Can You Sue Comcast For Identity Theft? Complete Legal Guide

Identity theft tied to major corporate data breaches is on the rise, and Comcast (Xfinity) has become one of the most notable examples. With millions of customer accounts compromised in recent years due to cyberattacks and internal failures, many affected individuals are wondering: Can I sue Comcast for identity theft? The answer is yes, under the right circumstances. This article offers a complete roadmap—from understanding your rights and Comcast’s internal process to filing lawsuits or arbitration.

Quick Summary

Yes, you can sue Comcast for identity theft if your data was compromised due to their negligence or breach of contract.
Legal routes include class action lawsuits, individual litigation, or arbitration.
Affected customers may recover compensatory, statutory, and even punitive damages.
Federal and state laws like the Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence Act (ITADA) and California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) provide legal grounds for action.
Immediate steps include filing Comcast’s affidavit, a police report, and an FTC complaint.

What Is Identity Theft and Why Comcast May Be Liable

Identity theft occurs when someone wrongfully uses another person’s data—such as a Social Security number, name, or credit details—to commit fraud. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1028, companies can be held liable for failing to protect personal data.

In Comcast’s case, several breaches exposed sensitive data, and lawsuits argue the company:

Failed to encrypt or secure personal information
Ignored known vulnerabilities
Didn’t properly vet or monitor third-party vendors
Breached contractual promises regarding customer data security

Comcast Data Breaches: A History of Failures

1. October 2023 – Citrix Vulnerability Breach

Affected 36 million Xfinity accounts
Data exposed: usernames, hashed passwords, contact info, dates of birth, partial Social Security numbers, security questions
Lawsuits filed in Pennsylvania federal court for failure to apply security patches (CVE-2023-4966)

2. February 2024 – FBCS Ransomware Attack

A former Comcast collections vendor (FBCS) leaked data of 237,703 customers
Exposed full Social Security numbers, addresses, account info
Comcast ended its FBCS contract in 2020 but failed to ensure data deletion

3. 2015 – Unlisted Numbers Leak

75,000 unlisted phone numbers leaked due to a process error
Victims included domestic violence survivors and law enforcement officers
Comcast paid a $33 million settlement, including $100 per customer

Can You Sue Comcast for Identity Theft? Complete Legal Guide

Legal Grounds to Sue Comcast

1. Negligence

Comcast has a legal duty to secure personal data. Failing to patch known software flaws or protect user data adequately could be deemed gross negligence.

2. Breach of Contract

Comcast’s user agreements typically promise data security. A breach that violates those promises could be the basis for a lawsuit.

3. Violations of State and Federal Laws

CCPA (California): Statutory damages of $100–$750 per incident
New York SHIELD Act: Broader breach-notification and enforcement powers
FCRA & ITADA (Federal): Additional remedies for identity-theft victims

4. Unjust Enrichment

Lawsuits argue Comcast collected service fees while neglecting cybersecurity, thereby profiting at customers’ expense.

What Compensation Can You Receive?

Out-of-pocket losses: Reimbursement for credit monitoring, fraud resolution, legal fees
Statutory damages: Up to $750 per incident under state law
Punitive damages: In cases of willful misconduct
Injunctive relief: Court orders forcing Comcast to improve its security
Attorney’s fees: Recoverable under certain state/federal laws

Step-by-Step: How to Sue Comcast for Identity Theft

1. Start with Comcast’s Internal Process

Submit the Identity Theft Victim’s Complaint and Affidavit Form:

Include government ID, utility bills, lease agreements, and fraud details
Email: [email protected]
Comcast must respond within 2 business days; resolution may take up to 30 days
While under review, collections are paused and credit bureaus are notified

2. File a Police Report and FTC Affidavit

Create a federal record of identity theft via IdentityTheft.gov
File a local police report to strengthen your claim in court or arbitration

3. Evaluate Legal Options

Class Action Lawsuits:

Join existing lawsuits (e.g., Milberg Coleman Bryson, Lynch Carpenter LLP)
Requirements: breach notification, proof of compromise

Individual Lawsuit:

Recommended for victims with unique damages (e.g., credit loss, mental distress)
Collect:
- Credit reports
- Comcast communication
- Police report
- FTC affidavit

Arbitration:

Comcast includes mandatory arbitration clauses in its contracts
To avoid arbitration, you must have opted out within 30 days of signing
You can still sue in small claims court in some states

Legal Tips & Evidence Checklist

Evidence to Gather:

Breach notification letters
Fraudulent account entries (credit reports)
Bank statements with unauthorized transactions
Copies of all affidavits and police reports
Comcast claim emails and responses

Venue Choice:

Federal court: If invoking federal statutes (e.g., ITADA)
State court: For negligence and breach of contract

Common Legal Claims:

Negligence
Breach of contract
Identity fraud under FCRA
Violations of CCPA or state laws

Statutes of Limitations

Federal claims (e.g., ID theft): 5 years from the offense under 18 U.S.C. § 3282
State tort claims: Typically 2–3 years from the date you discover the fraud

Precedent Cases

ChoicePoint (2004): Set national precedent for third-party data breach liability
O’Neil v. Comcast: Comcast compelled arbitration—highlighting the need to opt out early

Preventative Measures You Should Take

Place credit freezes with Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion
Set up fraud alerts with your bank and creditors
Purchase identity-theft insurance
Regularly monitor accounts and use two-factor authentication

FAQs

What if I didn’t opt out of Comcast’s arbitration clause?

You may still file a small claims case in some jurisdictions. Arbitration remains an option, though potentially less favorable.

Is class action better than an individual lawsuit?

If your losses are minimal and match the class criteria, class action is easier. But individual lawsuits may offer larger compensation.

How long does resolution take?

Comcast’s internal claims: ~30 days. Litigation/arbitration: 6–18 months depending on the case.

Final Thoughts: Should You Sue Comcast?

If your identity was stolen due to Comcast’s negligence, you have valid legal grounds to seek justice. Whether through class action, arbitration, or civil court, victims have recourse under both federal and state law.

The most important step is to act quickly, build thorough documentation, and understand your legal rights. With the right legal support, not only can you pursue compensation—you can also help push for better data security at one of America’s largest internet providers.

Need Legal Help?

Consider contacting:

Milberg Coleman Bryson Phillips Grossman
Lynch Carpenter LLP
Or check for active cases at ClassAction.org

Spread the love

Table of Contents