Keurig McCafé K-Cup Recall 2026, Labeling Mix-Up, Health Risks, and How to Get a Refund
If you bought McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods from Amazon, check your pantry right now. On January 23, 2026, the FDA classified Keurig Dr Pepper’s voluntary recall of 80,640 pods as Class II — meaning the mislabeled product may cause temporary health issues for caffeine-sensitive consumers. The pods labeled “decaf” might actually contain regular caffeinated coffee.
Why Keurig Recalled McCafé Decaf K-Cup Pods
Keurig Dr Pepper initiated a voluntary recall on December 6, 2025, after discovering a labeling error affecting nearly 1,000 cartons of McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods. The problem isn’t contamination — it’s mislabeling.
Some pods marked as “decaf” may contain regular caffeinated coffee. For most people, accidentally drinking caffeinated coffee is just an inconvenience. But for pregnant women, people with heart conditions, or anyone limiting caffeine for medical reasons, unexpected caffeine exposure can trigger serious symptoms.
The FDA categorized this as a Class II recall, which applies when a product “may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences.”
Which McCafé K-Cup Pods Are Recalled
Only one specific batch is affected. Here’s how to identify recalled products:
Product: McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods
Size: 84-count carton (29 ounces / 823 grams)
UPC Code: 043000073438
Best-By Date: November 17, 2026
Batch Number: 5101564894
Material Number: 5000358463
ASIN: B07GCNDL91
These cartons were sold exclusively through Amazon and distributed only in California, Indiana, and Nevada between 2024 and December 2025.
If your K-Cup carton matches these identifiers, stop using the pods immediately.
Health Risks From Mislabeled Caffeine Products
The coffee itself isn’t unsafe to drink — but if you’re avoiding caffeine, accidental exposure can cause real problems.
Symptoms of unexpected caffeine consumption include racing heart, increased blood pressure, heart palpitations, rapid breathing, anxiety, insomnia, jitters, nausea, and vomiting. People with caffeine sensitivity, heart conditions, pregnancy, or those taking certain medications face the highest risk.
According to the FDA, no illnesses have been reported as of January 2026. But that doesn’t eliminate the risk — it means affected consumers need to act now before exposure happens.
What Keurig Is Doing About the Recall
Keurig Dr Pepper says all affected consumers were notified directly by the retailer in mid-December 2025 and provided with replacement product instructions. All remaining recalled inventory has been returned from the retailer.
A Keurig spokesperson confirmed: “In cooperation with the FDA, we initiated a voluntary recall of a limited number of 84-count boxes of McCafé Premium Roast Decaf coffee K-Cup pods, sold through a single retail partner, as the coffee may contain regular caffeinated coffee.”
The company maintains its commitment to safety and quality standards, and has removed all impacted products from sale.
How to Get a Refund or Replacement for Recalled K-Cups
If you purchased recalled McCafé K-Cup pods, follow these steps:
Step 1: Verify your product matches the recall identifiers (UPC 043000073438, best-by date November 17, 2026, batch number 5101564894).
Step 2: Contact Keurig Consumer Care at (866) 901-2739 to request a refund or replacement. You can also return the product to your place of purchase (Amazon) for a full refund.
Step 3: Dispose of the recalled pods by throwing them away. Do not use them.
You do not need a receipt to request a refund through Keurig Consumer Care, but having your order confirmation from Amazon may speed up the process.
What You Must Know About Product Recalls and Consumer Rights
Hidden Consumer Protections Most People Miss
Federal law requires manufacturers to notify consumers about product recalls and offer remedies at no cost. Under the Consumer Product Safety Act, companies must report known defects to the FDA or CPSC within 24 hours of discovery.
You have the right to a full refund or replacement for any recalled product — even without a receipt in many cases. If you experienced health issues from using a recalled product, you may have additional legal options beyond the standard recall remedy.
Similar bacterial contamination recalls, like the Pine Sol Class Action Lawsuit settlement, resulted in millions in compensation for affected consumers.
Common Misconceptions About the Keurig Recall
Myth: “Class II recalls aren’t serious.”
Reality: Class II means the product may cause temporary health issues — which can still be severe for vulnerable populations.
Myth: “If I haven’t had symptoms, the product is safe.”
Reality: Symptoms depend on your individual caffeine sensitivity and health status. Even if you haven’t noticed problems, you should still return recalled products.
Myth: “I can’t get a refund without proof of purchase.”
Reality: Keurig is offering refunds through Consumer Care even without receipts. Contact them directly at (866) 901-2739.
2026 Product Safety Updates
Product recalls involving mislabeling and contamination have increased significantly in 2025-2026. Recent high-profile cases include the Angry Orange Enzyme Stain Remover Recall affecting 1.5 million bottles due to bacterial contamination.
The FDA is increasing scrutiny on labeling accuracy, especially for products marketed to specific dietary or health needs like decaf coffee.
What to Do Next If You Have Recalled K-Cups
Check Your Product Right Now
Look at the bottom of your McCafé K-Cup carton. If the UPC is 043000073438 and the best-by date is November 17, 2026, you have a recalled product.
Don’t wait — even if you’ve already used some pods without noticing issues, the remaining pods still pose a risk.
Contact Keurig for Refund or Replacement
Call Keurig Consumer Care at (866) 901-2739 (Monday–Friday, business hours) or contact Amazon customer service if you purchased through their platform.
Keurig will provide either a full refund or replacement product at no cost to you. The process is straightforward and does not require proof of purchase in most cases.
Report Any Health Issues
If you consumed the recalled product and experienced adverse health effects, report it to the FDA’s MedWatch program at 1-800-FDA-1088 or online at SaferProducts.gov.
Document your symptoms, keep medical records, and note the product details. If your symptoms were severe or required medical treatment, consult a personal injury attorney about potential claims separate from the recall.
FAQs About the Keurig McCafé K-Cup Recall
Which Keurig products are included in the recall?
Only McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods in 84-count cartons with UPC 043000073438, best-by date November 17, 2026, and batch number 5101564894 are recalled. No other Keurig or McCafé products are affected.
What are the health risks of drinking the recalled K-Cups?
The main risk is unexpected caffeine exposure for people who are avoiding caffeine. This can cause racing heart, high blood pressure, anxiety, insomnia, and other caffeine-related symptoms — especially in pregnant women, people with heart conditions, or those with caffeine sensitivity.
Can I get a refund without a receipt?
Yes. Keurig Consumer Care is processing refunds and replacements even without proof of purchase. Call (866) 901-2739 with your product details, or return the product to Amazon for a full refund.
When was the Keurig McCafé K-Cup recall announced?
Keurig Dr Pepper initiated the voluntary recall on December 6, 2025. The FDA classified it as Class II on January 23, 2026. Affected consumers were notified by the retailer (Amazon) in mid-December 2025.
How much is the refund or compensation for recalled K-Cups?
Keurig is offering a full refund for the purchase price or free replacement product. There is no class action lawsuit or settlement associated with this recall as of January 2026. Refunds are processed directly through Keurig Consumer Care or Amazon.
Where were the recalled McCafé K-Cups sold?
The recalled products were sold exclusively through Amazon and distributed only in California, Indiana, and Nevada. If you purchased these products in other states, they are not part of the recall.
Is there a lawsuit for the Keurig McCafé K-Cup recall?
As of January 2026, there is no active class action lawsuit or settlement related to this specific recall. However, product liability attorneys may be monitoring the situation for potential claims if consumers report health injuries. Previous Keurig recalls have resulted in settlements — the K-Supreme coffee maker defect settlement paid up to $250 per claimant in 2025.
Last Updated: Feb 5, 2026
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. Consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your situation.
If you bought McCafé decaf K-Cups from Amazon between 2024 and December 2025, check your carton today and contact Keurig for your refund.
Stay informed, stay protected. — AllAboutLawyer.com
About the Author
Sarah Klein, JD, is a licensed attorney and legal content strategist with over 12 years of experience across civil, criminal, family, and regulatory law. At All About Lawyer, she covers a wide range of legal topics — from high-profile lawsuits and courtroom stories to state traffic laws and everyday legal questions — all with a focus on accuracy, clarity, and public understanding.
Her writing blends real legal insight with plain-English explanations, helping readers stay informed and legally aware.
Read more about Sarah