MultiCare $55.5 Million Spine Surgery Settlement, Spokane Patients May Qualify for $2,000 or More

Patients who had qualifying spine surgery performed by Dr. Jason Dreyer at MultiCare Deaconess Hospital or MultiCare Valley Hospital in Spokane County may receive money from a proposed $55.5 million class action settlement. Claims are open, and the deadline is January 4, 2027.

About 475 patients are included. Eligible patients can request a $2,000 basic payment without submitting medical documentation, or seek potentially larger compensation through expert medical review. Patients with the most serious qualifying injuries may be eligible for an additional payment of up to $750,000.

The January 4 deadline applies to claims, exclusions, and objections. The settlement still needs final court approval. MultiCare and the Dreyers deny liability.

Official website: MultiCareSpineSettlement.com

MultiCare $55.5 Million Settlement: Quick Facts

DetailVerified information
Settlement$55,500,000
CaseSumerlin et al. v. MultiCare Health System et al.
Case number23-2-01703-32
CourtSpokane County Superior Court, Washington
JudgeJulie M. McKay
DefendantsMultiCare Health System, Dr. Jason A. Dreyer, and Laura Dreyer
Hospitals coveredMultiCare Deaconess and MultiCare Valley
Surgery periodJuly 23, 2019 to March 10, 2021
Estimated class size475 patients
Tier 1$2,000
Tier 2Variable payment after medical review
Tier 3Additional payment, up to $750,000
Claim deadlineJanuary 4, 2027
Opt-out and objection deadlinesJanuary 4, 2027
Final approval hearingFebruary 2, 2027, 8:30 a.m.
Administrator phone1-877-313-8724

Who Qualifies?

According to the official notice, you qualify if your medical records confirm that:

  1. Dr. Jason Dreyer performed one or more spine surgeries on you.
  2. The surgery took place at MultiCare Deaconess Hospital or MultiCare Valley Hospital in Spokane County.
  3. It occurred between July 23, 2019 and March 10, 2021, inclusive.
  4. It was performed under general anesthesia.

A qualifying spine surgery is an operation to treat a condition of the spinal column in an operating room under general anesthesia. You do not need to prove negligence to request the basic Tier 1 payment, but Tier 2 and Tier 3 require additional medical review.

What about MultiCare Rockwood Clinic?

The class definition requires surgery at Deaconess or Valley. An office visit, consultation, or imaging at Rockwood Clinic does not by itself establish eligibility. If Dr. Dreyer saw you at Rockwood but operated at one of the two covered hospitals, your surgical records may qualify you.

Do patients who moved away qualify?

Possibly. The definition turns on the surgeon, hospital, anesthesia, and dates, not where you live now.

Can families of deceased patients apply?

Yes. A legally authorized representative of a deceased patient’s estate may file, as may representatives of incapacitated living patients. But the Plan of Allocation limits estates to Tier 1 or Tier 2. Estates cannot receive Tier 3 compensation.

Related article: Hearthside $4.5 Million Child Labor Settlement, Former Illinois Workers Must File by November 20

MultiCare $55.5 Million Spine Surgery Settlement, Spokane Patients May Qualify for $2,000 or More

How Much Can Patients Receive?

TierWho it coversPotential payment
Tier 1Eligible patients requesting basic compensation$2,000
Tier 2Patients whose surgeries qualify as unnecessary or below the standard of care after expert reviewVariable pro rata payment
Tier 3Tier 2 patients with qualifying extreme harmAdditional pro rata payment, capped at $750,000

Tier 1: $2,000 without medical proof

You submit a valid claim, and the administrator verifies eligibility from the settlement’s records. You do not need to supply medical documents. The $2,000 is per eligible patient, not per surgery.

Tier 2: Higher compensation for unnecessary or negligent surgery

If you believe your surgery was medically unnecessary or below the accepted standard of care, you can request Tier 2 review. A designated neurosurgery spine expert examines your MultiCare records and imaging. You do not have to submit those MultiCare records yourself to start the review. Approved Tier 2 patients share the tier’s funds under the settlement formula, so the payment depends on how many claims are approved.

Critical warning: requesting Tier 2 means giving up the $2,000 Tier 1 payment to help cover the review costs, even if the review does not support a higher award. Weigh this tradeoff carefully before choosing Tier 2.

Tier 3: Up to $750,000 for the most severe injuries

Tier 3 is for patients who qualify for Tier 2 and suffered extreme harm directly attributable to the surgery. Examples named in the settlement include:

  • Multiple surgeries, including corrective or revision operations
  • Paralysis or permanent loss of bodily function
  • Severe permanent disability, including loss of limb function
  • Severe, unmanageable chronic pain
  • Clinically documented, severe and permanent emotional trauma linked to the surgery

Pre-existing conditions are examined to decide whether the harm came from the surgery. The allocation plan reserves $10 million for Tier 3, with an individual cap of $750,000, and Tier 3 money is additional to any Tier 2 recovery. Tier 3 review is estimated to cost $5,000 to $10,000, deducted from the claimant’s Tier 2 allocation if that review happens. Tier 3 applicants must supply supporting medical records and imaging from providers outside MultiCare when needed.

The $750,000 figure is a maximum under the formula, not a promised payment. If experts deny a Tier 2 or Tier 3 request, the Plan of Allocation provides an appeal process.

How to File a Claim Before January 4, 2027

The court-approved notice requires online claims. Official claim portal: Submit a MultiCare Spine Settlement Claim.

  1. Visit the official site. Go to www.multicarespinesettlement.com and select “Start Your Claim.”
  2. Find your Unique ID and PIN. They appear on the notice mailed to eligible patients. Notices began going out November 4, 2026.
  3. Log in to the claim portal with your Unique ID and PIN.
  4. Confirm your information. Complete identity and contact details accurately.
  5. Choose your tier. Understand the consequences of Tier 1, 2, or 3 before submitting, since higher-tier review can reduce or eliminate the basic payment.
  6. Provide documents if required. Tier 3 applicants should prepare medical records, imaging, and evidence of severe harm.
  7. Complete tax information. The notice says the administrator requires a Social Security number to process payment. Enter it only on the verified official portal.
  8. Submit before January 4, 2027, and keep your confirmation and records.

What if you never received a notice?

Not receiving a letter does not necessarily mean you are ineligible. If you lack a Unique ID and PIN, contact the administrator:

Explain that you believe you had qualifying surgery from Dr. Dreyer and need help verifying class membership. Never send medical records, Social Security numbers, or banking details to an unverified website.

Why Was MultiCare Sued?

The lawsuit alleges a pattern of medically unnecessary or improper spine surgeries and failures by MultiCare to supervise Dr. Dreyer. According to the notice, plaintiffs alleged MultiCare used an uncapped physician compensation program that encouraged additional or more complex surgeries. The complaint also raised allegations about hospital oversight, patient safety, and financial incentives.

What did federal investigators find?

The patient suit followed years of government investigation. On February 4, 2026, the U.S. Department of Justice announced a separate $3.728 million settlement with MultiCare resolving federal and state health-care fraud allegations. The government said MultiCare made factual admissions. According to the DOJ, two physician assistants raised safety concerns after Dr. Dreyer began working at MultiCare; one reportedly left an operating room during a procedure over concerns about patient harm, and another raised concerns and later resigned. Investigators also said MultiCare received warnings about Dreyer’s prior practices but kept allowing surgeries while financially rewarding procedure volume and complexity, leading to improper claims to Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs.

Those statements concern the separate government case. They do not mean every patient in the $55.5 million settlement was proven to have had unnecessary surgery. Source: DOJ, February 4, 2026 announcement.

Did MultiCare admit wrongdoing in the patient settlement?

No. The settlement states the defendants deny liability and settled to avoid the cost, risk, and uncertainty of continued litigation. The Spokane County court has not made a final finding that any defendant violated the law. The admissions described by the DOJ belong to the separate government resolution.

Which Washington Laws Are Relevant?

The administrator identifies claims for medical negligence, corporate negligence, unlawful profiteering, the Washington Consumer Protection Act, and related common-law theories.

LawRelevance
RCW 7.70.030Grounds for recovery for health-care injuries, including negligence and lack of informed consent
RCW 7.70.040Proof that a provider failed to follow the accepted standard of care
RCW 7.70.050Informed consent requirements
RCW 19.86.020Prohibits unfair or deceptive business practices
RCW 4.16.350Limitations periods for certain health-care injury actions

In a typical Washington medical-negligence case, a patient must show the provider failed to use the care a reasonably prudent provider would under similar circumstances and that the failure caused injury. An unnecessary procedure can raise questions about both the standard of care and what the patient was told before consenting. Hospital negligence can also involve alleged failures in credentialing, supervision, or responding to safety concerns. For background, see What Is Medical Malpractice?.

Can a patient still file an individual malpractice suit?

Potentially, but staying in the class may release the claims the settlement covers once it becomes final. Review the release terms and the January 4, 2027 opt-out deadline. Washington’s rules under RCW 4.16.350 are complex and generally involve three years from the act or omission or one year from discovery, with exceptions. The settlement deadline and the deadline for an independent lawsuit are not necessarily the same. Consult a Washington-licensed attorney promptly. See also Medical Malpractice Lawyer: How to Know If Your Doctor Made an Illegal Mistake.

What Happens If You Opt Out, Object, or Do Nothing?

Your decisionConsequence
File a valid claimSeek compensation and remain bound by the approved settlement
Opt outReceive no settlement money but preserve any separate claims still legally available
ObjectStay in the settlement while asking the court to reconsider terms
Do nothingReceive no payment and generally remain bound if the settlement is finally approved

To opt out, mail a signed written request identifying the case, your name and address, and your clear intent to be excluded, postmarked by January 4, 2027, to:

Sumerlin v. MultiCare Health System Settlement Administrator PO Box 2857 Portland, OR 97208-2857

Opting out by email or phone is not allowed. Mail early or get a proper postmark.

To object, file a written objection with Spokane County Superior Court and send copies to the attorneys named in the notice, following its full instructions. Objecting is not opting out. You may still be bound if the settlement is approved.

Will All $55.5 Million Go to Patients?

No. The common fund also covers administration costs, the medical-review process, court-approved class representative awards, and attorneys’ fees and costs. Class counsel intends to request fees of up to one-third of the fund plus eligible expenses, and the judge must approve any award. Class representatives may seek service awards of up to $25,000 each, also subject to approval. The money available for Tier 2 and Tier 3 depends on the approved allocations and valid claims. The $55.5 million is not being divided equally among 475 patients.

Can insurance or Medicare reduce payments?

Yes. The notice explains that payments can be subject to reimbursement claims, liens, garnishments, and other legal obligations, including those of Medicare, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, or private insurers. Class members are responsible for resolving them, and the administrator may hold payment until they are settled. Patients with large medical bills should get advice before assuming the gross allocation is their take-home amount.

When Will Payments Be Sent?

The final approval hearing is set for February 2, 2027, at 8:30 a.m. before Judge Julie M. McKay at Spokane County Superior Court (1116 West Broadway, Spokane). The judge will decide whether the settlement is fair, reasonable, and adequate, along with requested fees, expenses, and service awards.

The Plan of Allocation calls for payments within 30 calendar days after entry of the final approval order and judgment, or after all necessary reviews are complete, whichever is later, subject to conditions such as liens. No payment date is guaranteed yet. Payment methods may include checks or electronic options such as ACH, PayPal, Venmo, and Zelle.

Is This the Same as the Providence $100 Million Settlement?

No. The two settlements are related but cover different locations and class definitions. The Providence matter involves care by Dr. Dreyer and Dr. Daniel Elskens in Walla Walla. This MultiCare settlement covers Dr. Dreyer’s qualifying surgeries at Deaconess and Valley hospitals in Spokane County. Together the patient settlements total $155.5 million. See Providence and MultiCare $155.5 Million Settlements Over Dr. Jason Dreyer’s Spine Surgeries. Do not assume you qualify for both, because each has its own rules and procedures.

Key Dates

DateEvent
July 23, 2019Covered surgery period begins
March 10, 2021Covered surgery period ends
February 4, 2026DOJ announces separate $3.728 million government settlement
November 4, 2026Patient settlement notices begin
December 14, 2026Scheduled filing of class counsel’s fee motion
January 4, 2027Claim, exclusion, and objection deadline
February 2, 2027Final approval hearing, 8:30 a.m.
After final approval and reviewsPayments processed

What Spokane Patients Should Do Before January 4

If Dr. Dreyer performed your spine surgery at MultiCare Deaconess or Valley during the covered period, review the official notice and confirm your eligibility. The basic payment requires the least documentation. If you are considering higher compensation, carefully review the expert-review requirements, costs, evidence needed, and the loss of the $2,000 basic payment. If you have serious permanent injuries or an existing individual claim, consider speaking with a qualified Washington attorney before deciding whether to participate or opt out.

The most important step is to submit the appropriate claim or exclusion request before January 4, 2027.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the MultiCare spine surgery settlement real?

Yes. It is a proposed $55.5 million class settlement in Sumerlin v. MultiCare Health System, No. 23-2-01703-32, with an official administrator website and claim portal.

What is the claim deadline?

January 4, 2027. The same date applies to opt-outs and objections.

How much can I get?

Tier 1 pays $2,000 per eligible patient. Tier 2 is a variable payment after expert review. Tier 3 is an additional payment capped at $750,000 for the most severe qualifying harm. Higher tiers are not guaranteed.

Do I give up money by choosing Tier 2?

Yes. Requesting Tier 2 means giving up the $2,000 Tier 1 payment to help fund the review, even if you are not approved for a higher award.

Do I need medical records to claim?

Not for Tier 1 or the initial Tier 2 review, which rely on MultiCare’s records. Tier 3 applicants must supply supporting records and imaging as needed.

I had a consultation at Rockwood Clinic. Do I qualify?

Not automatically. The surgery must have been at MultiCare Deaconess or Valley Hospital.

Can I still sue separately?

Possibly, but you must opt out by mail by January 4, 2027, or you may be bound by the release. Talk to a Washington attorney.

Is the settlement final?

Not yet. The court’s final approval hearing is February 2, 2027.

When will I be paid?

No date is guaranteed. Payments are scheduled within 30 days after final approval or completion of required reviews, whichever is later, subject to liens.

Can Medicare or insurance take part of my payment?

Yes. Liens and reimbursement claims may apply, and payment can be held until they are resolved.

Official Sources and Documents

  1. MultiCare Spine Surgery Settlement: Official Administrator
  2. Court-Approved Settlement Notice
  3. Settlement Agreement
  4. Plan of Allocation
  5. Third Amended Class Action Complaint
  6. Official Claim Form Login
  7. DOJ: MultiCare Government Settlement, February 4, 2026
  8. Chapter 7.70 RCW, Health-Care Injury Claims
  9. RCW 19.86.020, Consumer Protection

Disclaimer: This article offers general legal information, not individual legal or medical advice. AllAboutLawyer.com is not affiliated with MultiCare, the settlement administrator, the parties, or the court. Payments and deadlines remain subject to court orders and the settlement agreement.

Prepared by the AllAboutLawyer.com legal content research team.

About the Author

Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *