What If My Wife Gets Pregnant by Another Man During Divorce? Legal Rights, Paternity, and Child Support Explained

When a wife becomes pregnant by another man during divorce proceedings, the husband is typically presumed to be the legal father if the child is born within 300 days of divorce finalization in most states. This presumption affects child support obligations, custody arrangements, and divorce timing—regardless of biological paternity. Understanding your state’s specific paternity laws, DNA testing procedures, and legal options is critical.

How Does Pregnancy Affect Divorce Proceedings?

Pregnancy complicates divorce timing significantly. Several states prohibit or delay divorce finalization until after birth.

States That Restrict Divorce During Pregnancy:

• Texas: Cannot finalize divorce while wife is pregnant. Courts require paternity establishment before proceeding. (Texas Family Code § 160.204)
• Arkansas: Judges postpone divorce until birth to resolve paternity and custody.
• Missouri: Judges typically delay proceedings until after birth despite no explicit statutory prohibition.
• Arizona: Courts generally refuse to finalize divorces during pregnancy.
• Florida: While filing is permitted, finalization typically waits until birth.
• Mississippi: Delays finalization to address child support and custody properly.

States That Allow Divorce During Pregnancy:

• California: Divorce can finalize before birth, but custody and support determinations wait.
• New York: No prohibition on finalizing during pregnancy; paternity presumption applies.
• Pennsylvania: Separate proceedings for divorce and custody allow finalization during pregnancy.
• Washington: State law explicitly prohibits judges from delaying divorce due to pregnancy. (Wash. Rev. Code § 26.09.030(e))
• Massachusetts: Permits finalization during pregnancy.
• Illinois: Courts may grant bifurcated divorces in appropriate circumstances.

The 60-day mandatory waiting period in Texas begins at filing but divorce cannot finalize during pregnancy regardless of timing. In California’s six-month waiting period, property division and spousal support can proceed, but child-related issues must wait until birth.

Paternity Presumptions: Who Is Legally Considered the Father?

Most states apply the “marital presumption of paternity”—a legal doctrine presuming the husband is the father of any child conceived or born during marriage.

The 300-Day Rule

The critical timeline: If a child is born within 300 days (approximately 10 months) after divorce finalization, the ex-husband is presumed to be the legal father in most jurisdictions.

State-Specific Paternity Presumptions:

California (Family Code §§ 7540, 7611):

• Husband presumed father if child born during marriage or within 300 days after termination
• Presumption applies even to invalid marriages if attempted in apparent compliance with law
• Can be rebutted through court action, but timing and circumstances matter

Texas (Family Code § 160.204):

• Child born during marriage or before 301st day after termination creates presumption
• If multiple presumptions conflict, courts weigh policy considerations and facts

Louisiana (Civil Code Art. 185-186):

• Husband presumed father for children born during marriage or within 300 days after termination
• If child born within 300 days and mother remarried, first husband presumed father unless rebutted

Alabama (§ 26-17-204):

• Presumption for children born during marriage or within 300 days after termination
• Rebuttable only through formal adjudication

Tennessee (§ 36-2-304):

• Child born during marriage or within 300 days after termination creates presumption
• If mother married and living with husband at conception and remained together, presumption may be irrebuttable absent extraordinary circumstances
• Action to establish alternative paternity must be brought within 12 months of birth if married couple files sworn statement

Hawaii (§ 584-4):

• Presumption applies to children born during marriage or within 300 days after termination
• Requires “clear and convincing evidence” to rebut presumption

Pennsylvania (Recent Case Law – B.C. v. C.P. & D.B., 2024):

• Supreme Court held presumption applies to intact marriages even with periods of separation
• Biological father’s paternity action dismissed when married couple reconciled and lived together as family
• Court emphasized preserving intact marriages over biological father’s claims

When Presumptions Conflict

When a wife conceives during separation but remains married, or remarries before birth, multiple presumptions may arise. Courts resolve conflicts by considering:

• Which presumption serves child’s best interests
• Policy favoring intact marriages
• Timing of conception relative to marriage/divorce
• Whether marriage was “intact” at relevant times

In B.C. v. C.P. & D.B. (Pa. 2024), Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court held that temporary separations don’t automatically defeat the marital presumption when a couple ultimately reconciles and maintains an intact family unit.

Child Support Obligations: Legal Father vs. Biological Father

Child support liability depends on legal paternity, not biological paternity. Understanding this distinction is critical.

Legal Paternity vs. Biological Paternity

Legal Father: The man recognized by law as the child’s father through:

• Marriage to mother at time of conception or birth
• Voluntary acknowledgment of paternity
• Court order establishing paternity
• Name on birth certificate (in some states)

Biological Father: The genetic father proven through DNA testing.

Legal paternity creates support obligations regardless of genetic connection.

When Non-Biological Fathers Pay Child Support

Courts may require the husband to pay child support even when DNA proves he’s not the biological father if:

Marital Presumption Applies: Child born during marriage or within 300 days after divorce creates automatic presumption in most states.

Paternity Estoppel: Courts apply “parentage by estoppel” when:

• Husband knew or should have known he might not be biological father
• Voluntarily represented himself as father
• Child relied on this representation
• Developed parent-child relationship

In Shondel J. v. Mark D. (N.Y. 2007), New York’s Court of Appeals held a man estopped from denying paternity despite negative DNA test because the child justifiably relied on his representation as father and developed a parent-child bond.

Failure to Challenge Timely: Most states impose strict deadlines to challenge paternity:

• Louisiana: One year from birth or discovery for married fathers; one year for unmarried fathers (Wetta v. Wetta)
• California: Two years in many circumstances; longer if can prove fraud, duress, or material mistake
• Florida: Must file within statutory timeframe with “newly discovered evidence”
• Maryland: No specific time limit, but courts disfavor belated challenges

Final Judgment in Divorce: In Dreyer v. Greene (Tex. 1993), Texas Supreme Court barred wife from establishing another man’s paternity after divorce decree adjudicated husband as father based on her sworn testimony.

Biological Father’s Support Obligations

The biological father’s obligations depend on whether legal paternity is established:

If Legal Paternity Not Established: Generally no automatic support obligation until paternity is legally established through:

• Voluntary acknowledgment
• Administrative paternity order
• Court order after genetic testing

If Another Man Is Legal Father: Biological father typically has no legal obligation unless:

• He establishes paternity through court action
• Legal father successfully disestablishes paternity
• State law permits dual paternity findings (rare)

Establishing Biological Father’s Paternity: When husband is presumed father, biological father faces significant barriers:

• Must file paternity action in court
• May need mother’s cooperation
• Must overcome marital presumption
• Courts prioritize child’s established relationships
• May be barred if marriage is “intact”

Challenging Paternity: Disestablishment Procedures

When a husband discovers he’s not the biological father, disestablishment procedures vary by state but generally follow similar patterns.

Requirements for Disestablishment

Florida (§ 742.18):

• File petition in circuit court with jurisdiction over child support
• Submit affidavit with newly discovered evidence
• Provide DNA test results showing exclusion or sworn statement explaining inability to obtain testing
• Prove current on child support or substantial compliance
• Cannot have adopted child
• Cannot apply if child conceived through artificial insemination during marriage

Mississippi (§ 93-9-10):

• File petition in court with jurisdiction over support obligation
• Serve mother and Attorney General if state involved
• DNA testing must show man cannot be father
• Newly discovered evidence requirement
• Cannot have signed stipulated agreement after knowing not the father
• Cannot have failed to appear for court-ordered genetic testing

Louisiana (Wetta v. Wetta):

• Disavowal action subject to one-year prescription
• Clock starts from birth or discovery that he may not be biological father
• Must provide clear and convincing evidence beyond just DNA results
• Husband’s testimony must be corroborated
• Cannot succeed if voluntarily assumed responsibility knowing potential non-paternity

What Courts Consider

Newly Discovered Evidence: Most states require evidence that wasn’t known when paternity was established:

• DNA test results obtained after initial determination
• Mother’s admission
• Third-party statements
• Medical impossibility (geographic separation during conception)

Best Interests of Child: Courts balance:

• Established parent-child relationship
• Child’s age and awareness
• Psychological harm from disrupting relationship
• Financial stability considerations
• Whether biological father is available and willing

Equitable Considerations:

• Whether husband knowingly assumed paternity despite doubts
• Fraud, duress, or material mistake of fact
• Whether husband prevented biological father from asserting rights
• Length of established relationship

Limitations on Disestablishment

Courts deny disestablishment when:

Husband Acted with Knowledge: If husband knew or should have known he wasn’t biological father but:

• Signed voluntary acknowledgment anyway
• Named himself on birth certificate
• Agreed to paternity in court proceedings
• Made promises to support child

Child’s Best Interests: Long-established parent-child relationships may be protected over biological truth when child:

• Is older and has psychological bond with presumed father
• Would suffer significant harm from change
• Has no relationship with biological father

Procedural Bars:

• Missed statutory deadlines
• Failed to challenge during divorce proceedings
• Previous court determinations with preclusive effect
• Signed agreements waiving rights to challenge

Past Support Obligations: Disestablishment typically:

• Terminates future support obligations only
• Does not create right to recover previously paid support
• May not eliminate arrears that accrued before petition filed
• Preserves legal status until court order granted

Custody and Visitation Implications

Pregnancy by another man affects custody arrangements in complex ways.

Presumed Father’s Rights

Until paternity is disestablished, the husband retains:

• Legal rights to custody and visitation
• Obligation to provide financial support
• Authority to make decisions about child’s welfare
• Standing to seek custody modifications

Biological Father’s Rights

The biological father generally has no legal rights until establishing paternity:

Before Paternity Established:

• No custody rights
• No visitation rights
• No decision-making authority
• No legal standing in custody proceedings

After Paternity Established:

• Can seek custody or visitation
• May be granted parenting time
• Obtains decision-making rights
• Assumes child support obligations

Court’s Best Interest Analysis

When determining custody after paternity issues arise, courts consider:

• Each parent’s relationship with child
• Primary caretaker history
• Stability of proposed living arrangements
• Each parent’s ability to meet child’s needs
• Child’s preferences (if age-appropriate)
• Any established parent-child relationships
• Impact of disrupting existing bonds

States vary on whether biological connection outweighs established relationship. Some prioritize biology; others protect psychological parentage.

DNA Testing: Procedures and Implications

Genetic testing resolves paternity questions but timing and procedures matter significantly.

When Testing Occurs

Before Birth: Some states permit prenatal paternity testing through:

• Non-invasive prenatal paternity (NIPP) testing using mother’s blood
• Generally available after 7-8 weeks of pregnancy
• Results not legally binding until confirmed after birth in many jurisdictions

After Birth: Most formal testing occurs post-birth:

• Buccal (cheek) swab from child, mother, and alleged father
• Blood testing (less common now)
• Results typically available within 1-2 weeks
• Must use court-approved laboratory for legal proceedings

How to Obtain Court-Ordered Testing

During Divorce:

• File motion for genetic testing
• Provide basis for questioning paternity
• Court evaluates whether testing serves child’s best interests
• May require showing changed circumstances or newly discovered evidence

After Divorce:

• File petition to establish or disestablish paternity
• Must show standing to challenge
• Timing limitations apply based on state law
• May need to overcome final judgment barriers

Administrative Process: Many states offer child support agency services:

• Lower cost testing
• Streamlined procedures
• Results admissible in court
• Available when establishing initial support orders

Test Result Standards

Probability Thresholds: Most states presume paternity when DNA shows:

• 97% to 99% or higher probability (varies by state)
• Combined Paternity Index (CPI) of 500:1 or higher
• 99.9% is common standard for conclusive results

Exclusion: If testing excludes alleged father (typically showing 0% probability), this provides basis for disestablishment—but may not be sufficient alone in some jurisdictions.

Cost Allocation

• State typically pays for initial court-ordered testing
• Alleged father may reimburse if results confirm paternity
• Private testing costs paid by requesting party
• Challenge testing after initial results requires challenger to pay

State-by-State Legal Variations

Uniform Parentage Act (UPA) States

Many states adopted versions of the UPA (2002), which standardizes:

• 300-day presumption window
• Methods for establishing paternity
• Procedures for rebutting presumptions
• Recognition of same-sex parents

States with UPA-based laws include Texas, Washington, Illinois, and others—but each may modify provisions.

Practical Steps: What to Do Immediately

If You’re the Husband

Document Everything:

• Timeline of separation
• Evidence of no sexual contact during conception period
• Communications suggesting alternative paternity
• Medical records if relevant

Consult Attorney Immediately: Time limits matter. Don’t wait to:

• Understand your state’s paternity laws
• Learn disestablishment procedures and deadlines
• Evaluate strategic options
• Protect legal rights

Request DNA Testing: If paternity is questioned:

• File motion during divorce proceedings
• Don’t wait until after judgment
• Seek court-ordered testing for legal validity
• Consider prenatal testing if timing allows

Don’t Assume Parental Role: If you have strong evidence child isn’t yours:

• Avoid actions that create estoppel
• Don’t sign birth certificate
• Don’t hold child out as yours
• Understand each action may create legal obligations

Raise Issue in Divorce: Paternity must be addressed:

• Include in initial filings if known
• Don’t let judgment enter without resolution
• Final judgments may preclude later challenges
• Courts can bifurcate divorce from paternity issues

If You’re the Wife

Disclose Pregnancy: Requirements vary, but disclosure prevents:

• Perjury charges
• Complications with final judgment
• Later legal challenges
• Custody determination issues

Establish Biological Father’s Paternity: If known:

• Biological father can file paternity action
• May require DNA testing
• Timing matters—file before divorce finalizes if possible
• Mother’s cooperation helps but isn’t always required

Protect Child’s Interests:

• Ensure accurate birth certificate
• Establish proper child support
• Secure appropriate custody arrangements
• Consider child’s relationships with all parties

Address Financial Support:

• Determine who will provide support during pregnancy
• Establish temporary orders if needed
• Consider medical expenses
• Plan for birth-related costs

If You’re the Biological Father

Assert Rights Early: Don’t delay:

• File paternity action as soon as possible
• Register with putative father registry if your state has one
• Participate in prenatal care if mother consents
• Document your involvement and intent

Establish Paternity Formally:

• Voluntary acknowledgment if mother and husband agree
• Court action if contested
• DNA testing to prove biological connection
• Overcome marital presumption through legal process

Understand Obstacles:

• Marital presumption favors husband
• Mother’s marriage may be deemed “intact”
• Courts protect established relationships
• Financial obligations follow legal determination

Seek Legal Counsel: Biological fathers face complex barriers:

• Standing requirements vary
• Time limitations apply
• Mother’s cooperation helps significantly
• Husband’s rights may take precedence

How Long Does This Process Take?

Divorce Timeline

Without Pregnancy Complications: 6-12 months in most states

• Mandatory waiting periods (60 days to 6 months)
• Discovery and negotiation (2-6 months)
• Court proceedings (varies widely)

With Pregnancy: Add 9+ months

• States requiring post-birth finalization extend process
• Paternity testing adds 2-4 weeks
• Contested paternity adds months or years
• Multiple parties complicate proceedings significantly

Paternity Establishment Timeline

Uncontested: 2-4 months

• Voluntary acknowledgment: Immediate legal effect
• Administrative process: 30-60 days
• Uncontested court action: 60-90 days

Contested: 6-18 months

• DNA testing: 2-4 weeks for results
• Court scheduling delays: Varies by jurisdiction
• Hearings and evidence presentation: Multiple court dates
• Appeals possible: Add 6-18 months

Disestablishment Timeline

Typical Process: 6-12 months

• Gathering evidence and DNA testing: 1-3 months
• Filing petition and service: 2-4 weeks
• Mother’s response time: 20-30 days
• Court hearing scheduling: 2-6 months
• Final order: Varies by court

Recent Case Law and Developments

Pennsylvania Supreme Court (2024)

B.C. v. C.P. & D.B. clarified that the marital presumption of paternity applies to intact marriages even when couples experienced multiple separations. The court dismissed a biological father’s paternity action when the married couple reconciled and lived together as a family, emphasizing that temporary separations don’t automatically defeat the presumption when marriage is ultimately intact.

Key Takeaway: Courts prioritize preserving intact marriages over biological father’s claims. The “intact marriage” analysis focuses on current family status rather than past separations.

Legislative Trends

Pregnancy and Divorce Restrictions: As of 2024, ongoing legislative discussions in Missouri, Texas, and Arkansas address whether pregnancy should prevent divorce finalization. Advocacy groups note these laws, dating to the 1970s, create barriers for domestic violence victims.

Same-Sex Parentage: Courts increasingly apply paternity presumptions to same-sex married couples:

• California recognizes spouse of birth mother as presumed parent
• Courts grappling with gender-specific statutory language
• Movement toward “parentage” rather than “paternity” terminology

Putative Father Registries: More states establishing registries requiring biological fathers to register to preserve rights:

• Protects against adoption without consent
• Provides notice of proceedings
• Failure to register may waive rights

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Be Forced to Pay Child Support for a Child Who Isn’t Mine?

Yes, if you’re the legal father. Marital presumption, voluntary acknowledgment, or established parent-child relationship can create support obligations regardless of biology. You must successfully disestablish paternity through legal proceedings to terminate future obligations—and even then, past support obligations may remain.

What If I Signed the Birth Certificate Not Knowing I Wasn’t the Father?

Signing the birth certificate typically establishes legal paternity. Most states allow challenges based on fraud, duress, or material mistake of fact, but strict time limits apply. You must:

• File disestablishment petition promptly
• Provide DNA evidence
• Prove you didn’t know or have reason to know
• Act within statutory deadline (often 1-2 years)

Can the Biological Father Get Custody Rights?

Yes, but he must first establish legal paternity. The process requires:

• Filing paternity action
• Overcoming marital presumption if mother is/was married
• DNA testing proof
• Court determination

Once paternity is established, biological father can seek custody or visitation based on child’s best interests. Courts balance his rights against any established relationship with presumed father.

What Happens If My Wife Won’t Disclose Who the Father Is?

You can:

• File motion requesting DNA testing
• Court can order testing over mother’s objection
• Proceed with disestablishment action
• Request court investigation

Mother’s refusal to cooperate may have legal consequences including contempt, but courts prioritize child’s best interests in determining testing orders.

Will I Have to Pay for the Biological Father’s Child?

If divorce finalizes with you as legal father without challenging paternity, yes. However, you may:

• File disestablishment action with newly discovered evidence
• Request DNA testing
• Challenge paternity during divorce proceedings
• Seek to have biological father established as legal father

Critical: Raise paternity issues before final divorce judgment. Final judgments often preclude later challenges under principles of res judicata.

How Much Does DNA Testing Cost?

• Court-ordered testing: Often state-funded initially, with potential reimbursement if paternity confirmed
• Private testing: $100-$500 for standard paternity testing
• Legal testing (admissible in court): $300-$500
• Prenatal testing: $400-$2,000

Always use court-approved laboratories for testing intended for legal proceedings. Home testing kits aren’t admissible in court.

Can We Agree That the Biological Father Is the Legal Father?

Agreement helps but doesn’t always suffice. Most states require:

• Husband to formally disestablish paternity
• Biological father to establish paternity through court order or acknowledgment
• Court approval of arrangements
• Consideration of child’s best interests

Voluntary three-party agreement streamlines process but still requires legal formalization. Consult attorney to ensure proper procedures.

Key Takeaways

1. Marital presumption controls: The husband is presumed the legal father of any child born during marriage or within 300 days after divorce in most states—regardless of biological paternity.
   
2. State laws vary significantly: Texas, Arkansas, Missouri, and Arizona restrict divorce finalization during pregnancy; California, New York, Pennsylvania, and Washington allow it.
   
3. Time is critical: Strict deadlines apply for challenging paternity. Don’t wait until after divorce finalizes—raise issues immediately.
   
4. Legal paternity ≠ biological paternity: Child support obligations follow legal paternity, not genetic testing. Disestablishment procedures are required to terminate obligations.
   
5. Biological fathers face barriers: Establishing paternity when mother is/was married requires overcoming marital presumption through legal proceedings.
   
6. Courts prioritize child’s interests: Established parent-child relationships may be protected over biological truth, especially when child is older or would suffer harm from disruption.
   
7. DNA testing procedures matter: Use court-approved laboratories for legally admissible results. Timing, cost, and probability thresholds vary by state.
   
8. Final judgments create barriers: Failing to address paternity during divorce may preclude later challenges under res judicata principles.
   

Getting Legal Help

This article provides general information about pregnancy during divorce and paternity law. Laws vary significantly by state, and individual circumstances create unique legal issues. Consult a qualified family law attorney in your state for advice specific to your situation.

Essential next steps:

• Research your state’s specific paternity laws and timelines
• Consult attorney experienced in paternity and divorce matters
• Don’t delay—time limits are strict and unforgiving
• Document all relevant facts and communications
• Preserve evidence supporting your position

References:

• Alabama Code § 26-17-204 (Presumption of Paternity)
• California Family Code §§ 7540, 7611 (Paternity Presumptions)
• Texas Family Code § 160.204 (Presumption of Paternity)
• Louisiana Civil Code Articles 185-186 (Presumption of Paternity)
• Tennessee Code § 36-2-304 (Presumption of Parentage)
• Hawaii Revised Statutes § 584-4 (Presumption of Paternity)
• Florida Statutes § 742.18 (Disestablishment of Paternity)
• Mississippi Code § 93-9-10 (Disestablishment of Paternity)
• Washington Revised Code § 26.09.030(e) (Divorce During Pregnancy)
• B.C. v. C.P. & D.B., Pennsylvania Supreme Court (2024)
• Dreyer v. Greene, 871 S.W.2d 697 (Tex. 1993)
• Shondel J. v. Mark D., 7 N.Y. 3d 330 (2007)
• Wetta v. Wetta (Louisiana)

Additional Resources:

• California Department of Child Support Services: https://childsupport.ca.gov
• California Courts Self-Help Center: https://www.courts.ca.gov/selfhelp-parentage.htm
• Uniform Parentage Act (2002)
• State bar association family law resources
• Local child support enforcement agencies

Last Updated: December 2024

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws change, and this article may not reflect the most current legal developments. Always consult with a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.

About the Author

Sarah Klein, JD, is a former family law attorney with over a decade of courtroom and mediation experience. She has represented clients in divorce, custody cases, adoption, Alimony, and domestic violence cases across multiple U.S. jurisdictions.
At All About Lawyer, Sarah now uses her deep legal background to create easy-to-understand guides that help families navigate the legal system with clarity and confidence.
Every article is based on her real-world legal experience and reviewed to reflect current laws.
Read more about Sarah