuit filedNovember 9, 2026
CaseWashington Education Association v. State of Washington
Case number26-2-36880-5 SEA
CourtKing County Superior Court
PlaintiffsWashington Education Association (WEA), TransFamilies, and parents
DefendantState of Washington
Plaintiffs’ attorneysPacifica Law Group, Legal Voice, and ACLU of Washington
State’s outside defense counselBryan Cave Leighton Paisner (announced November 12)
Intervention motionFemale Athletes United, represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, moved to intervene November 13
Current statusLitigation pending; no blocking order verified

What Is Initiative 638, and Why Did Voters Approve It?

Initiative 638 changes eligibility rules for girls’ interschool athletic competitions in Washington. It was promoted by Let’s Go Washington, a political organization associated with Brian Heywood.

Supporters argue that female-only categories are needed to preserve competitive fairness, safety, and opportunities for girls, including team spots, championships, and college recruitment.

Opponents argue that Washington already had protections for student-athletes and that the measure excludes transgender girls while adding medical verification for all girls in covered competitions.

Before the initiative, Washington’s school athletics policies generally allowed transgender students to take part on teams consistent with their gender identity. I-638 changes that by requiring school districts and covered athletic organizations to bar students the measure describes as biologically male from designated girls-only competitions. It amends RCW 28A.600.200 and RCW 28A.640.020.

Under Article II, Section 1(d) of the Washington Constitution, an approved initiative takes effect 30 days after the election, which is why the date is December 3.

Will Every Girl Need a Medical Exam to Play School Sports?

Every student entering a covered girls-only interschool competition would have to provide healthcare-provider verification under Section 3(2) of I-638. That does not mean every girl must automatically get a new DNA test, hormone test, or genital exam.

The initiative requires a health examination and consent form, or another statement signed by the student’s personal healthcare provider, verifying what the measure calls biological sex. It names three possible bases:

  1. Reproductive anatomy
  2. Genetic makeup
  3. Normal endogenously produced testosterone levels (testosterone the body makes naturally)

The text says the provider may rely on one or more of these. It does not require all three for every athlete. It also does not set a detailed statewide protocol for how providers should handle conflicting or inconclusive findings.

The legal dispute is over whether routine medical records can satisfy the requirement and whether families will be pushed into additional intimate exams or testing.

Can a Doctor Use an Existing Sports Physical?

Supporters say verification can be handled in routine care, since student-athletes already get sports physicals. Opponents respond that ordinary sports physicals check whether a student can play safely. They do not routinely include genetic testing, testosterone measurements, or exams designed to establish sex for eligibility.

The Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA) has said updates to its physical-exam requirements are under legal review and that guidance and forms will be provided to schools. Until those forms are released, families should not assume an existing sports physical automatically satisfies the new requirement.

Who Pays for the Verification?

The initiative does not create a state program to pay for provider statements. Costs would fall on families and insurers, and whether insurance covers a visit or any testing depends on the plan and the services involved. Families should ask their provider and insurer before scheduling anything beyond a routine physical, and wait for official WIAA and district guidance first.

Which Students and Sports Are Covered?

The initiative applies to interschool athletic activities with separate male and female classifications, focusing on competitions intended exclusively for female students. Depending on how they are classified, examples could include girls’ basketball, volleyball, soccer, cross-country, swimming, and track.

ActivityWhat I-638 Says
Girls-only interschool competitionEligibility restriction and provider verification apply
Boys’ school sportsNo comparable verification requirement under Section 3
Ordinary physical education classesNot directly covered by Section 3’s competition language
General classroom activitiesNot covered
Recreational activities outside the covered interschool structureNot automatically covered
Mixed or coed teamsDepends on the competition classification and governing rules

The law addresses district athletic rules and the voluntary nonprofit organizations that regulate interschool activities, including the WIAA framework. It is not a ban on every form of physical activity for transgender students. It also does not govern private recreational leagues or college athletics, which have their own rules.

Related article: H-1B 60-Day Grace Period 2026, Has DHS Ended the Time Workers Get After Losing a Job?

Washington Initiative 638 Lawsuit, Will Girls Need Sex Verification to Play School Sports?

Why Are Parents and Teachers Suing?

The WEA, TransFamilies, and parents of students in girls’ school sports filed suit on November 9. Their complaint argues that the measure imposes unequal verification requirements, intrudes on student privacy, and excludes transgender girls from educational opportunities. Some parents are using pseudonyms to protect their children.

The complaint challenges I-638 under four provisions of the Washington Constitution:

1. Article I, Section 7: Right to Privacy

Washington’s constitution protects people from intrusions into their private affairs. The plaintiffs say requiring medical verification involving reproductive anatomy, genetics, or hormone levels intrudes on sensitive personal information, and that children should not have to disclose it to play school sports.

2. Article XXXI: Washington Equal Rights Amendment

This amendment bars denying or abridging equality of rights under the law on account of sex. The plaintiffs argue that I-638 imposes a sex-verification requirement on students entering girls’ competitions with no equivalent process for boys. Supporters argue that sex-separated sports serve legitimate fairness and safety goals.

3. Article IX, Section 1: Equal Access to Public Education

This section requires Washington to provide education without distinction or preference on specified grounds, including sex. The plaintiffs argue that athletics are an important educational opportunity involving teamwork, leadership, and belonging, and that excluding transgender girls and adding conditions for all girls violates that duty.

4. Article II, Section 37: How Laws May Be Changed

This section generally bars amending a law by reference to its title alone, without setting out the amended text. The plaintiffs argue I-638 changes protections in existing laws without properly setting out all the changes. The laws they point to include:

  • RCW 28A.600.200 (interschool activities)
  • RCW 28A.640.020 (sex discrimination in education)
  • RCW 28A.642.010 (discrimination in public schools)
  • RCW 49.60 (Washington Law Against Discrimination)
  • RCW 28A.605.005 (parental rights)

I-638 expressly amends the first two. The plaintiffs argue it also changes how the others operate without meeting the constitution’s requirements.

None of these claims has been decided by a final judgment.

The State’s Defense and the Attorney General’s Role

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown announced on November 12, 2026 that the state appointed Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner as outside counsel, serving as special assistant attorneys general, to defend the initiative. Reuters reported it on November 13.

Brown said his office has previously defended transgender rights and Washington’s anti-discrimination laws, and that his personal views do not decide whether a voter-approved law gets a legal defense. The choice of outside counsel drew public comment from several directions, including criticism from Washington State Republican Party Chair Jim Walsh, and attention to Brown’s former association with Pacifica Law Group, which represents the plaintiffs.

The appointment does not mean the state has conceded the initiative is unconstitutional.

Female Athletes United Seeks to Join the Case

On November 13, Alliance Defending Freedom filed a motion for Female Athletes United to intervene as a defendant. The group says its members include Washington female athletes who believe they have been competitively disadvantaged by policies allowing transgender girls in girls’ sports. It argues it has a direct interest in defending the measure and that the existing parties may not adequately represent that interest. The motion relies on Washington Superior Court Civil Rule 24.

A motion to intervene is not permission to become a party. The judge must decide whether to grant it. The group’s allegations have not been resolved by the court in this case.

Outside groups can also take part by filing amicus curiae (friend-of-the-court) briefs.

Has the Lawsuit Blocked the December 3 Effective Date?

No blocking order had been verified as of November 16. The lawsuit asks for declaratory and injunctive relief, and the plaintiffs have said they plan to seek emergency relief before December 3. Filing a lawsuit does not suspend a voter-approved law.

What Will the Judge Look At?

To get a preliminary injunction in Washington, a party generally has to show a clear legal or equitable right, a well-grounded fear of immediate invasion of that right, and that the challenged act is causing or will cause actual and substantial injury. Courts also weigh the public interest. Courts are generally cautious about blocking laws voters have approved, so the outcome is not predictable.

What Could Happen

  • Injunction granted: The judge could pause all or some of the challenged provisions while the case continues. This would not decide whether the law is permanently unconstitutional, and the actual scope would depend on the written order.
  • Injunction denied: The law takes effect December 3 while the case continues. The plaintiffs could seek further review from a higher Washington court.
  • Narrower ruling: The judge could address only certain provisions.
  • Later appeals: Whichever side loses at the trial level can ask a higher court to review the ruling. Because the pleaded claims are under the Washington Constitution, state courts will have the main say on those claims.

What Schools Must Do Before December 3

School districts, athletic directors, and coaches face practical changes. The WIAA has said its executive board can update the association handbook to conform to changed state law. Schools should follow official guidance and not create their own medical verification requirements.

Steps for Schools and Athletic Directors

  1. Monitor court orders from King County Superior Court affecting the December 3 date.
  2. Follow WIAA and OSPI guidance and get official forms when released.
  3. Review existing sports physicals to see whether extra provider documentation will be required.
  4. Protect student information. Do not request, store, or circulate sensitive medical details beyond what the rules authorize.
  5. Document eligibility decisions, including the reasons and the available appeal steps if a student is found ineligible.
  6. Communicate with families without publicly identifying any student’s transgender status or medical information.

Guidance for Coaches

Coaches should not make eligibility decisions on their own or ask students for medical records directly. Verification should go through the school’s designated athletic clearance administrator.

Existing Protections Kept by I-638

Section 2 of I-638 keeps protections requiring written activity rules, notice of the reasons for a rejection, an opportunity to contest eligibility decisions, and proportional penalties. It also references existing appeal procedures under RCW 28A.600.205 and RCW 28A.645.010-.030.

What Parents Can Do

  • Wait for official forms and guidance from your district and the WIAA before arranging any extra medical visit or testing.
  • Ask in writing which documentation is required, whether existing records qualify, and what review procedure is available.
  • If your child is found ineligible, request the decision and its legal basis in writing and use the available appeal process.

If I-638 takes effect without an injunction, a student who doesn’t provide the required verification could be found ineligible for a covered girls-only competition. That does not mean she is barred from school, PE, or all extracurricular activities.

Medical Privacy

The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) generally governs disclosure of personally identifiable information in school education records, which can include health-related records. Healthcare providers have separate privacy duties. A signed eligibility statement does not automatically authorize a school to get a child’s full medical history.

Related Reading on AllAboutLawyer.com

Does Title IX Override Initiative 638?

Title IX (20 U.S.C. § 1681) prohibits sex discrimination in federally funded education programs. How it applies to transgender students in sex-separated athletics has been the subject of federal litigation and policy changes. Supporters of I-638 argue that protecting female categories is consistent with Title IX. Opponents argue that excluding transgender girls raises federal discrimination concerns as well as the state constitutional issues pleaded here.

The King County complaint challenges I-638 mainly under the Washington Constitution. It is not a federal Title IX ruling.

Could Seattle Public Schools Take Legal Action?

Seattle Public Schools has authorized possible legal action. On November 9, its Board of Directors adopted Resolution No. 2026/27-11, allowing the district to obtain counsel and take actions needed to protect students. The district cited concerns about privacy, equal access to education, and administrative burdens.

The resolution does not establish that a separate lawsuit has been filed or that the district is exempt from the initiative. Other Washington districts will also need to follow any statewide court order or official guidance.

Key Dates

DateDevelopment
January 2026I-638 submitted to the Washington Legislature
November 3, 2026Voters approve Initiative 638
November 9, 2026Lawsuit filed in King County Superior Court; Seattle school board authorizes possible legal action
November 10, 2026Plaintiffs publicly announce the challenge
November 12, 2026Attorney General appoints Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner
November 13, 2026Female Athletes United files motion to intervene
November 16, 2026Litigation pending; no injunction verified
December 3, 2026Scheduled effective date, subject to court action

Frequently Asked Questions

Is I-638 already in effect?

No. The scheduled effective date is December 3, 2026, and it could change if a court issues an injunction.

Will cisgender girls have to prove their sex to play school sports?

Under the text, every student entering a covered girls-only interschool competition must provide provider verification, unless a court blocks the requirement. A birth certificate by itself is not what the initiative describes; it describes provider verification based on one or more specified criteria.

Do all girls need DNA tests?

No. The initiative does not expressly require DNA testing for every girl. How providers and schools will implement it is an important disputed question.

Does I-638 ban transgender girls from all sports?

No. It restricts participation in specified girls-only interschool competitions. It is not a ban on every school or recreational athletic activity.

Can girls keep competing before December 3?

The initiative is not yet effective, so existing eligibility rules remain relevant until the law changes or a court issues an order.

Who filed the lawsuit?

The WEA, TransFamilies, and several parents filed against the State of Washington in King County Superior Court.

What happens if a judge blocks I-638?

The order could stop some or all challenged requirements from taking effect while the case continues. Its actual scope depends on the written order.

Can parents challenge an eligibility decision?

The initiative keeps existing notice, contest, and appeal protections for certain interschool activity decisions. Families should request written reasons and review the school and WIAA rules.

Does I-638 affect youth recreational leagues or college sports?

No. It applies to K-12 interschool athletic activities, not private community leagues or college athletics.

What if a district refuses to enforce it?

If the law takes effect without an injunction, a district that doesn’t comply could face state regulatory enforcement, WIAA consequences, or legal action from families or advocacy groups.

What Happens Next?

The key question is whether a King County judge will grant emergency relief before December 3. The court may also rule on Female Athletes United’s motion to intervene. Meanwhile, the WIAA and school districts are preparing for possible changes to eligibility and sports-physical documentation.

Bottom line: I-638 was approved by voters, but its new requirements are not yet in effect. The lawsuit seeks to stop enforcement, and the final implementation rules and court outcome remain unresolved. Parents should wait for official district and WIAA guidance before arranging additional medical testing.

Disclaimer: AllAboutLawyer.com provides legal news and general information, not individualized legal advice. The lawsuit contains allegations that have not been resolved by a final judgment. Families facing an eligibility dispute should seek guidance from their school district, athletic association, or a qualified Washington education-law attorney.

Researched by AllAboutLawyer.com, Legal Content Research. Last updated: November 16, 2026.

Sources

  1. Washington Legislature, Full Text of Initiative IL26-638: https://lawfilesext.leg.wa.gov/biennium/2025-26/Htm/Initiatives/Initiatives/INITIATIVE%20IL26-638.htm
  2. Legal Voice, November 9 Complaint and Exhibit A: https://legalvoice.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/IL-26-638-Complaint-w-Ex-A.pdf
  3. Washington Attorney General, November 12 Appointment of Outside Counsel: https://www.atg.wa.gov/news/news-releases/ago-appoints-outside-law-firm-defend-initiative-638
  4. Alliance Defending Freedom, November 13 Motion to Intervene: https://adflegal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/washington-education-association-v-state-of-washington-2026-11-13-motion-to-intervene-as-defendant.pdf
  5. Seattle Public Schools, November 10 Board Announcement: https://www.seattleschools.org/news/seattle-school-board-authorizes-legal-action-regarding-initiative-il26-638/
  6. Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, Handbook: https://www.wiaa.com/wiaa-handbook/
  7. Washington Secretary of State, Ballot Measure Information: https://www.sos.wa.gov/elections/voters/proposed-ballot-measure-information
  8. Washington Constitution, Art. I § 7, Art. II §§ 1 and 37, Art. IX § 1, Art. XXXI; RCW 28A.600.200, 28A.600.205, 28A.640.020, 28A.642.010, 28A.645.010-.030, 49.60; Superior Court Civil Rules 24 and 65
  9. 20 U.S.C. § 1681 (Title IX); FERPA, 20 U.S.C. § 1232g
  10. Reuters, report on the Attorney General’s appointment of outside counsel (November 13, 2026)

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *