BMW Transfer Case Class Action, $13,000 Defect Lawsuit Claims xDrive Models Jerk and Shudder—Company Knew Since 2020
A BMW transfer case class action lawsuit filed in December 2025 claims that 2019-2025 xDrive models contain defective transfer cases causing dangerous jerking and shuddering, with replacement costs reaching $13,000. The lawsuit alleges BMW knew about the factory-filled fluid defect since 2020 through internal service bulletins but continued selling vehicles without warning buyers, violating the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and state consumer protection laws. No settlement has been reached yet.
You’re making a slow turn into a parking spot. Suddenly, your BMW jerks. You accelerate from a stoplight, and the car shudders like it’s about to stall. It happens again during low-speed maneuvers—a disconcerting lurch that makes your “Ultimate Driving Machine” feel broken.
Welcome to the BMW transfer case defect at the center of a growing class action lawsuit affecting hundreds of thousands of vehicles. According to the complaint filed in New Jersey federal court, BMW has known about this transfer case problem since at least May 2020—yet continued selling vehicles with defective “lifetime” fluid that doesn’t actually meet BMW’s own specifications.
Now BMW owners are stuck with repair bills between $7,000 and $13,000 to replace an all-wheel-drive component that should never fail this early.
What the BMW Transfer Case Class Action Lawsuit Claims
Four BMW owners—Joseph Sangenito, Zhargal Dampilon, Richard Grad, and Kevin Finley—filed the class action lawsuit in New Jersey federal court on December 2, 2025. An amended complaint followed on December 26, 2025.
Their claim is straightforward but damaging: BMW sold tens of thousands of luxury vehicles with a manufacturing defect in the xDrive transfer case, failed to disclose the problem to consumers, and refuses to cover repairs once the original warranty expires—even though BMW knew the factory-filled fluid was defective. This BMW transfer case class action seeks to hold the automaker accountable for these alleged practices.
The transfer case is the heart of BMW’s xDrive all-wheel-drive system. It distributes power between the front and rear wheels to maintain traction and stability. When it fails, your BMW can’t properly send torque where it’s needed, causing jerking, shuddering, and unpredictable handling.
According to the lawsuit, BMW filled these transfer cases at the factory with fluid that “does not meet BMW specifications.” The company advertised this fluid as “lifetime-filled,” meaning owners would never need to service it. But that fluid allegedly breaks down prematurely, causing the clutch system inside the transfer case to wear out and fail.
BMW’s Own Service Bulletin Proves They Knew
Here’s the smoking gun: In May 2020, BMW issued Service Industry Bulletin (SIB) 27-02-20 titled “Jerking or Shuddering From The Driveline (XDrive Transfer Case ATX13-X).”
The bulletin told dealerships that owners were complaining about:
- Jerking or shuddering during cornering or accelerating from low speeds
- Problems driving with low to medium loads
- No warning lights or messages (meaning owners had no idea what was wrong)
BMW’s bulletin explicitly stated the problem could be caused by “factory-filled transfer case oil does not meet BMW specifications.”
In March 2025—five years after first acknowledging the problem—BMW updated SIB 27-02-20 to add even more affected models. The lawsuit argues this proves BMW knew the defect was widespread and getting worse, yet still didn’t warn consumers or issue a recall.
Which BMW Models Are Affected
The lawsuit includes virtually every 2019-2025 BMW equipped with the xDrive all-wheel-drive system. That means:
SUVs:
- X3 (G01)
- X4 (G02)
- X5 (G05)
- X6 (G06)
- X7 (G07)
Sedans, Coupes, and Gran Turismos:
- 2 Series
- 3 Series (G20)
- 4 Series
- 5 Series (G30)
- 7 Series (G12)
- 8 Series (G14, G15, G16)
- 640i xDrive Gran Turismo (G32)
M Series models are excluded from the lawsuit. Those use different transfer cases.
If you own or lease any xDrive BMW from model years 2019 through 2025 (except M models), your vehicle likely has the allegedly defective transfer case.
The Real-World Cost of BMW’s Defect
BMW dealerships follow a specific repair protocol when transfer case problems appear:
Step 1: Transfer Case Fluid Change – Cost: $250 to $1,300
Dealers first replace the defective factory-filled fluid with the correct specification fluid. BMW covers this under the New Vehicle Limited Warranty. But if your warranty expired? You pay out of pocket.
Here’s the problem: The fluid change is often just a temporary fix. The damage may already be done.
Step 2: Transfer Case Replacement – Cost: $7,000 to $13,000
When the fluid change doesn’t solve the shuddering and jerking—or the problem returns months later—the entire transfer case must be replaced. This is a major repair involving removing the transmission cross-member and replacing the entire assembly.
BMW covers this under the New Vehicle Limited Warranty too. But there’s a catch the lawsuit highlights: BMW does NOT cover transfer case repairs under Certified Pre-Owned warranties or Extended Service Contracts, even though the transfer case itself isn’t explicitly excluded from coverage.
So if you bought a CPO BMW expecting factory-level protection, or you purchased an extended warranty for peace of mind, you’re still stuck paying thousands to fix a defect BMW allegedly knew about before you even bought the car.
What BMW Says (And Doesn’t Say)
BMW has not publicly responded to the lawsuit yet. The company typically denies all allegations in class action complaints and claims it acted appropriately.
What BMW can’t deny:
- SIB 27-02-20 exists and acknowledges the problem
- BMW updated the bulletin in March 2025 to include more models
- BMW’s own technical documentation admits the factory-filled fluid doesn’t meet specifications
- Thousands of BMW owners report identical symptoms across different models and years
The Legal Claims Against BMW
The lawsuit alleges BMW violated multiple consumer protection laws:
Fraudulent Concealment – BMW allegedly knew about the defect but hid it from consumers and continued selling affected vehicles without disclosure.
Breach of Warranty – BMW’s promises about vehicle quality, durability, and “lifetime-filled” fluid were allegedly false.
Violation of the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act – Federal law requires manufacturers to honor implied warranties. The lawsuit claims BMW failed to repair defects within a reasonable time or provide adequate remedies.
State Consumer Protection Statutes – BMW allegedly engaged in deceptive practices by selling vehicles with known defects without disclosure.
Unjust Enrichment – BMW profited from selling defective vehicles and forcing owners to pay for repairs that should have been covered or prevented.
Diminished Vehicle Value – The lawsuit claims BMW vehicles lost value the moment they were sold because they contained undisclosed defects. If you tried to trade in or sell your BMW, the transfer case issue likely affected its resale value.
What You Should Do If You Own an Affected BMW
This lawsuit is in its earliest stages. There’s no settlement, no claim form, and no deadline yet. But if you own a 2019-2025 xDrive BMW, here’s what you should know:
Document Everything
Keep detailed records of:
- Transfer case symptoms (jerking, shuddering, when it occurs)
- Dates and mileage when symptoms appeared
- All repair orders and invoices related to transfer case issues
- Communications with BMW dealerships about the problem
- Whether BMW covered repairs or you paid out of pocket
Don’t Ignore the Symptoms
If your BMW jerks or shudders during low-speed turns, acceleration, or cornering, get it diagnosed immediately. The longer you drive with a failing transfer case, the more damage occurs.
Know Your Warranty Status
Check whether you’re still covered under:
- BMW New Vehicle Limited Warranty (typically 4 years/50,000 miles)
- Certified Pre-Owned warranty
- Extended Service Contract
The lawsuit alleges BMW covers fluid changes and transfer case replacements under the New Vehicle warranty but not under CPO or extended warranties—a distinction that could cost you thousands.
Consider Joining the Lawsuit
The law firms representing the plaintiffs are:
- Carella, Byrne, Cecchi, Brody & Agnello, P.C.
- Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein, LLP (lieffcabraser.com/defect/bmw-transfer-case)
- Heber Han, P.C. (heberhan.com/bmw-transfer-case-investigation)
These firms are actively seeking BMW owners affected by transfer case defects. You can contact them through their websites to learn about your legal rights. There’s no fee or obligation to inquire.
File a NHTSA Complaint
Report your transfer case problems to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration at www.nhtsa.gov/report-a-safety-problem. Consumer complaints help regulators decide whether to open formal investigations or order recalls.
Why This BMW Transfer Case Class Action Matters Beyond BMW
This isn’t BMW’s first rodeo with class action lawsuits over alleged defects:
Timing Chain Defects (2012-2015 N20/N26 engines) – BMW settled claims that timing chains and oil pump drive chains failed prematurely, causing sudden engine failure.
Diesel Emissions “Defeat Devices” (2009-2013 X5 xDrive35d, 2009-2011 335d) – BMW paid $6 million to settle allegations it used software to cheat emissions tests. That settlement just distributed final payments in May 2025.
Front Cupholder Liquid Spillage (2019-2022 X5/X6/X7) – BMW settled claims that spilled liquids in cupholders seeped onto electrical components, causing SRS warning light illuminations.
The pattern the lawsuit alleges: BMW discovers a defect through internal testing or customer complaints, issues a service bulletin to dealerships, but doesn’t warn consumers or issue recalls—leaving owners to discover problems only after warranties expire.
What Happens Next
The case is Sangenito, et al. v. BMW of North America, LLC, et al., Case No. 2:25-cv-17858 in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey.
Expected timeline:
- Early 2026 – BMW will likely file a motion to dismiss the lawsuit
- Spring/Summer 2026 – Court rules on dismissal motion
- 2026-2027 – If the case survives dismissal, discovery begins (document exchanges, depositions)
- 2027-2028 – Class certification hearing (court decides if it can represent all affected BMW owners)
- 2028 or later – Settlement negotiations or trial
Class action lawsuits typically take 2-4 years from filing to resolution. Don’t expect quick answers.
The Broader Questions This Raises
If the allegations are true, why didn’t BMW recall the vehicles and fix the defect for free?
Federal law requires manufacturers to recall vehicles with safety-related defects. Transfer case failures could arguably affect vehicle stability and control, especially during emergency maneuvers or inclement weather.
But recalls are expensive and embarrassing. The lawsuit alleges BMW chose to handle the problem quietly through a service bulletin—covering repairs under warranty when forced to, but making owners outside warranty pay the full cost.
That’s exactly the kind of corporate behavior consumer protection laws are designed to punish.
Your BMW Isn’t Just a Car—It’s a $60,000+ Promise
People buy BMWs expecting German engineering excellence, legendary reliability, and luxury that lasts. You don’t buy a $70,000 SUV expecting a $13,000 drivetrain repair after 40,000 miles.
The transfer case should last the life of the vehicle. The factory-filled fluid should actually meet BMW’s specifications. And if BMW discovered a widespread defect, they should have recalled the vehicles and fixed them—not buried the issue in service bulletins while continuing to profit from new sales.
That’s what this lawsuit is really about: holding a luxury automaker accountable for allegedly choosing profits over customer protection.
If your BMW jerks, shudders, or doesn’t feel right during low-speed driving, don’t ignore it. And don’t let BMW convince you it’s “normal” or “within specifications.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a BMW transfer case settlement yet?
No. The BMW transfer case class action lawsuit was just filed in December 2025. There’s no settlement, no claim form, and no payout yet. The case is still in its earliest litigation stages.
How do I know if my BMW has the defective transfer case?
If you own a 2019-2025 BMW with xDrive all-wheel drive (excluding M Series models) and experience jerking or shuddering during low-speed turns, acceleration, or cornering, your transfer case may be affected.
Will BMW fix my transfer case for free?
BMW appears to cover fluid changes and transfer case replacements under the New Vehicle Limited Warranty. But according to the lawsuit, BMW does NOT cover these repairs under Certified Pre-Owned or Extended Service Contract warranties—even though the transfer case isn’t explicitly excluded.
How much does a transfer case replacement cost?
Transfer case fluid changes cost $250-$1,300. Full transfer case replacement costs $7,000-$13,000.
Should I get my transfer case fixed even if I don’t notice problems yet?
If you’re experiencing symptoms, yes—get it diagnosed immediately. Continuing to drive with a failing transfer case can cause more damage. If you have no symptoms, monitor for jerking or shuddering and address it promptly if it occurs.
Can I join the BMW transfer case class action lawsuit?
The lawsuit seeks class certification, meaning it would represent all affected BMW owners automatically. You can contact the plaintiff’s law firms (Lieff Cabraser, Heber Han, Carella Byrne) to inquire about your situation and potentially participate in the BMW transfer case litigation.
What if I already paid for a transfer case repair out of pocket?
Keep all documentation. If the lawsuit results in a settlement, you may be able to claim reimbursement for past out-of-pocket repairs. Document your expenses now.
Will BMW recall these vehicles?
No recall has been announced. The lawsuit is attempting to force accountability through the legal system instead.
What symptoms indicate a failing transfer case?
Jerking or shuddering during low-speed turns, acceleration from stops, cornering, or driving with light to medium loads. No warning lights typically appear.
Are M Series BMWs affected?
No. M Series models use different transfer cases and are excluded from the lawsuit.
How long does the lawsuit take?
Class action lawsuits typically take 2-4 years from filing to resolution, whether through settlement or trial.
Essential Resources:
- Lieff Cabraser BMW Transfer Case Investigation – Plaintiff’s law firm seeking affected owners
- Heber Han BMW Transfer Case Investigation – Another plaintiff’s law firm
- NHTSA Complaint Portal – Report safety and defect issues
- FTC Consumer Protection – Learn about your consumer rights
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult with a qualified attorney about your specific situation.
About the Author
Sarah Klein, JD, is a licensed attorney and legal content strategist with over 12 years of experience across civil, criminal, family, and regulatory law. At All About Lawyer, she covers a wide range of legal topics — from high-profile lawsuits and courtroom stories to state traffic laws and everyday legal questions — all with a focus on accuracy, clarity, and public understanding.
Her writing blends real legal insight with plain-English explanations, helping readers stay informed and legally aware.
Read more about Sarah