Apex Bank Lawsuit 2026, Why Tennessee Senator Kerry Roberts Is Seeking $50 Million
Tennessee State Senator Kerry Roberts and his wife, Dianne, accuse Apex Bank of fraudulent lending practices that they say cost them their historic Springfield home and a nearly finished wedding venue. They are seeking $50 million. Apex Bank denies wrongdoing, and a jury trial is scheduled to begin November 30, 2026.
The dispute involves about $4.56 million in financing for Historic Beeches, a Robertson County property the couple planned to turn into a wedding, events, and short-term rental destination. The case is pending in Robertson County Circuit Court as No. 2025 CV 378.
The $50 million is a damages demand, not a judgment or settlement. No court has found that Apex Bank committed fraud. This is an individual commercial dispute, not a class action, so there is no claim form and no payout for other bank customers.
Apex Bank Lawsuit: Quick Facts
| Detail | Information |
| Bank | Apex Bank, Tennessee |
| Borrowers | Kerry Roberts, Dianne Roberts, Historic Beeches LLC |
| Other counter-defendant | Matthew D. Daniels, the bank’s president |
| Court | Robertson County Circuit Court, Tennessee |
| Case number | 2025 CV 378 |
| Property | Historic Beeches, Springfield, Tennessee |
| Original financing | About $4.56 million |
| Damages requested | 50million(25M compensatory, $25M punitive) |
| Foreclosure | May 2025 |
| Latest verified order | April 10, 2026 |
| Scheduled jury trial | November 30–December 2, 2026 |
| Judge | Chancellor Benjamin K. Dean |
| Class action? | No |
| Settlement announced? | None verified |
Why Is Apex Bank Being Sued?
Kerry and Dianne Roberts owned a historic residence in Springfield dating to the 1860s. They planned to renovate it and develop the surrounding land into a venue for weddings, corporate retreats, and short-term rentals. The property and adjoining parcels served as collateral for the loan.
The couple alleges that Apex Bank, through its president Matthew Daniels, made repeated assurances about construction funding and loan extensions, and that they relied on those promises while investing in the project. They say the bank then delayed or withheld funds, refused to extend the loan when the project was close to completion, and pursued foreclosure.
Apex Bank disputes this and says the borrowers did not meet the obligations in their loan documents.
What Is the Alleged Fraud?
The central accusation is that the bank’s handling of the loan made default more likely and positioned it to take valuable real estate instead of collecting interest on a repaid loan. According to the counterclaim, Apex Bank and Daniels used concealment of material facts and intentionally false promises to induce the couple to pledge their home as security, then delayed the project and called the loan near completion.
The counterclaim asserts fraud by trickery, misrepresentation by concealment, promissory fraud, and promissory estoppel, and seeks rescission of the loan transaction. These are allegations, not established facts.
What Happened to the Historic Home?
The Robertses had lived at the property for years and expanded it for the business. The improvements reportedly included a conservatory, pool, gardens, event facilities, and short-term rental accommodations.
The loan was obtained in 2022, and its maturity terms were modified more than once during 2023 and 2024. The couple says these changes, combined with delayed disbursements, disrupted construction and left them unable to refinance. The bank says the borrowers agreed to the modified terms.
Apex Bank foreclosed in May 2025. In October 2025, a judge in an earlier possession proceeding ruled the bank was entitled to the property and ordered the couple to leave. Reporting says the judge found the bank had not broken any law but expressed concern that the couple had been put at a disadvantage in the business arrangement. That ruling was not a final decision on the fraud and contract claims the couple later raised.
The core question is whether the default came from the borrowers missing valid loan obligations, or whether the bank’s alleged conduct helped create it. The loan documents, correspondence, and financial records will largely decide that.
Why Are the Robertses Seeking $50 Million?
In an answer and counterclaim filed around December 2, 2025, the couple asked for:
- Restoration of ownership of the property
- $25 million in compensatory damages
- $25 million in punitive damages
- Rescission of the loan transaction and other relief
They also claim that about $750,000 in anticipated bookings was affected, including events and more than 200 short-term rental reservations planned for 2024. These are the borrowers’ claimed losses, not amounts found by a court.
Related article: Arkansas Abortion Ban 2026, Judge Allows Lawsuit to Proceed — Is Abortion Legal Now?

Does Apex Bank Have to Pay $50 Million?
No. The court has not awarded anything. In fact, an April 10, 2026 order divided the trial into two phases and paused the damages claims. The first phase covers contract obligations, possession, and defenses. Damages come only in a possible second phase.
What Has Apex Bank Said?
Apex Bank denies engaging in predatory lending or making fraudulent promises. It says it provided substantial financial support and that the borrowers did not meet their obligations. In earlier proceedings, bank attorneys pointed to the written loan agreements, extension conditions, and correspondence about financing approvals. The bank also rejects the suggestion that the foreclosure was a plan to obtain the property improperly.
The parties disagree on whether oral assurances were made, whether those assurances could legally change the written agreements, and whether the bank’s conduct caused the default.
What Have the Courts Ruled So Far?
The dispute spans several proceedings, and their outcomes should not be confused.
Earlier possession ruling (October 2025): this favored Apex Bank, as described above.
April 10, 2026 order: in the Robertson County Circuit Court case, Chancellor Benjamin K. Dean denied the bank’s motion to dismiss the counterclaims under Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 12.02(6), finding the allegations sufficient to proceed at that early stage. He also declined, for now, to move the case to Knox County. The order left room to revisit venue, contract defenses, and summary judgment later.
This ruling was not a finding that Apex Bank committed fraud. Read the April 10, 2026 court order.
Why Is the Trial Split Into Two Phases?
The order creates a two-stage process under Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 42.02.
| Phase | Issues |
| Phase One | Breach of contract, entitlement to possession, fraud-related defenses, rescission, and estoppel |
| Phase Two, if needed | Claims for monetary damages |
The judge reasoned that resolving contract and possession questions first could simplify or eliminate later damages issues. Headlines about a “$50 million trial” can mislead: the first phase does not ask the jury to award or reject that figure.
What Tennessee Laws Apply?
Breach of contract. A claim generally requires an enforceable agreement, a material failure to perform, and resulting damages. The court will examine the actual loan documents.
Written lending agreements, Tenn. Code § 29-2-101. Under subsection (b), a lender’s promise to provide credit, or to modify, renew, or extend a loan, generally must be backed by a qualifying signed writing to be enforceable. That creates a significant hurdle for claims based on verbal promises of an extension. The April order acknowledged the competing contract and estoppel theories without resolving them.
Fraudulent misrepresentation. A plaintiff generally must show a material false representation, the required knowledge or recklessness, reasonable reliance, and injury. Discussing an extension does not by itself establish fraud.
Promissory estoppel. This doctrine can sometimes give relief when someone reasonably relies on a promise to their detriment. It does not automatically override statutory writing requirements.
Foreclosure law, Tenn. Code Title 35, Chapter 5. These provisions set notice and sale procedures for certain foreclosures. Whether this sale complied depends on the statutes and contract terms in effect in 2025.
For a separate foreclosure dispute that reached a federal appeals court, see Gregory Brian Myers v. U.S. Bank, 11th Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Naples Foreclosure Lawsuit.
Is the Case Connected to Bankruptcy?
Yes. Historic Beeches LLC filed for Chapter 11 protection in 2024 in the Middle District of Tennessee (In re Historic Beeches, LLC, No. 3:24-bk-02738). A March 17, 2025 order there addressed compensation for the debtor’s counsel and limits on use of Apex Bank’s cash collateral.
A bankruptcy filing can temporarily pause foreclosure through the automatic stay under 11 U.S.C. § 362, but it does not erase a valid secured debt. The state-court case focuses on whether the underlying loan obligations are enforceable and how the parties behaved.
Is This a Class Action?
No. This is a dispute between specific borrowers and a lender over one project. No class has been certified, and there is no settlement fund, claim form, or deadline for the public. Having an Apex Bank account or loan does not make anyone eligible for compensation.
If you receive a message offering to help you file a claim in an “Apex Bank class action settlement,” treat it with caution and check official court records. No such process exists for this case.
For a broader financial-services example, compare the OneMain Financial Lawsuit Update 2026, 13 States Allege Hidden Loan Add-Ons, $20 Million CFPB Order and New Data Breach Cases.
Are There Other Apex Bank Lawsuits?
Yes, but they are separate cases with different parties, properties, and legal questions, and they are not part of a combined settlement:
- Ramirez v. Apex Bank, No. 7:26-cv-00316 (S.D. Texas), a foreclosure-related case. An August 18, 2026 order dissolved a temporary restraining order and imposed sanctions on the plaintiffs’ attorney.
- Casasnovas-Cortes v. Apex Bank, No. 3:25-cv-01427 (D. Puerto Rico), about mortgage servicing information requests and related foreclosure proceedings. A September 14 order addressed improper service and dismissed claims against certain other defendants.
Searches may also return cases involving similarly named companies, such as Apex Global Solutions, which faced separate data-breach litigation. Those are unrelated to Apex Bank.
When Is the Trial?
The April 10, 2026 order sets a three-day jury trial beginning November 30, 2026, at 9:00 a.m. Central Time, through December 2. I did not verify any later order moving the date, so check the Robertson County docket for continuances before relying on it.
Could the Case Settle?
Yes. Civil cases can settle before, during, or after trial, but no settlement has been verified as of November 16, 2026. Any settlement would not necessarily involve the full $50 million.
For another active commercial lending case, see Ehren Jordan Wine Cellars Lawsuit, First-Citizens Bank’s $17.5 Million Claim and Foreclosure Request Over Failla Wines.
Timeline
| Date | Development |
| 2022 | About $4.56M financing arranged |
| 2023–2024 | Loan maturity terms modified and later extensions disputed |
| 2024 | Historic Beeches LLC files Chapter 11 |
| March 17, 2025 | Bankruptcy order on counsel compensation and cash collateral |
| May 2025 | Apex Bank forecloses |
| October 2025 | Possession ruling favors the bank |
| December 2, 2025 (approx.) | Roberts answer and counterclaim filed |
| April 10, 2026 | Circuit court denies dismissal and splits trial into phases |
| November 30, 2026 | Phase One jury trial scheduled to begin |
| December 2, 2026 | Scheduled end of the three-day trial |
| Final liability ruling or damages award | None |
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Apex Bank being sued?
Kerry and Dianne Roberts allege the bank mishandled financing for their Historic Beeches project and made misleading promises that led to default and foreclosure.
Who filed the $50 million claim?
The Robertses and their business interests, against Apex Bank and its president, Matthew D. Daniels.
Did Apex Bank commit fraud?
No court has found that. The bank denies wrongdoing.
Did Kerry Roberts lose his home?
Apex Bank foreclosed in May 2025, and an earlier possession ruling favored the bank. The broader contract and possession dispute continues in the circuit court case.
Did a judge reject the lawsuit?
No. The April 10, 2026 order denied the bank’s request to dismiss the counterclaims, letting them proceed without deciding their merits.
Will Apex Bank pay $50 million?
There is no $50 million judgment or settlement. The figure is the damages the borrowers are requesting.
Can other Apex Bank customers file a claim?
No. There is no class action or public compensation program for this case.
When is the trial?
The scheduling order sets Phase One for November 30 through December 2, 2026, subject to any later court changes.
Latest Update: November 16, 2026
The dispute turns on whether the bank’s financing conduct broke contractual or other legal obligations, and whether the foreclosure can be challenged. The court has let the counterclaims proceed and divided the trial into liability and damages phases, with the first jury trial set for November 30, 2026. Apex Bank continues to deny any fraudulent lending.
No finding of fraud, $50 million judgment, class action, or settlement claim form has been verified.
Sources and Court Records
- Robertson County Circuit Court, April 10, 2026 Order on Motions to Dismiss, Transfer, and Bifurcate Trial, No. 2025 CV 378
- In re Historic Beeches LLC, Bankruptcy No. 3:24-bk-02738
- Tennessee Code § 29-2-101, Written Lending Agreements
- Tennessee Code Title 35, Chapter 5, Foreclosure Procedures
- Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 42.02, Separate Trials
- Ramirez v. Apex Bank, August 18, 2026 Order
- Casasnovas-Cortes v. Apex Bank, September 14, 2026 Order
Source note: The April 10 order confirms the case number, parties, dismissal ruling, trial split, and trial dates. Details about the counterclaim’s damages breakdown, lost bookings, loan communications, and the bank’s public position come from accounts of the pleadings and earlier proceedings, and the full counterclaim was not independently reviewed.
Disclaimer: This article provides general legal information, not legal or financial advice. The allegations are contested, and no final judgment has found that Apex Bank committed fraud or owes the requested damages.
Last reviewed: November 16, 2026.
Researched by AllAboutLawyer.com, Legal Content Research.
About the Author
Israr Ahmad is a legal content researcher with 4+ years of experience covering class action settlements and consumer rights cases. He has researched and published coverage of 2,500+ settlements using verified court records, settlement administrator filings, and government sources. Learn more about Israr.
