Nelnet Lawsuit Your $35K Student Loan Bill Just Jumped to $2,000 Per Month, Nelnet Sued for Gross Miscalculation

A West Virginia woman couldn’t buy a house because Nelnet tripled her student loan payment overnight. Now Nelnet faces explosive class action lawsuits alleging the company miscalculated monthly payments, exposed 2.5 million borrowers’ data in a security breach, and misled students about federal loan protections. The Nelnet lawsuit cases reveal a pattern of alleged negligence that’s cost borrowers thousands in overcharges, denied mortgages, and identity theft risks—all while servicing $589.5 billion in student loans for 17.4 million Americans.

The Payment Miscalculation Scandal: “$2,000 a Month on a $35K Loan”

In June 2024, a bombshell class action lawsuit exposed what may be Nelnet’s most damaging alleged practice: grossly miscalculating borrowers’ monthly payment amounts under income-driven repayment plans.

The lawsuit details a West Virginia borrower enrolled in the SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) plan with approximately $35,000 in student loan debt and a gross monthly income of $5,833.32. Under SAVE rules, her payment should have been around $583 (10% of discretionary income).

Instead, Nelnet calculated her monthly payment as $1,969—more than triple what she actually owed.

The consequences were devastating. When she applied for a mortgage in January 2024, lenders denied her application because Nelnet reported to credit bureaus that she owed nearly $2,000 monthly. Her debt-to-income ratio exceeded the 50% limit required for mortgage approval—all based on Nelnet’s incorrect calculation.

Even after she filed detailed disputes showing the miscalculation, Nelnet continued verifying the incorrect information to credit reporting agencies while placing her in “administrative forbearance.”

Who’s Affected by Payment Miscalculations?

The class action seeks to represent all consumers with West Virginia addresses who had loans serviced by Nelnet and for whom Nelnet calculated monthly payments for income-based repayment plans. However, borrowers nationwide have reported similar issues.

The $2.5 Million Data Breach: Social Security Numbers Exposed

If payment miscalculations weren’t bad enough, Nelnet also faces consolidated class action litigation over a massive 2022 data breach that exposed the sensitive personal information of more than 2.5 million student loan borrowers.

What Happened?

In July 2022, unauthorized actors gained access to Nelnet’s systems—access that may have begun as early as June 2021. The compromised data included:

• Full names
• Physical addresses
• Email addresses
• Phone numbers
• Social Security numbers (unencrypted and unredacted)

Nelnet discovered the breach on July 21, 2022, and closed the unauthorized access on July 22. But the company didn’t notify the Department of Education until August 17—nearly a month later. Individual borrowers weren’t notified until August 26, 2022.

The Legal Claims

Twenty-three separate class action lawsuits were filed and consolidated into a single proceeding in Nebraska federal court in January 2023. The lawsuits allege:

• Negligence in failing to secure borrower data with encryption
• Breach of implied contract to protect sensitive information
• Invasion of privacy through unauthorized disclosure
• Violations of state consumer protection laws in multiple jurisdictions
• Unreasonable delay in notifying affected borrowers

According to court documents, “Hackers obtained their personally identifiable information because of its value in exploiting and stealing the identities of Plaintiff and similarly situated Class Members. The risks to these persons will remain for their respective lifetimes.”

The CARES Act Deception: “We’re Calling on Behalf of the Department of Education”

In September 2020, another Nelnet lawsuit alleged the company misled borrowers into believing their loans were federally backed when they were actually private loans ineligible for CARES Act relief.

The lead plaintiff, Kimberly Isner-Monticello—a licensed attorney in Florida—financed her law degree through Nelnet. Throughout her repayment period, she claims Nelnet representatives repeatedly told her the company was “calling on behalf of the United States Department of Education.”

When the CARES Act provided payment relief for federal student loans during the COVID-19 pandemic, Isner-Monticello learned her Nelnet loans weren’t actually federally backed. They were owned by “a bank, credit union or other lender”—making her ineligible for the payment pause.

The class action (Case No. 8:20-cv-02135-MSS-TGW in U.S. District Court, Middle District of Florida) seeks to represent borrowers with Nelnet account numbers starting with the letter “D” who received similar misleading communications.

The Original Sin: Income-Driven Repayment Plan Delays

The legal troubles actually began even earlier. In June 2020, borrowers from Illinois, Missouri, Texas, Colorado, and Michigan filed a comprehensive class action alleging Nelnet breached its servicing agreement with the federal government by mishandling Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) plan applications.

The case (Johanson v. Nelnet, Case No. 4:20-CV-03069, U.S. District Court, Nebraska) alleges Nelnet:

• Refused to accept monthly payments from borrowers
• Refused to process forbearance applications
• Involuntarily placed borrowers in forbearance by refusing to process IDR plan renewal requests
• Charged excessive interest and loan servicing fees
• Refused to restructure loans, significantly increasing debt over time

The court permitted plaintiffs to proceed with claims of breach of contract, negligent misrepresentation, and Illinois consumer deception practices. One borrower had her income-based repayment plan canceled before its stated deadline—before she could renew it—adding thousands of dollars to her loan balance.

Massachusetts Takes Action: $1.8 Million Settlement

While federal lawsuits proceeded, Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell secured a $1.8 million settlement with Nelnet in January 2024 for violations of state consumer protection law.

The settlement resolved allegations that Nelnet failed to appropriately communicate with borrowers about renewing Income-Driven Repayment plans between 2013 and 2017.

What Nelnet Did Wrong

Federal regulations require servicers to provide borrowers with at least 60 days’ notice of IDR recertification deadlines. They must also explain consequences of missing the deadline, including:

• The estimated amount the monthly payment will increase
• That unpaid interest may be capitalized (added to the loan balance)

Massachusetts investigators found that many of Nelnet’s communications failed to comply with these regulations, violating state consumer protection law.

Under the settlement, Nelnet agreed to:

• Pay $1.8 million to Massachusetts
• Comply with federal notice requirements for IDR plans
• Implement business practices making it easier for borrowers to maintain affordable income-driven payments

Understanding Your Rights as a Nelnet Borrower

If you have student loans serviced by Nelnet, here’s what you need to know:

Check Your Monthly Payment Calculation

If you’re enrolled in an income-driven repayment plan (SAVE, PAYE, IBR, or ICR), verify your monthly payment is correctly calculated:

1. Calculate 10% of your discretionary income (for SAVE plan)
2. Compare to what Nelnet is charging you
3. Check your credit report to see what payment amount Nelnet is reporting
4. If there’s a discrepancy, file a formal dispute with Nelnet in writing

Monitor Your Credit Report

Under federal law, you’re entitled to free credit reports from all three major bureaus (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion) annually at AnnualCreditReport.com. Look for:

• Incorrect payment amounts reported by Nelnet
• Accounts you don’t recognize (potential identity theft from data breach)
• Late payments you didn’t actually miss

Document Everything

Keep records of:

• All communications with Nelnet (emails, letters, phone call notes)
• Payment confirmations and bank statements
• IDR plan application and renewal submissions
• Any disputes you’ve filed

Know Where to Complain

If you’re experiencing problems with Nelnet, file complaints with:

• Federal Student Aid Ombudsman: StudentAid.gov/feedback-ombudsman
• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: ConsumerFinance.gov/complaint
• Your State Attorney General: Consumer protection division
• Better Business Bureau: BBB.org

What Happens If You’re Part of a Class Action?

For most class action lawsuits, you don’t need to do anything to be included when they’re initially filed. If you meet the class definition, you’re automatically part of the lawsuit unless you opt out.

However, if a settlement is reached, you’ll typically need to:

1. File a claim form within the deadline
2. Provide documentation proving you’re a class member
3. Wait for approval and settlement distribution

The payment miscalculation lawsuit and data breach litigation are still ongoing, so no settlements have been announced yet. Check ClassAction.org regularly for updates.

FAQs About Nelnet Lawsuits

Q: How do I know if Nelnet miscalculated my payment?

Log into your Nelnet account and review your payment history. Compare your required monthly payment to what you should owe based on your income and IDR plan rules. For SAVE plans, your payment should be approximately 5-10% of discretionary income (income above 225% of the federal poverty line). If your payment seems much higher, request a detailed calculation explanation from Nelnet.

Q: Was I affected by the 2022 Nelnet data breach?

If you had loans serviced by EdFinancial or the Oklahoma Student Loan Authority (OSLA) and should have received a notification letter in August 2022, your information was likely compromised. The breach affected approximately 2.5 million borrowers. Contact Nelnet at 1-888-486-4722 to confirm.

Q: Can I sue Nelnet individually if I’m part of the class action?

Generally, once a class action is certified, individual lawsuits covering the same claims are prohibited. However, you can opt out of the class action if you want to pursue your own lawsuit. This decision should be made with legal counsel, as class actions often provide compensation without individual legal costs.

Q: Will these lawsuits fix my credit report if Nelnet reported wrong information?

Not automatically. You’ll need to dispute inaccurate information with the credit bureaus directly. However, if the lawsuits result in settlements or court orders requiring Nelnet to correct credit reporting, that could help. In the meantime, file disputes with Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion, providing documentation of the correct payment amount.

Q: What consumer protection laws does Nelnet allegedly violate?

The lawsuits cite violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), state consumer protection statutes, the Higher Education Act’s servicer requirements, and federal regulations governing Income-Driven Repayment plans (34 CFR §685.209). Massachusetts’ settlement specifically addressed violations of state consumer protection law (M.G.L. c. 93A).

Q: Should I switch from Nelnet to another loan servicer?

Federal student loan borrowers generally cannot choose their servicer—the Department of Education assigns servicers. However, you can consolidate your loans through the Direct Loan Program, which may assign a different servicer. Before consolidating, understand the implications for your interest rates and any forgiveness programs you’re pursuing.

Q: How long do class action lawsuits typically take?

Student loan class actions often take 2-5 years to resolve, including appeals. The consolidated data breach litigation began in 2022 and is still in discovery phase as of 2025. The payment miscalculation lawsuit filed in June 2024 is in early stages. Subscribe to ClassAction.org for updates on settlement announcements and claim deadlines.

The Bigger Picture: Student Loan Servicing Crisis

Nelnet’s legal troubles reflect broader systemic problems in the student loan servicing industry. With $1.7 trillion in outstanding student debt affecting 43 million Americans, servicer mistakes have devastating consequences.

Industry-Wide Issues

Other major servicers face similar legal challenges:

• MOHELA has been criticized for processing delays affecting Public Service Loan Forgiveness
• Aidvantage faces complaints about customer service and payment processing
• EdFinancial was impacted by the same 2022 Nelnet data breach

The Sweet v. Cardona settlement (a separate case involving the Department of Education) has delivered relief to over 271,000 borrowers as of May 2025, with ongoing monitoring of servicers including Nelnet to ensure proper implementation.

Why Servicer Accountability Matters

Student loan servicers handle critical functions:

• Processing loan payments
• Managing income-driven repayment plan applications
• Determining eligibility for forgiveness programs
• Reporting payment history to credit bureaus

When servicers fail, borrowers face:

• Damaged credit scores preventing home purchases
• Incorrectly capitalized interest inflating balances
• Denied access to affordable payment options
• Years of additional repayment due to processing errors

Protecting Yourself: Action Steps for Nelnet Borrowers

Immediate Actions:

1. Review your account today at Nelnet.com or call 1-888-486-4722
2. Request a payment calculation breakdown if you’re on an IDR plan
3. Pull your credit reports at AnnualCreditReport.com
4. Enable account alerts for any changes to your loan
5. Screenshot important documents before they disappear from your account

Ongoing Monitoring:

• Check your account monthly for unexpected changes
• Set calendar reminders for IDR recertification deadlines (submit early!)
• Keep electronic and paper copies of all correspondence
• Review annual billing statements carefully
• Track total amount paid vs. principal reduction

If You Discover Problems:

• File written complaints with Nelnet, FSA Ombudsman, and CFPB
• Consult with a consumer protection attorney specializing in student loans
• Consider whether consumer law representation is appropriate
• Document all financial harm (denied credit, increased interest, fees)
• Join class action tracking services for settlement notifications

The Bottom Line: Your Student Loans Deserve Better

The multiple Nelnet lawsuits expose serious flaws in how America’s fourth-largest federal student loan servicer handles borrower accounts. From miscalculated payments derailing homeownership dreams to data breaches exposing millions to identity theft, the alleged failures have real-world consequences.

While these cases wind through the courts, borrowers must remain vigilant. Review your accounts regularly, verify calculations independently, and don’t assume your servicer is handling your loans correctly.

Student loan debt is overwhelming enough without servicer mistakes making it worse. These lawsuits represent borrowers fighting back—and potentially recovering compensation for the harm they’ve suffered.

Stay informed, document everything, and know your rights. Your financial future may depend on it.

Legal Disclaimer: This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The information provided is based on publicly available court documents, legal filings, and news reports. Class action lawsuits discussed are ongoing or in various stages of litigation. For specific legal guidance about your individual situation or student loan concerns, please consult with a qualified attorney. We are not affiliated with Nelnet, the Department of Education, or any parties involved in the litigation discussed.

Related Reading:

• Consumer Protection Attorney Who Handles Identity Theft Cases
• Consumer Law Attorney in Houston
• How Much Does a Debt Collection Lawyer Cost

Meta Description: Nelnet faces multiple class action lawsuits for miscalculating student loan payments, exposing 2.5M borrowers’ data, and misleading students about federal protections. Learn your rights.

About the Author

Sarah Klein, JD, is a licensed attorney and legal content strategist with over 12 years of experience across civil, criminal, family, and regulatory law. At All About Lawyer, she covers a wide range of legal topics — from high-profile lawsuits and courtroom stories to state traffic laws and everyday legal questions — all with a focus on accuracy, clarity, and public understanding.
Her writing blends real legal insight with plain-English explanations, helping readers stay informed and legally aware.
Read more about Sarah