Gateway Church Settles Multiple Lawsuits Amidst Founder’s Abuse Allegations Alleging child Sex Assault, Harassment

Gateway Church, a prominent North Texas megachurch, has recently found itself at the center of a storm of legal and ethical controversies. The church has settled multiple lawsuits in recent months, dealing with allegations ranging from child sexual abuse to workplace discrimination. These settlements have come to light just as the church faces a major scandal involving its founder, Robert Morris.

Background on Gateway Church 2020 Lawsuit

Founded in 2000 by Robert Morris, Gateway Church has grown to become one of the largest congregations in the United States. Based in Southlake, Texas, the church boasts approximately 100,000 attendees across its nine campuses each weekend. Morris’s influence extended far beyond the local community, with his weekly program broadcasted live online to over 190 countries.

Recent Legal Settlements

In the months leading up to the public accusation against its founder, Gateway Church quietly settled two significant lawsuits:

1. April 2023 Settlement: Child Sexual Abuse Cover-Up Allegations

   This case, originally filed in Tarrant County in 2020, involved serious accusations against multiple church pastors. The lawsuit alleged that these church leaders covered up the sexual abuse of a child by a congregation member in March 2018. Furthermore, it claimed that pastors encouraged other church members to ostracize the child’s mother after she raised concerns.

   The lawsuit asserted that church leaders failed to inform law enforcement about the alleged abuse, despite being aware of it and having spoken with the accused church member. It also accused the church leadership of attempting to discredit the allegations.

   Gateway Church vehemently denied these accusations, stating that the incident did not occur on church property or during a church event. According to the church, the alleged abuse happened between two teenagers during a sleepover at a family home.

The church maintains that when a third teenager informed his mother (a Gateway Church staff member) about the incident, she reported it to the proper authorities within 48 hours.

   The church characterized the mother’s lawsuit as stemming from her anger over perceived delays in reporting. After the plaintiff went through six different attorneys, the church’s insurance company decided to settle to avoid further litigation expenses.

2. June 2023 Settlement: Workplace Discrimination and Harassment

   This case involved a former employee who alleged discrimination and sexual harassment by her superior, a Gateway Church pastor. The lawsuit, filed in 2023, painted a disturbing picture of the church’s workplace environment.

   According to the plaintiff, who began working at the church in 2018 after completing cancer treatment, her boss made derogatory remarks about her appearance and unwanted romantic advances. The lawsuit claimed that when she reported this behavior, she was merely told to avoid being alone with the pastor and was encouraged to apply for a more senior position.

   However, when she did apply for a higher role, she was allegedly told that while she was “more than qualified,” the church preferred to hire a man for the position because “our congregation responds better to men.” The plaintiff was forced to continue working with the pastor, who allegedly continued his inappropriate behavior.

   In a particularly troubling incident in 2021, the pastor allegedly questioned the legitimacy of the #MeToo movement, suggesting it was based on “false accusations.” The pastor was eventually terminated with two years of severance pay, but the plaintiff claims she was blamed for his departure and subsequently fired during a Zoom call.

Both cases were settled for undisclosed amounts, highlighting the church’s desire to resolve these matters quietly.

The Robert Morris Scandal

As these legal settlements were being finalized, Gateway Church was hit with a far more public and damaging controversy involving its founder, Robert Morris. In June 2023, Cindy Clemishire publicly accused Morris of sexually assaulting her starting in 1982 when she was just 12 years old. Morris, who was a traveling Evangelist in his early 20s at the time, had become close to Clemishire’s family.

These allegations, first published by The Wartburg Watch, a church watchdog blog, and later picked up by The Christian Post, claim that the abuse continued until 1987. Morris has partially acknowledged inappropriate behavior in his past. In a 2014 sermon, he admitted to being “sexually immoral” as a young man, and in a statement to the Christian Post, he confessed to “inappropriate sexual behavior” with a young woman, describing it as “kissing and petting and not intercourse.”

However, Morris’s admission falls far short of the allegations made by Clemishire. Church elders stated that Morris had disclosed an extramarital affair to them, but not the alleged abuse of a 12-year-old.

Fallout and Church Response

The repercussions of these allegations have been significant:

1. On June 18, 2023, Robert Morris resigned from his position as senior pastor at Gateway Church.

2. Clemishire expressed mixed feelings about Morris’s resignation, stating that while she was grateful he was no longer pastor, she believed he should have been terminated rather than allowed to resign.

3. On June 23, protesters gathered outside the church as elder Tra Willbanks addressed the congregation, expressing shock and offering compassion to Clemishire.

4. On June 28, four members of the Gateway Church Board of Elders, including Robert Morris’s son, were placed on temporary leaves of absence pending an investigation by an outside legal team.

Broader Implications

These events at Gateway Church highlight several critical issues facing religious institutions today:

1. Child Protection in Religious Settings

 The allegations against Morris and the earlier lawsuit settlement underscore the vital importance of robust child protection policies in churches and other organizations working with young people.

2. Accountability in Leadership

 The case raises questions about how religious leaders are held accountable for their actions, both past and present.

3. Workplace Culture in Religious Organizations

 The discrimination and harassment lawsuit points to potential systemic issues in how some churches manage their employees and handle complaints.

4. Transparency and Crisis Management

 The church’s handling of these various controversies will likely be scrutinized as an example of how large religious organizations navigate complex legal and ethical challenges.

5. Long-term Impact on Faith Communities

Such incidents can have profound effects on the faith and trust of congregants, necessitating careful handling and transparent communication.

Conclusion

The multiple settlements and ongoing controversy surrounding Gateway Church serve as a stark reminder of the complex challenges facing modern religious institutions. As one of the largest congregations in the nation, Gateway Church’s handling of these issues will likely have far-reaching implications for how other churches approach similar situations.

These events underscore the need for religious organizations to prioritize transparency, accountability, and the protection of vulnerable individuals within their communities. They also highlight the importance of robust policies and procedures for handling allegations of misconduct, whether they involve church leaders or members of the congregation.

As Gateway Church navigates this turbulent period, the eyes of both the religious community and the wider public will be watching closely. The church’s response to these challenges could set important precedents for how large religious organizations handle similar crises in the future.

FAQs