Knix Period Underwear Lawsuit Update Controversy Over Toxic Chemicals In Menstrual Underwear

Menstrual underwear brands such as Thinx, Knix, and Diva have recently faced growing scrutiny and legal challenges concerning the potential presence of harmful chemicals, particularly per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), commonly known as “forever chemicals,” in their products. These chemicals, which are known for their persistence in the environment and the human body, have raised serious health concerns. This article delves into the ongoing legal dispute, the science behind PFAS, and what consumers should know when it comes to the safety of menstrual underwear.

What Are PFAS and Why Are They Concern?

PFAS are a class of human-made chemicals that are commonly used for their water, oil, and stain-repellent properties. These chemicals are found in a wide variety of products, including clothing, cosmetics, food packaging, and household items. Because they do not break down easily, PFAS have earned the nickname “forever chemicals” and have been linked to various health risks.

Health Risks of PFAS

Research has shown that exposure to high levels of PFAS may lead to significant health issues, including:

Cancer: Studies suggest that certain types of PFAS are associated with an increased risk of cancers such as kidney and testicular cancer.
Endocrine Disruption: PFAS can interfere with hormone levels, potentially affecting thyroid function and fertility.

Liver and Kidney Damage: Long-term exposure to PFAS may cause liver and kidney damage.
Reproductive and Developmental Issues: Exposure may impact fertility, pregnancy, and early childhood development.

According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), these chemicals are widely found in the bloodstreams of people and animals worldwide. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has found detectable levels of PFAS in nearly every American’s blood, signaling their widespread presence in the environment and consumer products. Source: CDC – PFAS

Legal Cases Against Menstrual Underwear Brands

Several lawsuits have been filed against prominent menstrual underwear companies, alleging the presence of PFAS in their products. These lawsuits are not just about consumer protection; they also raise questions about corporate responsibility, product safety, and legal accountability.

Knix and the Allegations of PFAS Contamination

In June 2022, Knix Wear Inc., a Canadian undergarment maker, filed a motion to dismiss a class-action lawsuit that accused its menstrual underwear of containing harmful PFAS. The plaintiffs claimed that Knix’s products were marketed as free of these chemicals, despite tests indicating the presence of fluorine, which can signal the presence of PFAS.

Knix, however, denied these allegations, arguing that the plaintiffs had not conducted independent investigations to verify their claims and were merely repeating unverified accusations from a “mom blog.” The company emphasized that it conducted thorough, third-party testing to ensure its products were safe and free of harmful chemicals.

In addition to demanding the dismissal of the lawsuit, Knix filed a Rule 11 sanctions motion under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, accusing the plaintiffs’ lawyers of filing a frivolous lawsuit without proper investigation. Source: CTV News – Knix Case

Knix Period Underwear Lawsuit Update Controversy Over Toxic Chemicals in Menstrual Underwear

Thinx and the $5 Million Settlement

In January 2023, Thinx, a U.S.-based brand, settled a class-action lawsuit for $5 million, which claimed the company misled consumers by advertising its products as free from PFAS. The lawsuit stemmed from third-party lab tests that found PFAS in some of Thinx’s products, despite the company’s claims to the contrary.

Thinx responded by denying the allegations, stating that PFAS were never part of the product design. The company also introduced a refund program for affected customers and pledged to continue testing its products for safety.

Key Questions:

Why Did Thinx Settle the Lawsuit?

Thinx settled to avoid prolonged litigation, despite denying any wrongdoing. The company agreed to compensate consumers who purchased their products between November 12, 2016, and November 28, 2022.

What Compensation Did Affected Consumers Receive?

Consumers who purchased Thinx underwear during this period could receive a refund of $7 per product (up to three items) if they provided proof of purchase, or $3.50 per product without proof of purchase. Source: Global News – Thinx Settlement

Diva’s Patent Infringement Lawsuit with Knix

In a separate legal struggle, Diva International Inc. was accused of infringing on Knix’s patents. Knix claimed that Diva, which had once sought to rebrand Knix’s underwear, began selling infringing products after their business proposal was rejected. The lawsuit, filed in Oregon, highlighted that Diva’s products violated three of Knix’s U.S. patents.

What Should Consumers Know About Menstrual Underwear Safety?

With the controversy surrounding PFAS, consumers are right to be concerned about the safety of menstrual underwear. Below are some key insights and guidance for individuals who need to make informed decisions about these products.

Testing for PFAS: What Companies Are Doing

Leading menstrual underwear companies, such as Knix, have taken proactive measures to ensure that their products are safe. Knix, for example, began routine testing for PFAS in January 2020. The company states on its website that it does not intentionally use PFAS in its products and works closely with third-party suppliers to avoid contamination. Knix regularly tests its fabrics for organic fluorine, a compound that may indicate PFAS, and posts the results online.

Similarly, Aisle, another Canadian company, claims that its menstrual products are free from detectable levels of PFAS, based on independent third-party testing conducted by SGS, a leading testing and inspection company.

Role of Independent Testing

Several companies have pledged transparency by conducting independent testing of their products. However, as the case of Thinx demonstrated, third-party testing results can vary, and it’s important for consumers to verify the integrity of these claims. Consumers should be cautious of brands that do not provide clear testing results or fail to disclose the testing process.

Is It Safe to Use Period Underwear?

For most consumers, the health risks associated with using period underwear that may contain trace amounts of PFAS are minimal. Experts like Jen Gunter, an obstetrician and gynecologist, suggest that the level of PFAS exposure from period underwear is likely low, especially when compared to other sources like food packaging or contaminated water.

That being said, if you are concerned about PFAS exposure, it’s advisable to choose brands that openly test their products and provide verifiable results. Additionally, washing period underwear before use can reduce the likelihood of chemical residue remaining on the fabric.

Legal and Regulatory Rules What Does the Law Say?

In the context of consumer protection, several legal frameworks govern the safety of products like menstrual underwear. In the U.S., the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) enforces truth-in-advertising laws, which require that companies provide accurate information about the safety and features of their products. Additionally, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has the authority to regulate PFAS chemicals under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA).

In Canada, the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA) regulates the use of hazardous substances, including PFAS. As of recent years, Canada has taken steps to ban certain types of PFAS to protect public health.

For consumers, these legal protections ensure that companies are held accountable for any deceptive claims about their products. However, ongoing litigation in the menstrual underwear industry highlights the need for greater transparency and more robust consumer protection. Source: EPA PFAS Regulation

FAQs

Does Knix Still Contain PFAS?

Knix has consistently denied that its products contain harmful levels of PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances). The company has undergone third-party testing and continues to emphasize that it is committed to producing safe, non-toxic menstrual underwear. Knix began testing for PFAS in January 2020 and has made its results available to consumers. As of the latest updates, the company claims that its products are free from PFAS, and it tests its materials for organic fluorine, a chemical marker commonly associated with PFAS.

However, some concerns have persisted due to the nature of these chemicals being difficult to detect at low levels, and there have been occasional reports of trace amounts of PFAS being found in the fabrics. As a result, consumers who are particularly concerned about PFAS may want to choose brands that provide certified organic, PFAS-free products and consider verifying the testing information available.

Why Do My Knix Underwear Smell So Bad?

The smell in your Knix underwear may stem from a few different factors:

Bacterial Build-Up: Like any fabric worn close to the body, menstrual underwear can develop an odor if not properly washed or dried. Bacteria can thrive in moist conditions, so it’s important to wash your Knix underwear after each use and let it air dry completely. Washing at higher temperatures (according to care instructions) can help eliminate odor.
Residual Detergents: Sometimes, if detergent isn’t thoroughly rinsed out, it can create a lingering smell. Make sure you’re using a detergent that doesn’t leave strong residues or fragrances, as this can contribute to unpleasant odors.

Moisture Retention: While Knix underwear is designed to be absorbent, moisture that isn’t properly absorbed or has remained too long in the fabric could lead to a smell. It’s a good practice to change out of them frequently, especially if you’re engaging in physical activity.

To help prevent smells, follow the washing instructions carefully and avoid fabric softeners, which can clog the fabric’s pores and affect its performance.

Are Knix and Thinx the Same Company?

No, Knix and Thinx are not the same company. They are separate, competing brands that both specialize in menstrual underwear.

Knix: Founded in 2013 in Canada, Knix is known for its leakproof and absorbent underwear designed for menstruation, incontinence, and postpartum use. The brand focuses on creating comfortable, everyday underwear and has expanded to include bras and loungewear. Knix has a strong focus on sustainability and transparency, regularly conducting third-party testing for product safety.
Thinx: Thinx was founded in 2013 in the United States and is widely recognized for pioneering the market for period underwear. Thinx also offers absorbent products for menstruation, and its line includes styles for different body types and absorbency needs. Thinx made headlines for a large settlement related to PFAS contamination allegations, which resulted in a class-action lawsuit.

Conclusion Should You Be Concerned?

While the controversy surrounding PFAS in menstrual underwear raises valid concerns, it is essential to consider the evidence and steps that brands are taking to ensure product safety. Consumers should remain informed, want out brands that prioritize transparency and third-party testing, and stay aware of ongoing legal developments in this area.

As the issue of PFAS in consumer products continues to evolve, legal actions and regulatory measures will play a critical role in shaping the future of product safety. In the meantime, consumers can mitigate their risk by choosing brands that have proven their commitment to safe, sustainable products.

Spread the love