How Does The New Real Estate Commission Law Work? What You Need To Know In 2025

In the U.S., new real estate commission laws aim to increase transparency and potentially change the way commissions are handled in real estate transactions. These laws address concerns about fairness, conflicts of interest, and consumer choice. Here’s how they work and what they typically involve:

1. Traditional Real Estate Commission Model in the U.S.

Historically:

Sellers pay the real estate commission (typically 5-6% of the sale price).
The total commission is split between the seller’s agent and the buyer’s agent (usually 50/50).
The cost of the buyer’s agent’s commission is baked into the sale price, meaning buyers indirectly pay for the services of their own agent.

This traditional setup has been criticized for:

Lack of transparency (buyers may not realize they’re indirectly paying for their agent’s services).
Limited flexibility for sellers to negotiate commission rates.
Potential conflicts of interest, as buyers’ agents may steer clients toward properties with higher commissions.

2. Key Changes Under New Real Estate Commission Laws

The new laws or rulings aim to reform how commissions are paid. While details vary by state or region, here are the key changes:

a. Buyers May Pay Their Agent Directly

Some new laws and industry reforms require buyers to pay their agent directly, rather than having their commission bundled into the sale price.
This change promotes transparency by making buyers more aware of the costs involved in hiring an agent.

b. Seller’s Obligation to Pay Buyer’s Agent Is Eliminated

In some cases, sellers are no longer required to pay the buyer’s agent’s commission, allowing them to negotiate lower fees.
This gives sellers more control over their expenses and reduces pressure to inflate property prices.

c. Transparency Requirements

Agents and brokerages must disclose more information about commission structures, including how commissions are divided and who pays them.
MLS (Multiple Listing Service) platforms may be required to show commission offers publicly, so buyers and sellers can make more informed decisions.

d. Negotiability of Commissions

New laws emphasize that commission rates are negotiable.
Buyers and sellers are encouraged to shop around for agents and negotiate fees that work for them.

e. Increased Competition

By allowing more flexibility in commission arrangements, these laws aim to encourage competition among real estate agents, potentially lowering costs for consumers.

How Does the New Real Estate Commission Law Work? What You Need to Know in 2025

3. Recent Developments Driving These Changes

a. Legal Challenges

In recent years, lawsuits have targeted major real estate trade organizations (e.g., the National Association of Realtors or NAR) for antitrust practices.
Plaintiffs argue that traditional commission structures harm consumers by inflating prices.

b. Federal and State-Level Legislation

Some states have passed or are considering laws requiring greater transparency in real estate transactions.
Federal regulators, like the Department of Justice (DOJ), are also investigating industry practices to ensure they comply with antitrust laws.

c. Settlements and Rulings

Recent legal settlements (e.g., NAR-related lawsuits) may result in significant changes to commission practices, such as requiring separate agreements for buyer agent compensation.

4. Pros and Cons of the New Laws

Pros

Transparency: Buyers and sellers better understand what they’re paying for.
Consumer Choice: Buyers and sellers have more freedom to negotiate commissions and choose agents based on value.
Lower Costs: Increased competition among agents may lead to reduced commission rates.

Cons

Additional Costs for Buyers: Buyers may have to pay their agent directly, which could strain affordability.
Impact on Agents: Agents working with buyers may face challenges in securing compensation if buyers are unwilling or unable to pay.
Market Transition: Adjusting to these new laws may create confusion or temporary disruption in the real estate market.

5. Example States Leading Change

Oregon and Colorado: These states have enacted legislation emphasizing commission transparency.
Illinois: Recently passed laws requiring agents to disclose commission agreements and relationships more clearly.
California: Exploring reforms to unbundle commission structures to improve fairness and reduce conflicts of interest.

6. What Does This Mean for Buyers, Sellers, and Agents?

For Buyers: Be prepared to pay your agent directly, potentially requiring upfront cash or financing assistance.
For Sellers: You may have more flexibility to negotiate commissions or opt not to cover the buyer’s agent’s fees.
For Agents: Adaptation is key—agents must be clear about their value proposition and competitive pricing to attract clients.

Spread the love